Sometime these algorithms break or are exploited. Often in spectacular disasters. Knight lost half a billion dollars in 30 seconds. Nobody reversed though, even though it was clear error.
If you have a 401k I guarantee you that a significant amount of your money was traded by an algorithm that if broken would have lost everything. If the question is whether people would ever trust capital to irreversible algorithms, the answer is they already do. It’s called the stock market.
You cited Knight twice in this thread, and it's just not the same concept. I think your point is that people should accept irreversible transactions in whole because there are some edge cases where they exist today, and that just doesn't make sense.
First, there's a difference between an average person and Knight in the degree of sophistication of tools that they can wield. So the fact that Knight is allowed to operate like this is in no way connected to whether this mode should be the default for an average person.
Second, the Knight example can be interpreted as an exception that proves the rule. They had an unforced error that (from what I recall) looked to the rest of the world like real trading. But there's a whole other slew of issues (clearly bad prices, exchange-errors, etc) that cause trades to be unwound. Some exciting reading if you care: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/erroneous-trade.asp
You have a point that yes to some extent we're all subject to underlying risk of irreversible activity but the bigger point is that we as society try to minimize it where possible. So moving the system in the other direction, especially where it makes it easy for Joe-Blow to fuck it up, is not the way.
Say the fund managers running your 401k decided to say “fuck it, turn off all the circuit breakers.” Would you just shrug your shoulders and say “no worries, I’m sure FINRA’s got my back if anything goes wrong. Blindly trusting the people running institutions to keep you safe is as misguided as assuming that all software is infallible .
The point is - do you aim to make the system fixable by human judgement or not? This thread is full of examples we like: the credit card protecting us from fraudulent charges, FDIC insurance, etc. Are there places in our life that society is forced to operate without such backstops? Yes. But we want to minimize, not maximize those - especially when it comes to consumer-facing capabilities.
Then I learned about out-trades. In reality, these heavily automated markets screw up (or, rather, customers of these markets screw up) somewhat regularly. Surprise: one of the reasons lots of humans work both at the exchanges and at companies that program directly to them is that mistakes happen, and are often resolved not by code but by hashing things out between cooperating blobs of electrified fat tissue. Gross, I know!
Obviously, there are big screwups where the rules coded into the algorithm are the last word. But those rules aren't always the final word, and, more importantly, the rules themselves are easily changed when the electric meat blobs want them to.
NYSE and the SEC _chose_ not to reverse those trades but they could have. There are plenty of ways the exchange can undo those and also trade busts happen daily on every exchange.
Almost certainly if a large index etf or fund lost everything to a software glitch the trades would be reversed and even if for policy reasons they weren’t they could be. The facility exists.
How so? My 401k is invested in a fund that just owns a broad index of stocks, not an algorithmic trading hedge fund.
OP is trying to say that even something as simple as VTSAX could have a problem and, I don't know, accidentally sell all its AAPL and so it's proof that even for the current market there are rules that govern.
Except, of course, if VTSAX dumped all their AAPL somehow the trade would be unwound, as trades occasionally are. Selling stock on the market is not nearly as irreversible as it may seem.
This actually blew my mind. The exchanges bust trades all the time. I don't why they didn't do it in this case.
As we've repeatedly learned, to the detriment of most people in the world.
An exploit where I take all your bitcoins isn't a lose-lose outcome, and neither is that. If I steal your credit card and you have to pay for my stuff, you're the only party who loses.
If someone steals my wallet's private key (= stealing my credit card), I'm done. There is no recourse AFAIK.
I’d say it depends. You probably shouldn’t manage your life savings using a crypto wallet. Keep some money at a bank. Keep some money in cryptos.
Cryptos are not a solution to every financial problem out there but they add new and exciting options for us. Don’t think black and white. But embrace more freedom to choose.
The Coinbase wallet integrates the major lending protocols. Ethereum fees are reasonable these days. So lending USDC or DAI and earning interest has become a great alternative to saving accounts.
If you hold fair amounts of Bitcoin or Ethereum long term, you can use it as collateral and borrow USDC. This way you can not only let your money work for you, you can also use it to borrow dollars for a short term credit — like getting a mortgage but without a bank.
Furthermore, these days there are other emerging financial tools that banks simply can’t provide. Earning exchange fees on liquidity pools, for example, or staking cryptos and earn validation fees like a miner for Proof-Of-Stake networks.
Point is: Lots of innovation, here. When I look at banks nothing really has been happening there for decades.
This is an epically terrible argument for why you shouldn't have to pay for things someone else purchased with your stolen credit card. "I shouldn't have to because I don't have to"?
Compare tptacek's claim:
>>> which is why when your credit card gets stolen you don't end up paying for stuff.
There are four parties involved: you, the thief, the bank, and the merchant.
When you can afford to pay, here's a win/loss table in the case where you have to pay:
you: lose
bank: win
merchant: win
thief: win
And in the case where you don't have to pay, but the bank collects from the merchant: you: win
bank: win
merchant: lose
thief: win
You don't have to pay, and the bank can't collect from the merchant: you: win
bank: lose
merchant: win
thief: win
When you have to pay, but you can't afford it: you: win
bank: lose
merchant: win
thief: win
Where's the lose/lose scenario?So, just to clear this up: you, the customer, and your credit card company agree that it's lose-lose for retail customers to be on the hook for credit card fraud. It makes it much harder to actually use the credit card transaction processing system, which you want to do because it's way better and safer than carrying cash, and the credit card companies want you to do because they're credit card companies.
In any given situation, a merchant on the hook for stolen stuff does not agree that this is lose-lose. Them getting paid with stolen money is a win-lose for them. But the credit card company takes the long view: if customers were always on the hook for this stuff, customers would stop using credit cards as much. It's better for everyone if it's easy to buy things, and not terrifying to shop online.
Merchants that disagree with this assessment can refuse to take credit cards. They can just take Bitcoins, The Currency Of The Future. The consensus view here is not hard to discover.
If they did try to collect then that sounds like a great reason to go back to cash because even if I get mugged, criminals can't spend me tens of thousands of dollars into debt by stealing my cash on hand. They are limited to what's in my wallet.
This applies to everyone involved, but someone's going to pay for the loss anyway, unless you can recover from the thief.
There is no reason for the merchant to pay for the purchase either -- he is even less culpable than you are. But that's what everyone is advocating here.
>>> I did not initiate the sale with the merchant, I did not verify I was the rightful card holder, I did not authorize the funds to be transferred
there is also no reason why merchants should.
The fact that the system currently operates in a certain way is not actually evidence that it cannot operate in a different way.
But what if someone does not want the insurance of the bank? There is no opt out. With something like bitcoin you ideally have the option to take the risk of final settlement on your own or delegate it to some insurance deliberately