Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by spfzero on Sunday June 27, 2021 @07:16PM
(#27656370)
Another study where they don't differentiate between fast-food beef, cafo vs. grass-fed, processed with nitrates/nitrites vs. non-processed, etc. And only one year of dietary surveys, for a disease that takes many years to develop?
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by tryptophan on Sunday June 27, 2021 @06:12PM
(#27655962)
>The major message, according to Giannakis, is not that people should completely avoid red meat: “My recommendation would be that moderation and a balanced diet is key.” Only patients who consumed more than 150 grams (five ounces) of food per day, about two or more meals, had high levels of tumor alkylation damage.
So red meat is basically fine to eat. Just don't eat it twice a day every day? 150g is a good sized steak.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by AltonWells on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:56AM
(#27658561)
Going vegan is the only proven method (with regards to consumption) to reduce your risk of cancer, heart disease, and diabetes. If you care about longevity and consume large amounts of meat you’re doing the equivalent of smoking cigarettes everyday.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by seibelj on Sunday June 27, 2021 @06:37PM
(#27656131)
I try to avoid / limit grilled and smoked food. It seems clear to me that putting charred food and food specifically infused with smoke would be bad for you, just as smoking is bad for you. Don’t need science to tell me.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by beaconstudios on Sunday June 27, 2021 @07:07PM
(#27656317)
Smoking is bad for you because it deposits tar and other toxic substances in your lungs. As far as I'm aware, comparing that to smoked meat is apples to oranges.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by seibelj on Sunday June 27, 2021 @07:20PM
(#27656400)
If smoke is bad for your lungs, then putting meat into a smoke house for a long time, infusing all of the food with smoke, and having that carcinogen-infused product pass through your entire digestive system seems… also risky. Just logic to me.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by seibelj on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:07PM
(#27657378)
Are you arguing that smoke is harmless? I feel like I’m taking crazy pills. No one would cook meat with car exhaust and expect it to be safe. Burning charcoal or wood to cook meat using pure smoke cannot possibly be harmless.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by seibelj on Sunday June 27, 2021 @11:50PM
(#27657958)
Put it this way - smoke is clearly bad for you and proven to cause cancer. I believe what I eat is absorbed by my body and can affect it, like medicine affects my body when absorbed. Therefore I think it’s fairly likely that eating a lot of food infused with smoke and carcinogens is a strong risk. It would be quite odd if it turned out smoke-food had absolutely 0% effect on your body, and especially making it a routine piece of food you eat would be worse than a “once in a while” thing.
So that’s my point - if you think smoke is bad for your lungs, it’s probably bad for your colon too!
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by floatingatoll on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:24PM
(#27657136)
Nope, otherwise you’d get asthma from eating bread, since inhaled flour can irritate alveoli, and so therefore consumed flour can, too.
(To head off the usual argument about allergies, you can replace flour in the above statement with any neutral powder, such as cornstarch or potato starch or baking soda or sugar or salt.)
It’s valid to consider systemic toxins, but if this was a systemic toxin issue, it wouldn’t only be their colon that’s affected, it would also be affecting their lungs, even if they only consumed it.
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by maxerickson on Sunday June 27, 2021 @10:30PM
(#27657486)
Much of the harm to lungs from smoke is from the particulates. That won't be quite the same issue for things you eat.
And then a bunch of the compounds present in the smoke, that would get absorbed in the lungs, are not going to concentrate in the meat (anything with a low vapor pressure will mostly be driven off and exhausted out of the grill/smoker/etc).
Re:DNA damage caused by diets rich in red meat found in colo...
by sushid on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:40AM
(#27658180)
I think you're getting downvoted because people think you are saying smoking == eating smoked food. I think you're saying smoking = bad, smoked food = bad.
It's true that burnt food is a carcinogen and you shouldn't go out of your way to eat burnt food.
So red meat is basically fine to eat. Just don't eat it twice a day every day? 150g is a good sized steak.
14/16oz would be for ribeye or strip. That's quite a chunk of meat, and most people would not be able to finish it.
Everything I ever do
Every place I’ve ever been
Everywhere I’m going to
It’s a sin.
(song by Pet Shop Boys, or what every health article tells me)
Let's just yolo and enjoy the food of this bountiful earth.
No one is saying smoke inhalation is harmless. But to conclude it shouldn't be ingested based on this fact alone is dubious.
So that’s my point - if you think smoke is bad for your lungs, it’s probably bad for your colon too!
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/...
(To head off the usual argument about allergies, you can replace flour in the above statement with any neutral powder, such as cornstarch or potato starch or baking soda or sugar or salt.)
It’s valid to consider systemic toxins, but if this was a systemic toxin issue, it wouldn’t only be their colon that’s affected, it would also be affecting their lungs, even if they only consumed it.
And then a bunch of the compounds present in the smoke, that would get absorbed in the lungs, are not going to concentrate in the meat (anything with a low vapor pressure will mostly be driven off and exhausted out of the grill/smoker/etc).
It's true that burnt food is a carcinogen and you shouldn't go out of your way to eat burnt food.