In Norway (and I guess most of Europe) the manufacturer's warranty is often useless for lots of products, as the state mandated protection is much stronger. I don't care if a headset I buy comes with 1 year warranty, because the law gives me 5 years.
And I think it's a good thing environmentally. Because a consumer cannot really know how durable a product is, so producers try to lower prices by reducing quality. Which makes it so that one has to buy new stuff more often, leading to lots of waste. But these laws solves that, the cost of a bad quality product cannot be hidden and passed on to the consumer.
Re:Lemon Law
by 404mm on Monday July 05, 2021 @09:51AM
(#27737971)
Coming from Europe, this is one of things I really dislike in the US. Products don’t have to have a warranty by law. You can find lots of subpar merchandise with 90d or even 14d warranty. And another issue, you have to deal with the manufacturer with warranty claims after some period (typically 2weeks, again, may differ).
Oh and a favorite trick is to have a mandatory warranty registration within X days from purchase and/or pay shipping one or two ways (which is easily $20 each way, depending on size and carrier)
Re:Lemon Law
by Nursie on Monday July 05, 2021 @06:27AM
(#27736363)
Yeah for the EU I think that there's a law that effectively says things should last as long things should be expected to last.
For major appliances IIRC this has been shown in court to be as much as ten years. I think at some point in the past apple caught a lot of flack for this over "Apple Care", a paid add-on to give you a longer than basic warranty, but neither the original nor the enhanced warranty were as good as the legally required warranty anyway.
I guess this probably still applies in the UK, for now, as well.
Re:Lemon Law
by alliao on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:34AM
(#27737307)
we have similar mechanism in New Zealand, under consumer guarantees act. But the way it played out is quite differently. Retailers end up slapping on a little extra as insurance. With lower priced items they'd just buy a bit more and just exchange. With more expensive items they'd try to fix but often contract the jobs out anyway and just give customer a new unit then sell on the refurbished product on the second hand market.
I still come across many who don't know the law, and retailers take advantage of it by coercing gullible consumers into submission. And those who are able to whisper the magic words of consumer guarantees act gets a relatively speedy resolution.
Re:Lemon Law
by chiph on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:35AM
(#27736855)
Several years ago, I passed a man holding a sign and a basket out in front of a local car dealer. He was apparently having difficulties getting his car repaired, as the sign said "Why buy a car from [dealer], when I'll give you a lemon?" And he would - if you stopped he would hand you a lemon from his basket.
It took about 4 days before they caved in to his demands and refunded his money.
Note that in the US, if you end up with a lemon you have to make your claim through the manufacturer, not the dealer. Use the phone number that is in your owner's manual. Every state has it's own criteria for determining if a car is a lemon. In North Carolina, the law says "reasonable number of attempts", which has been commonly accepted to be four. Or has been out of service for 20+ business days over a year.
Re:Lemon Law
by 404mm on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:10AM
(#27738176)
Nice! I remember Clark Howard was talking about this being fairly cheap (of done properly) and effective way of getting your way at a dealership.
The key was not to do this on their property and not advertise your issue publicly, as that would just get you a suit. I think he suggested something like “Ask me about my experience at this dealership”.
I love being able to translate these less than common concepts. "Garantie des vices cachés" is something that everybody understands in France. Now I know the english name!
In my country it is the seller, not the manufacturer, who provides warranty service. And if the thing stops functioning in a way that is under warranty, then I, the consumer, can chose which outcome I want: money back, repair, or new device.
Re:Lemon Law
by Ma8ee on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:37AM
(#27736868)
In Sweden it is also the seller that is responsible. That is the only reasonable thing, since I can't be expected to track down some manufacturer in China.
But here the seller also have the right to try to repair the device, within some reasonable limits. So if the AC of my new car stops working, the seller can try to repair it, and can actually make several attempts before I can start demanding a new car.
Re:Lemon Law
by jdblair on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:29AM
(#27736810)
"A lemon" is the slang term for a badly manufactured car. Until the 80s there was often a noticeable difference in build quality for the same model. Some customers would even look up what day a particular car was built on, not wanting something finished on Friday afternoon.
And I think it's a good thing environmentally. Because a consumer cannot really know how durable a product is, so producers try to lower prices by reducing quality. Which makes it so that one has to buy new stuff more often, leading to lots of waste. But these laws solves that, the cost of a bad quality product cannot be hidden and passed on to the consumer.
Oh and a favorite trick is to have a mandatory warranty registration within X days from purchase and/or pay shipping one or two ways (which is easily $20 each way, depending on size and carrier)
So yah, you toss a lot of stuff at the end.
For major appliances IIRC this has been shown in court to be as much as ten years. I think at some point in the past apple caught a lot of flack for this over "Apple Care", a paid add-on to give you a longer than basic warranty, but neither the original nor the enhanced warranty were as good as the legally required warranty anyway.
I guess this probably still applies in the UK, for now, as well.
I still come across many who don't know the law, and retailers take advantage of it by coercing gullible consumers into submission. And those who are able to whisper the magic words of consumer guarantees act gets a relatively speedy resolution.
It took about 4 days before they caved in to his demands and refunded his money.
Note that in the US, if you end up with a lemon you have to make your claim through the manufacturer, not the dealer. Use the phone number that is in your owner's manual. Every state has it's own criteria for determining if a car is a lemon. In North Carolina, the law says "reasonable number of attempts", which has been commonly accepted to be four. Or has been out of service for 20+ business days over a year.
https://ncdoj.gov/protecting-consumers/automobiles/lemon-law...
The key was not to do this on their property and not advertise your issue publicly, as that would just get you a suit. I think he suggested something like “Ask me about my experience at this dealership”.
http://wwwdata.unibg.it/dati/corsi/8906/37702-Akerlof%20-%20...
But here the seller also have the right to try to repair the device, within some reasonable limits. So if the AC of my new car stops working, the seller can try to repair it, and can actually make several attempts before I can start demanding a new car.
Seriously, where does the name of the law come from?
(Edited for clarity)
Sense 5, slang: "a person or thing considered to be useless or defective"
It's dated slang now.