News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by rocqua on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:30AM (#27710598)
I often hear people I dismiss directly mention cultural marxism. But I have never seen an explanation of what cultural marxism is. Could you enlighten me?
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by _jal on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:42AM (#27710728)
So, in terms of intellectual thought, there was a strain of thought referred to as the Frankfurt School that discussed a thing they called 'cultural Marxism'. Some of that discussion was about what we'd now think of as PR/propaganda - promoting socialist/Marxist thought.

In terms of right wing PR/propaganda, it is another example of them following a specific playbook to redefine a term to mean what they want it to mean. 'Critical Race Theory' is the current example of this; 'political correctness' was another. Remember when they were shouting about Saul Alinsky? Well, that was because the playbook is largely derived from his writings - specifically, the tactic described as 'Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it.'

So there you are. Depending on your politics, it was a strain of Marxist intellectual thought in the 1930s, or just another cudgel in the culture wars.

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by ceilingcorner on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:31AM (#27710618)
Critical theory is actually what people mean when they say cultural Marxism.

Critical theory itself came out of various Marxist and Marxist-influenced academics in the mid-20th century.

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by rocqua on Friday July 02, 2021 @11:40AM (#27712914)
It seems that most people in this thread who use the term cultural marxism don't quite mean critical theory. Instead it seems to be about seeing (and advocating for) a dialectic between the oppressors and the oppressed. The idea is that this division maps somewhat to 'cultural' groups. The main 'cultural' division they mention is race. I would assume they also include LGBT+ and occasionally jews as part of the opressed group.

A main part of the concept behind this is that this dialectic is wrong. And hence people supporting it are doing so for other goals. Apparently this goal is "communism". That is, the goal is overthrowing the oppressed. It seems like the idea is that some of the people supporting this dialectic do so without questioning whether it is true. Hence, the argument goes, the supporters of this idea are either maliciously pushing a false agenda, or they are convinced by the false agenda and are well-meaning fools.

I also get the feeling there is an undertone of trying to understand why white / straight / gentile people are actually supporting the progressive side of identity politics.

Personally, I think most of this is plainly wrong. Though it seems like an interesting lens through which to look at the most extreme people at the progressive spectrum of identity politics.

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by blacktriangle on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:04PM (#27713265)
Marxism and critical theory are separate but related, and its no accident critical theory came out of a Marxist think tank. Marxism looks to exploit some perceived opressor/opresee relationship in a civilization. Critical theory is about examining a civilization to determine what the opressor/opresee relationships are within that culture.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by blacktriangle on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:37AM (#27710683)
Marx wrote about a theory of history in which all of history progresses through phases in which each phase is defined by struggle between classes. His view was that communism was the inevitable end of this model of history in that communism would finally resolve the class struggle. But for somebody who wishes to promote communism, the problem is if there is no class struggle, then history does not advance to their desired end state.

The original formulation of Marxism was economic, based on the struggle between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. This conflict worked to create communist revolutions in nations with more feudalistic systems like Tzarist Russia. However Communists have struggled to create revolution in more Democratic societies with greater social mobility, or at least the perceived possibility of.

So failing to get the economic class consciousness to trigger a revolution, the modern Marxist has moved on to pushing race/culture based class consciousness as the trigger for their revolution. This is why todays Marxist is not obsessed with rich and poor but white vs black vs hispanic.

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by rocqua on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:46AM (#27710778)
Summarizing what you said (without agreeing) to see if I understood your point correctly.

Marxism is the idea of needing class struggle for progress. Cultural Marxism is transposing that from class to culture / ethnicity. Essentially moving the dialectic from worker / captialist to privileged race / non-priviliged race?

And the idea is that this is done, not to engender gradual change, but to engender revolutionary change?

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by blacktriangle on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:51AM (#27710831)
Yes, I'd say that summarizes my statement well, where Marx's definition of progress is moving a society towards communism. This is why any time you see somebody talk about "the right side of history" that's a flag that said person is a Marxist, they view their desired communist end-state as inevitable.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by dekhn on Friday July 02, 2021 @10:36AM (#27712063)
The right side of history was the US immediately after WWII.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by blacktriangle on Friday July 02, 2021 @11:04AM (#27712430)
I think everybody in Eastern Europe who got to live behind the Iron Curtain would disagree with that. Not dealing with the USSR immediately has to be one of the greatest screwups in US history.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by rocqua on Friday July 02, 2021 @11:22AM (#27712696)
> Yes, I'd say that summarizes my statement well, where Marx's definition of progress is moving a society towards communism.

Thanks for the explanation!

> This is why any time you see somebody talk about "the right side of history" that's a flag that said person is a Marxist, they view their desired communist end-state as inevitable.

I think that is, at best, a gross generalization. Just because that is what a Marxist might say, does not mean that everyone who says that is actually a Marxist. Besides, I believe that "history is the story of human progress" is much more a modernist theory, than a Marxist one. It seems to me that someone being "on the right side of history" could just as easily mean, being part of the progress which modernists consider inevitable. Hence making it a modernist sentiment.

Besides, when someone says "the right side of history" all that suggests to me is "back then people thought X was acceptable, now we no longer think that. Person Y was against X, and hence 'on the right side of history' ". The idea that our current morals are better than our previous morals is rather unsurprising. Most people probably hold that opinion, because otherwise, our current morals would change.

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by onionisafruit on Friday July 02, 2021 @09:04AM (#27710964)
You may be right about the origin of "the right side of history", but the phrase has become popular enough that you can't use it to pin down the speaker's ideology. I think most people use it to mean that their ideas will be commonly accepted in the future. Whether their perceived future is a communist utopia or a libertarian thunderdome is irrelevant.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by nivenkos on Friday July 02, 2021 @09:04AM (#27710975)
So you think that Marxists are now promoting race war, not class war, and this is somehow a "leftist" idea?

Seems more that the US deliberately focussed on creating these divisions to destroy working-class movements with COINTELPRO.

That's also why it only exists in the US.

Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by blacktriangle on Friday July 02, 2021 @09:16AM (#27711098)
You think this is only going on in the US? You must not get out much.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by eplanit on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:50AM (#27710823)
A worldview which sees only The Oppressed and The Oppressors, and maps people into one category or the other. For Marx class was used, now it's race... and complete bullshit.
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by ericns on Friday July 02, 2021 @11:12AM (#27712557)
I submit 'Drewcoo's Dictum' for use in these cases.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by mikestew on Friday July 02, 2021 @11:12AM (#27712544)
Bonus points when they don't even get it right, as in this case. "Someone typed 'nazi', better get that Wikipedia URL on the clipboard, stat!"
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by at-fates-hands on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:38AM (#27710690)
Cultural Marxism is a revolutionary leftist idea that traditional culture is the source of oppression in the modern world. Cultural Marxism is often linked to an insistence upon political correctness, multiculturalism, and perpetual attacks on the foundations of culture: the nuclear family, marriage, patriotism, traditional morality, law and order, etc. Cultural Marxists are assumed to be committed to establishing economic Marxism, in which case their cultural attacks are a necessary preparation for their ultimate goal.
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by psychometry on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:43AM (#27710748)
Where'd you come up with that definition? MTJ's Twitter?
Re:Google reports soaring attrition among Black women by blacktriangle on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:51AM (#27710837)
I don't know, but his list of things cultural marxism stands against could literally be lifted from BLM's web page.