We /are/ on the same page because now you've moved from ethics free argument to one involving your version of ethics. Plenty to discuss there, that barely scratches the surface and any deeper is likely a waste of time.
There is a huge difference between genuine libertarian belief an just being a "tax karen" with a pretence libertarian justification. The only thing they really want is not to pay. The latter have really messed up libertarianism and that's a pretty big loss. Including in our tax bills if we can't or choose not to avoid it all.
At the end of the day you’re kinda pontificating fundamental morality? Mine is (roughly) me and my family > friends, people I know. > people in general > animals. Now with that rough framework, obviously an individual not paying their share of taxes (it being a drop in the ocean) while everyone else pays, it makes sense to take advantage of a Roth loophole. But again, it’s a rough framework because there’s obviously an extreme contrived scenario where you wouldn’t be extremely terrible to a lower ranked group in the framework to benefit a higher group only slightly (e.g kill 1000 strangers to be 1% richer), but I don’t think a Roth loophole is it. I’ve actually been consistent about this if you literally read my comments, but you seem to think I’m not. I also don’t know why you care at this point, as we seem to be clashing on fundamental values. I’m speaking for myself, and also human nature generally. Trust me, if people could legally exploit a Roth loophole this way, most would.
But yeah, it does make me angry and I have a fair bit of sympathy for socialists of which I am definitely not one when they get angry about this kind of thing. Rather more than for tax dodgers claiming "it's not actually illegal so no moral judgement can be made." But that's not you despite what you wrote as you've now clarified.
> "Why on earth wouldn't you legally avoid tax if you could"
You evidently have answers to this question yourself as indeed we all should. Once there, there is plenty of room for discussion and debate.