Re:Hotmail Adds New Feature "My Friend's Been Hacked"
by hammock on Saturday July 16, 2011 @08:13PM
(#2772160)
Curious, what is your reasoning behind allowing 123456 in order to keep some kind of crazy "random generator" purity, but at the same time requiring a minimum length? Suppose my pw generator randomly generates passwords of different lengths? It seems to me the same operating principle behind why you don't want to limit character selection/order applies to string length as well.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hotmail Adds New Feature "My Friend's Been Hacked"
by drdaeman on Saturday July 16, 2011 @08:46PM
(#2772201)
I thought that a minimum limit's there just to ensure sanity of a generator. You can't generally predict how a hash function will behave, but you can certainly define a minimum output length. What I was thinking about, that the restrictions are too strict, and there's a gap between what's secure and what looks secure.
I believed that it's generally expected that a password generator would produce passwords of a certain minimal length. At least I considered that nobody would write a generator (intended for a real-world usage) that'd produce, say, 3-character password for some edge case.
However, you sound reasonable. This leads us right to the extreme case - should empty passwords be allowed? (Considering that the user will be bugged like hell before letting him to do so.)
I should think more about this.
Re:Hotmail Adds New Feature "My Friend's Been Hacked"
by tiddchristopher on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:24AM
(#2772628)
I remember creating a blank password on Mac OS9 in grade school. It was clearly a bug that allowed me to do it, because the minimum password length was set to six characters, if I recall correctly. After I set the null password, I couldn't change it, but it worked fine for logging into my account. I was too embarrassed to ask the admin for help, so I was stuck with no password for about two years.