News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by irrelative on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:05PM (#2771117)
It's certainly true that the job market is going crazy in silicon valley, but the complaints in this article go against some pretty fundamental economic principles - namely that more efficient use of capital results in unemployment.

Disruptive technology often results in unemployment in the short term because it cleans up inefficiencies -- look at the industrial revolution. I think it's fair to say we're richer as a society because we can automate production of goods. Yes, it put a lot of craftsmen out of work, but it was a hugely beneficial change.

And so these days we have itunes putting record stores out of business. And amazon shutting down book stores. There's plenty of nostalgia for these establishments, but the things that have replaced them electronically give us incredibly better selection at less of a cost.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by vannevar on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:28PM (#2771162)
We're nearing a point where we might question whether efficiency as a goal in itself has ceased to be beneficial to us. After all, we begin as dust and end as dust; why not make things more efficient by eliminating all the messy life part in between?

Maybe we should be less concerned about efficiency and more concerned about our quality of life. And not just we the wealthy (and everyone reading HN is much, much wealthier than the average human being), but everyone. Because if there is one thing history demonstrates, it's that when wealth becomes overly concentrated, grief is sure to follow for everyone.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by dantheman on Saturday July 16, 2011 @02:19PM (#2771298)
By improving efficiency we are improving the quality of life of those around the world. Due to rapid improvements in technology those in the poorest countries can now easily access information, entertainment, books, knowledge from anywhere in the world at remarkably low cost -> Greatly improving their quality of life (if we agree that life like we have in the west is the goal).
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by dreamdu5t on Saturday July 16, 2011 @02:31PM (#2771340)
What's the point of completely automating everything if you still have to work 40 hours a week?
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by nostrademons on Saturday July 16, 2011 @02:46PM (#2771378)
Why do you still have to work 40 hours a week once everything is automated?
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by robryan on Saturday July 16, 2011 @10:16PM (#2772331)
The problem there though is that those working have little interest in paying say 50% tax to support those who they have put out if work with increased efficiency.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by NiceOneBrah on Saturday July 16, 2011 @02:54PM (#2771398)
Automating tasks allows us to work on tasks that we don't know how to automate and leads to innovation.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by vannevar on Sunday July 17, 2011 @02:32PM (#2773856)
Due to rapid improvements in technology those in the poorest countries can now easily access information, entertainment, books, knowledge from anywhere in the world at remarkably low cost -> Greatly improving their quality of life...

I find it unlikely that someone who is put out of a job by new efficiencies would find much solace in low cost YouTube access. It's precisely this blind faith in efficiency as a measure of progress that I question. I'm not saying it's always bad, but it's clear now that improved efficiency is not always good. We need to find new, more suitable metrics by which to measure progress.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by skybrian on Saturday July 16, 2011 @07:31PM (#2772121)
There are fundamental problems that aren't even close to being solved. Health care is the most obvious one. Efficiency in one area should (in theory) allow us to spend more on unsolved problems. Of course, that can only lead to employment to the extent that someone is willing to spend.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by vannevar on Saturday July 16, 2011 @10:04PM (#2772317)
Efficiency in one area should (in theory) allow us to spend more on unsolved problems.

It may also create new unsolved problems. Fast food is efficient, but has it represented a net gain in our quality of life or health?

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by DasIch on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:20PM (#2771146)
The assumption that unemployment caused by innovation is only short term is based on the assumption that new jobs will be created which require (roughly) the same qualifications.

I think that more and more this proves to be a questionable expectation.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by ivankirigin on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:33PM (#2771178)
If you don't operate under the assumption that people will work to improve their skills and learn so as to become functional and contributing members of society, you're committing to a static society or complete dependence on the government. People need to start acting like a job isn't a right but something you earn.

If you think the current disruption is meaningful, just wait 10 to 20 years for robots to replace almost all service jobs in a very short time

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by rbarooah on Saturday July 16, 2011 @02:01PM (#2771252)
I think this is pretty accurate, however there is a potential structural problem: entry level, or low level jobs in general don't pay people enough to invest time or resources in improving their skills - certainly not for longer term shifts in the economy.

"Earning" a job, implies that people invest their own resources in preparing themselves for the future. I am vehemently in favor of that as a general way for society to operate.

However, this vision requires that people have sufficient resources to make these investments. Given the increasing disparities of resource allocation that we're seeing, why should we assume that this is possible?

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by ivankirigin on Monday July 18, 2011 @12:34AM (#2775130)
In all of human history, it has never been easier than today to learn something new.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by orky56 on Saturday July 16, 2011 @02:01PM (#2771248)
"a job isn't a right but something you earn"

I definitely agree but when you are at a company who has employed you for a long time and have been doing your job well, then who's not to say that now unemployed person hasn't earned that job. The time spent at that job performing well could have been spent learning some new in-demand skill but think of the opportunity cost. Now when these people are unemployed, do we really think society has provided the motivation, resources, and most importantly, direction, to change their view on career and development. It's a very big step and I believe its naive to think that unemployment is an event actionable enough to make someone switch their mentality.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by ivankirigin on Monday July 18, 2011 @12:37AM (#2775134)
I don't really put blame on individuals. I think they are socialized to make their poor decisions. I mainly blame our educational institutions and government for telling people for decades that they will be taken care of when down. It's a lie, but comes with a bonus of placating people.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by gnaritas on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:46PM (#2771208)
> you're committing to a static society

You say that as if it's a given bad thing, it isn't; humans lived in virtually static societies for most of their existence; the current rate of change is simply too fast for most people and is itself not the norm. It's like we're trying to become the Morlocks and the Eloi.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by ivankirigin on Monday July 18, 2011 @12:32AM (#2775127)
Let me know your opinion on static societies when you or someone you love gets diagnosed with a currently terminal disease. Or, on a grander scale, a static human race is doomed to extinction by the next large asteroid.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by irrelative on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:38PM (#2771188)
Sure, that economic theory doesn't take into account jobs with the same qualifications. But why should it? When assembly line production began being automated by robotics, I'm sure there were stories about how the riveters and welders would never be able to work again. We're still better off because of that automation though - goods can be produced more efficiently and at higher quality.

We can't predict the future, but every previous disruptive technological innovation has resulted in society being richer. It would be quite the shock if the result of the most recent one somehow left us poorer -- something really worth reporting on -- but I don't believe it.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by RuadhanMc on Saturday July 16, 2011 @03:12PM (#2771461)
Society as a whole gets richer, but within those confines the rich can get richer and the poor can get poorer. Granted the poor today (I assume) have a higher quality of life than they did 50 years ago, but their expectations for life are also (probably) higher and cheap credit means that they can live beyond their means and a deeper whole for themselves, while temporarily giving themselves the impression that they have money to spend.

Silicon Valley is producing these great billion dollar companies, but the companies themselves are only hiring a small fraction of the employees that similarly sized (market cap) companies have in the past. That is a bit of a problem. It means that incredible wealth is concentrated in one place, but without the filter down value that has occurred in the past.

These companies still have immense value to society, but the value as far as numbers of people employed is decreasing dramatically and that is a major concern.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by burgerbrain on Saturday July 16, 2011 @05:06PM (#2771817)
"Granted the poor today (I assume) have a higher quality of life than they did 50 years ago, but their expectations for life are also (probably) higher"

So... if in the future I own a flying car with 30 cup-holders, but the rich people in society all have 5 hyper-deluxe flying cars with tinted windows, will I be worse off since my expectations are significantly higher than what I can obtain?

Or will I still own a flying car, whereas before I did not?

And no, this isn't some terrible example. "Poor" in America is anything but for the vast number of people below the poverty line. People with no skills of value to society should feel lucky for having so much.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by anamax on Saturday July 16, 2011 @03:29PM (#2771506)
> Society as a whole gets richer, but within those confines the rich can get richer and the poor can get poorer.

But, do they get poorer?

> Granted the poor today (I assume) have a higher quality of life than they did 50 years ago,

Good - they're getting richer.

But, why does the sentence continue.

> but their expectations for life are also (probably) higher and cheap credit means that they can live beyond their means and a deeper whole for themselves, while temporarily giving themselves the impression that they have money to spend.

Huh?

The fact that US poor can be better off than ever before has no connection to easy credit.

In fact, even with the easy credit and the resulting bankruptcy, they're better off now than past poor.

Note that I'm not arguing for stupid credit policies (pushed mostly by govt). I'm pointing out that they have nothing to do with whether the poor are better off now.

Oh, and most poor people didn't get into the cheap credit problem because they didn't even qualify under the stupid standards.

However, the efforts to prop up folks who bought what they can't afford have kept folks who saved out of those houses. It's unclear why that's a good thing.

For the good of society, banks need to lose money on stupid loans.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by paganel on Saturday July 16, 2011 @01:59PM (#2771244)
> There's plenty of nostalgia for these establishments, but the things that have replaced them electronically give us incredibly better selection at less of a cost.

The question is: who will buy all these things (doesn't matter if it's online or offline) if more and more people don't have a steady paycheck?