I've thought greatest failure of many professionals in this field is in the "protect the network" perspective rather than "protect the data". While many of them fess up to "we can make it difficult but not impossible" to breach the network, that is not evinced by the protections instituted.
If companies actually understood that they WILL be hacked, the focus would turn to protecting the data. Actual resting data protection would allow a "I don't care if I'm hacked," posture. Either behind encryption, VM's, segregation, or architectures, preferably all, if data is actually protected, then a hack can be weathered. It's still a pain if the computer-touchers have to rebuild and reload, but that's what you pay them for. If the data is protected, a hack is just a painful exercise rather than a newsworthy event.
I do understand that segregating (through protection and architecture) data is difficult, but I do not understand why it is not the focus.
Imagine if the solution to Covid was "the virus can spread to anyone, we need to replace all humans"
It's only prohibitively expensive because most of these enterprise tools and servers are actually very much focused on manual setup.
That's quite interesting. Where can I read more about that ?
https://www.csoonline.com/article/3247848/what-is-zero-trust...
Protecting the data means encrypting it (which Google also does) such that the client needs a key to decode it.
But if the client is hacked, the hacker can get their keys! so encrypting the data isn't a magical cure-all.
Moreover what if a hostile party constantly hammers-disrupts your IT, letting you teams "rebuild and reload" 24 hours/day (in other words you don't have any information system anymore)?
None of this is rocket science and these people probably aren't stupid, so somehow, somewhere, something is going horribly systemically wrong (incentives? Training? Organisation? I don't know).
It's not like Colin Percival or Theo de Raadt , perfect as they are, could just audit and secure all of the Fortune 500.
It doesn’t tell me whether they understand how it all works together, or if they understand the organization’s environment, or if they are a good worker.
I don’t hold it against people who fail (I’ve seen good people fail the test) or who don’t have it - I just have to ask a few more probing questions to ensure they know the tech I’m discussing. But I don’t outright ask if someone is a CISSP, so typically I ask the clarifying questions anyway so our understanding of the problem is accurate and aligned.
And cert or not, I’m still more interested in whether you know what you’re doing than what you put on your resume.
It's just a cram-and-forget vocab test, it doesn't mean anything other than that they could afford the training and the test.
it follows that
"Centralized hosting and management (SaaS, PaaS model) has the advantage of insecurity at scale."
It's as if someone sells you a laser that shoots intruders and tells you, you can leave the front door open from now on, but that laser only works 1 in 3 times.
I go through security reviews all the time with them, they have so many security processes that you get dizzy and on paper everything looks fine. They create security zones with massive risk reviews, but for some reason those security zones then share subnets with the entire LAN.
They also have a default configuration which makes everything access the standard intranet directory once its deemed secure. Enterprise security tools like Cyberark are deemed more secure than say yubikey HSMs, which may result in root ssh being enabled in a lot of settings. They have system configurations that are done with massive Excel sheets. Their cloud VPCs basically only have one risk profile and once its deemed secure it gets access to things in the intranet. They also vehemently refuse to do threat modelling when designing anything.
These people can tell you so much about the theory of security by heart that it will make you dizzy but then won't actually understand the underlying problems.
And the offenders are always the same, advised by Accenture, Infosys etc.