News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by tptacek on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:22PM (#27713529)
I remain baffled at the folk wisdom of using providers outside the United States in order to avoid the Five Eyes IC. You accomplish the opposite thing by doing that. NSA is literally chartered to hack into things outside of US jurisdiction; they don't even need permission to do it. They might even need permission not to do it.

Obviously, hosting in the US isn't a cure-all. And there are other good reasons to work with companies in Europe; for instance, their data privacy rules can often be better than ours, which can give you some commercial protections.

But these discussions about where people's email is hosted always talk about jurisdictional issues, and the only jurisdictional issue that matters here is this: if NSA is going to swipe mail from Google Mail, there's a whole fuckload of paperwork they have to do. If they want to get mail from your random email provider in Switzerland, they can just push a button.

Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by davidwritesbugs on Friday July 02, 2021 @02:27PM (#27715004)
If you are trying to avoid spook you're fucked anywhere you are: US EU whatever. Yes, if the NSA want your US email they probably won't press that button, but they'll ask GCHQ to press a UK button insetad and get it that way. Also, if the FBI wants your email they will just send a guy in a black MiB suit & 9/10 times the email company will roll over. If they meet resistance FBI just go to a tame US judge (they have loads) who rubber stamps the writ. If your server is in .CH they need lots of paperwork and a good arguable case. So yes it is worth hosting outside US. Ask Microsoft about why they do EU data hosting in Ireland.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by mox1 on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:05PM (#27716195)
Your kinda proving parents point. To get email content outside the USA, there are no rules. NSA can do more or less what they want to obtain that data (hack,bribe,etc.)

within the US, it requires some type of judicial process. You can argue about corrupt judges, power tripping FBI agents, etc. etc. but the fact is, its harder to obtain this data inside the USA.

Further, if you are just committing regular old crimes, the FBI will need to run some type of parallel reconstruction IF they obtained your data using less than pristine methods.

What DoJ attorney would risk their career cause some dumb-ass FBI agent went rogue and pistol whipped the sys-admin for the data?!?!?!?!

Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by tptacek on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:54PM (#27716733)
I'm not even trying to say you're meaningfully protected by US jurisdiction. I personally think you are, but I won't try to win the argument, and I think reasonable people can certainly disagree. I'm just saying that, if nothing else, selecting a smaller provider with fewer security resources just to get outside of the US is not a win with respect to mass surveillance.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by ikerdanzel on Saturday July 03, 2021 @07:36AM (#27720922)
If you read finish, he basically proved to host it outside USA or any 5eyes. Hacking is way more difficult than pushing a button. This is why FBI insist a backdoor key for phone manufacturers.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by tptacek on Sunday July 04, 2021 @06:30PM (#27733149)
If we're not on the same page about why it's harder to crack the encrypted filesystem of a locked recent-model iPhone than it is to hack into an always-on database-backed SMTP email service, there's little point in us debating this further.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by jarland on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:52PM (#27723846)
This has been my position for a while as well. We even saw last year the revelation that the CIA had been in Switzerland:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/national-...

It's definitely a false sense of security to assume that being on one side of a particular border increases your security. There may be degrees of truth to it but there's no "if your data is here, no agency will ever come for it." When protecting the contents of your data is important, the largest workload should be on sender and recipient. The protocols they decide to use, the encryption they choose for their content, etc.

Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by TedDoesntTalk on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:30PM (#27713648)
Excellent point! Illegal domestic spying in the US has mostly gone the way of the dodo bird because of certain whisteblowers.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by tptacek on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:37PM (#27713760)
I want to be clear that I have zero doubt that illegal domestic spying happens in the US. I chose my words carefully.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by shadilay on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:50PM (#27724807)
Recently there has been increasing government interest in "domestic terrorism" which is basically the public facing component of an increase in funding for three letter agencies.
Re:Migadu – No-nonsense multi-domain email at a flat price by colordrops on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:47PM (#27713878)
You are being sarcastic I assume.