News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by tptacek on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:49PM (#2771217)
Advice: next time you feel an urge to frustration or mockery of non-computer-professionals, pull this up and start reading it from the top.

And this is the general exam.

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by jarekr on Saturday July 16, 2011 @03:42PM (#2771546)
I obviously won't doubt the genius of Terrence Tao, but reading about PhD level research from any other discipline without knowing a yota about it would leave exactly the same impression, even from a lesser scientist. Of course some people are incredibly smart, but there is no need to mythologize their abilities without having any understanding of what they have actually done. Thus I think such an article can only have value for people who at least vaguely understand the mathematics involved.
Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by robryan on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:39AM (#2772655)
I think Terrence on his blog does a decent job as coming across as someone who is really smart but has got to that position in maths by spending a lot of time in some pretty narrow fields. He openly admits, like for example when P/NP stuff come up a bit maybe 6 months back, areas where he isn't an expert.

He could probably easily make his knowledge look even more impressive but is humble about what he does and doesn't know.

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by idle_processor on Saturday July 16, 2011 @05:03PM (#2771807)
a yota

an iota

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by StavrosK on Saturday July 16, 2011 @06:17PM (#2771951)
The pronunciation of γιώτα (iota) in Greek is, actually, exactly "yota", so I'll allow the nonstandard transliteration.

/resident Greek

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by acangiano on Saturday July 16, 2011 @07:54PM (#2772137)
In my experience programmers don't mock mathematicians and other hard science and engineering specialists. They are seen as more or less peers. They tend to mock marketers, MBAs, sociology majors, etc.
Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by redthrowaway on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:31AM (#2772640)
"Hard" is a relative term, here. Surely physics is hard science. Most would agree with Chemistry. Biology? Well, okay...Psychology? No, now you're just--Sociology? The hell? How did we get here?

As far as people I mock--only those who think a liberal arts education will land them a good job with no other qualifications. The world needs historians (even of the art variety), anthropologists, sociologists, and even marketers. What it doesn't particularly need, however, is 70% of the college population pursuing those degrees when maybe 3% of the jobs out there are suited to them.

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by btilly on Sunday July 17, 2011 @03:37AM (#2772779)
Let me justify that categorization for you.

http://bentilly.blogspot.com/2009/09/what-makes-it-science.h...

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by telemachos on Saturday July 16, 2011 @05:11PM (#2771827)
> And this is the general exam.

I agree with your basic point, but if you mean to say that some other set of exams (the non-general ones) were harder, I'm not so sure. For most places, there are two sets of exams: generals before you write a thesis and your thesis defense. In my experience, pre-dissertation general exams are significantly harder than the oral defense of a thesis. Most universities use them as a final weed-out phase before allowing people to even consider a thesis topic. As such, you have to demonstrate mastery over a far wider field than a dissertation might cover. For example, all of Math or Philosophy or English Literature or Romance Linguistics - often with chosen specialty sub-topics, so you end up having to worry about breadth and depth. By the time you get to the oral for your thesis, on the other hand, you are in such complete command of the material that defending your views (on that narrower scope) is relatively easy.

Also, in most cases, you won't be allowed to set a date for your dissertation defense unless the work as a whole is already passable.

Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by mctavjb9 on Saturday July 16, 2011 @11:07PM (#2772401)
Definitely my experience. I still have vivid nightmares about the general exam more than 10 years later. It was an 3 day x 8 hours per day written test with no breaks. If you wanted to eat, you had to bring food with you into the test room. Then there was the dreaded oral inquisition. Although I didn't appreciate it at the time, having survived the abject misery of the first 2 years of a physics Ph.D., everything else has seemed manageable in comparison. A few years ago, they changed the format of the written exam to a single 8 hour day. My thesis defense was a total cakewalk. Scheduling it late on a Friday afternoon was probably the single smartest thing I ever did in grad school.
Re:Terence Tao's General Exam by spearo77 on Saturday July 16, 2011 @07:00PM (#2772036)
You might also enjoy browsing his Math Overflow questions and answers.. http://mathoverflow.net/users/766/terry-tao