So, just to clear this up: you, the customer, and your credit card company agree that it's lose-lose for retail customers to be on the hook for credit card fraud. It makes it much harder to actually use the credit card transaction processing system, which you want to do because it's way better and safer than carrying cash, and the credit card companies want you to do because they're credit card companies.
In any given situation, a merchant on the hook for stolen stuff does not agree that this is lose-lose. Them getting paid with stolen money is a win-lose for them. But the credit card company takes the long view: if customers were always on the hook for this stuff, customers would stop using credit cards as much. It's better for everyone if it's easy to buy things, and not terrifying to shop online.
Merchants that disagree with this assessment can refuse to take credit cards. They can just take Bitcoins, The Currency Of The Future. The consensus view here is not hard to discover.
If they did try to collect then that sounds like a great reason to go back to cash because even if I get mugged, criminals can't spend me tens of thousands of dollars into debt by stealing my cash on hand. They are limited to what's in my wallet.
This applies to everyone involved, but someone's going to pay for the loss anyway, unless you can recover from the thief.
There is no reason for the merchant to pay for the purchase either -- he is even less culpable than you are. But that's what everyone is advocating here.
>>> I did not initiate the sale with the merchant, I did not verify I was the rightful card holder, I did not authorize the funds to be transferred
there is also no reason why merchants should.
The fact that the system currently operates in a certain way is not actually evidence that it cannot operate in a different way.
This is an epically terrible argument for why you shouldn't have to pay for things someone else purchased with your stolen credit card. "I shouldn't have to because I don't have to"?
Compare tptacek's claim:
>>> which is why when your credit card gets stolen you don't end up paying for stuff.
There are four parties involved: you, the thief, the bank, and the merchant.
When you can afford to pay, here's a win/loss table in the case where you have to pay:
And in the case where you don't have to pay, but the bank collects from the merchant: You don't have to pay, and the bank can't collect from the merchant: When you have to pay, but you can't afford it: Where's the lose/lose scenario?