News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday June 25, 2021 @06:43PM (#27637156)
> What part of... rules out aliens?

Because

1) Ruling _in_ aliens requires proof. Insisting that this specific scenario be ruled out is classic "shifting the burden of proof" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(philosophy)

The train of thought that "we don't know what we saw, so ... aliens!" is somewhere between wishful and nutty. Extra-ordinary claims require extra-ordinary proof.

2) claiming that it's _definitely_ "technology and flying at considerable speed without discernible means of propulsion" is itself a stretch. Given the supposed behaviour, a _very_ big stretch. More likely it's equipment failure, lens flare, sundog, bug-on-the-lens, etc.

3) the strong argument against this being real is how it is "perpetually liminal" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27354021

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by ALittleLight on Friday June 25, 2021 @07:47PM (#27637616)
1. I am not saying that these UAP are definitely aliens. I am saying that the findings of the report make aliens a more likely explanation. The report found that physical objects exhibited behavior that suggests advanced technology - including flying at considerable speed without discernible means of propulsion.

It's unfair to characterize this line of thinking as "We don't know what we saw, so aliens." Instead, what I wrote was more like "The report does not contradict aliens. The findings of the report are consistent with what we might expect from alien technology. I am updating my beliefs to increase the likelihood that these UAP are explained by aliens."

Your line about extra-ordinary claims is a bit misguided. For one thing, multiple observations by multiple witnesses and multiple sensor modalities in multiple instances across decades is pretty good evidence. I don't know what evidence you would expect to see if alien technology was operating in our atmosphere, but the described observations seem consistent with that conclusion.

2. The DNI report says "a Handful of UAP Appear to Demonstrate Advanced Technology" and "Some UAP appeared to ... move at considerable speed, without discernable means of propulsion" and "Most of the UAP reported probably do represent physical objects given that a majority of UAP were registered across multiple sensors, to include radar, infrared, electro-optical, weapon seekers, and visual observation." That doesn't sound like "bug-on-the-lens" type observations to me.

Obviously I can't know how good the DNI evidence is. They haven't shared much of it. I don't think it's reasonable to conclude from the report that people are getting confused with lens flares or equipment failures though.

3. That doesn't seem like an argument at all. Any thing which we have observed for a while but haven't explained would fit this description of being "perpetually liminal". UFOs fit the description worse than most things because they aren't very "perpetual". UFO sightings go back ~70 years. That's hardly perpetual. It's also not the case that we always know roughly the same amount. This report for example uses evidence to advance our understanding, arguing that they are physical objects, that they may emit RF energy, and that they have capabilities we do not.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by staticassertion on Friday June 25, 2021 @08:45PM (#27637981)
This is all a really roundabout, long winded way of demonstrating confirmation bias. The idea that there are aliens among us is obscenely unlikely, with debunked after debunked case. Stacking up a whole bunch of fallacious arguments doesn't add up to a good one, or even an ok one, or even a "maybe".

> For one thing, multiple observations by multiple witnesses and multiple sensor modalities in multiple instances across decades is pretty good evidence.

Like this. No it isn't. It's terrible evidence, it actually isn't evidence at all.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by ALittleLight on Friday June 25, 2021 @09:07PM (#27638083)
Whether or not aliens are "obscenely unlikely" addresses only your prior belief before reading this report. Does the report change your beliefs about aliens at all? If so, in what direction, more or less likely?

My point is that the observations of the report make me update towards aliens. The observations are consistent with the theory that alien craft operate in our atmosphere. Advanced technology that we don't understand. Doesn't appear to be ours. Yesterday, I wouldn't have said that was true or that we had good reasons to think it was true. Today, I'm more inclined to think it's true.

If my arguments are fallacious or terrible I'd appreciate you explaining how. Multiple witnesses with multiple sensors multiple times across years seems pretty persuasive. You think it's not evidence at all. Why not? What evidence would you expect to see?

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by staticassertion on Friday June 25, 2021 @09:48PM (#27638317)
The report did nothing to change my views on aliens. There are some events that we have very little information on, and so we can not explain, and so the answers could be anything and therefor imply nothing.

The reports are also consistent with angels - angels fly around, have capabilities beyond our technological understanding, and so on.

Your argument is fallacious because it's based on cherry picked, weak accounts that are inherently low-information, and said "it fits the theory".

I believe that 'aliens' exist. It just seems statistically likely, given the size of the universe. But I don't believe that there's other space-fairing life in our solar system, and the nearest celestial bodies are insanely far away. Trying to guess at what that sort of life would be like, how it would behave, or what evidence to expect, is again pointless - we have no information, it's totally baseless guessing.

The entire thing is nonsense. A theory that is based on a complete lack of information and evidence that itself lacks information.

Not compelling.

Personally, I think it's a combination of various perfectly terrestrial events:

1. People lying for attention (the vast majority)

2. Unmanned foreign vehicles that are actually spying on us

3. Equipment or natural aberration (weather events, smudges on lenses, equipment malfunction, lens glares, etc)

Note that unlike the alien theories...

The evidence for (1) and (3) is factual - repeatedly we have found this to be the case. (2) is the most fanciful, but requires far less of a leap of faith and fits within a context that we know does exist ie: technology we know publicly is under pursuit.

(1) Has been repeatedly the case

(2) Doesn't involve any insane advances in technology to explain some of these events, and we can understand the motivations as our own

(3) We know happens as well, as we have with (1)

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by ALittleLight on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:13AM (#27640370)
Let me rephrase things a little bit. Consider two realities, Reality A (RA) and Reality B (RB). In RA there are no aliens operating craft in our atmosphere and the report was motivated by your 3 explanations or similar. In RB there are aliens operating in our atmosphere. In which reality, RA, or RB, is the DNI report more likely to be published? I think the answer is clearly RB. For one thing, RB has all the same reasons for a fake report as RA and it has the reason of alien craft being observed.

The DNI report should update your beliefs about aliens in proportion to the extent which you think the report is more likely to be authored in RB relative to RA.

Of the three explanations you offer 1 and 3 have serious problems. The events in question are reported by multiple witnesses and sensors. It's not reasonable to suspect that sensors, in multiple modalities, malfunction in the same way that coincidentally coincides with the reports of human witnesses.

It's similarly not reasonable to think that human witnesses are lying for attention. They are faking the sensor reports? So they can get the attention of reporting something that might discredit or embarrass them? They collude with other human witnesses to do this? It just doesn't seem very reasonable.

Explanation 2 is more coherent. I don't think it is a good explanation because we have no reason to think that significantly more advanced flying technology is in the hands of our competitors. If it were, they would likely not both keep it secret from us, and repeatedly fly it in front of our airmen and sensors in broad daylight.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:22AM (#27640405)
> Consider two realities

We should not consider merely those two options, if you're speculating then there are a vast number of "possible" options that "cannot be ruled out". You're cherry picking, exhibiting confirmation bias etc. This is why there is a burden of proof on the hypothesis being proposed.

Disagree strongly with your "not reasonable" about sensors and people. A mish-mash of vague noisy readings cannot really be said to "coincide" much.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by ALittleLight on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:15AM (#27640680)
You can consider more realities than RA and RB, but RA and RB are still possible realities and what I wrote about them is still true. Even if you infinite other possibilities the relative likelihood of RA and RB still changes the way I describe.

If your radar reports some anomaly then the radar is probably malfunctioning. If the electro-optics report the same anomaly at the same time with the same characteristics, that's weird. If both these sensors, and others, agree on some strange data and you witness it with your own eyes and someone else does too... At some point you need to flip your conclusion from "sensor error" to "I'm observing something strange."

There's no basis that I'm aware of to refer to the observations as "A mish-mash of vague most readings".

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by staticassertion on Saturday June 26, 2021 @03:05PM (#27644833)
I don't care to really delve into why I think my theories are obviously correct. The problem is that your entire line of reasoning is broken. When your evidence is weak and your possibilities are infinite you can not say that the evidence changes your view on one of those infinite possibilities - that's just confirmation bias.
Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday June 26, 2021 @04:10AM (#27640094)
> I am saying that the findings of the report make aliens a more likely explanation.

> I don't know what evidence you would expect to see if alien technology was operating in our atmosphere, but the described observations seem consistent with that conclusion.

Could also be angels.

Or IMHO, what I want it to be is visitors from a parallel Earth where the dinosaurs never died out and instead developed a hyper-advanced civilisation. They're now crossing the multiverse (temporarily, that's why they vanish again) and looking at us in complete bemusement, much as we would look at a world where humanity dies out in a nuclear war, and rats evolve and civilise roughly to the level of ancient Egypt or Sumer.

The problem with "you cant rule it out", and "the facts fit the conclusion" thinking about such nebulous phenomena is that there are a vast or infinite number of things that "you can't rule out" and also "fit". It's true but it's a far weaker claim than it seems. What "I want" is just wishful: Your chosen scenario is vanishingly unlikely among them, and assembled out of scraps of pop culture anyway. That's why previous generations say witches, demons, angel's etc. Apophenia describes the person's inner world, as much as the external one. Isn't it convenient that its still such a such a nebulous phenomena?

This is why the burden of proof falls squarely on ruling it _in_.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by ALittleLight on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:26AM (#27640424)
It could be angels or alternate reality Earths or whatever. Your prior belief in those things matters and the extent to which you think the observations reported in the DNI report match what you would expect to see were any of those the source of the phenomenon.

I think there is good reason to believe that aliens exist (size of the universe, number of planets) and traveling between star systems is consistent with what we know of physics. I also think observing advanced technology in the form of objects flying in our atmosphere is consistent with the "alien craft operating in our atmosphere" explanation. A surprising observation that is consistent with a theory should add confidence to that theory.

"Burden of proof" is not a useful concept here. I am not saying "It was aliens." I am saying "There is no reason to think the report rules out aliens which the headline suggests, and, actually, the report is consistent with aliens and that's surprising."

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:30AM (#27640453)
> "Burden of proof" is not a useful concept here.

I disagree entirely. It is key. You are discarding rationality here.

The "alien craft operating in our atmosphere" explanation is basically ruled out by how it's always liminal observations, never progressing to solid evidence, always a good fit to the limits of the sensors.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by ALittleLight on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:22AM (#27640709)
You are failing to think rationally about probabilities in part because you attach to an idea like "burden of proof" which reduces to the discussion to something like "You can't prove to my satisfaction that it is aliens so I'll assume it's not." That's just ignoring the argument I've made above.

It's also not correct to say that there's never solid evidence. The DNI report suggests there is compelling evidence. I've not seen anything to suggest that the observed phenomenon are at the limits of our sensors.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:33AM (#27642192)
Burden of proof is irrational now? Rubbish. Have a nice day.
Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by double0jimb0 on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:02PM (#27638676)
Dude, the pentagon left the door wide open saying “we don’t have the technological capabilities to determine the origin of these phenomenon”. And that “we won’t be able to report the origin of these phenomenon until we have the technological capabilities to do so”. I mean what other answer is their besides “it’s aliens” (as in it’s non-human technology)

This report was an AP reading comprehension test.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:52AM (#27640557)
> I mean what other answer is their besides “it’s aliens”

Almost anything, really. But why not leap to the conclusion that you want it to be? I agree that it is a test of thought processes.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by anonAndOn on Friday June 25, 2021 @07:07PM (#27637344)
re #2: what's odd is that it is equipment failure that's been occurring for decades. One would hope that JIRA ticket wouldn't keep getting pushed back to the next sprint for 40+ years.
Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday June 26, 2021 @04:01AM (#27640048)
If it's not sensor artefacts, why have the readings not become clear over the last few decades, when the quality and quantity of sensors in use have improved by orders of magnitude? Why is it still liminal? Has the visibility of these things gotten worse in lockstep with the improvement in sensors?

Or (Occam's razor time) it was never real readings to begin with.

And, I never assumed a single cause and neither should you, don't oversimplify.

Every sensor has limits. There will be noise and artefact at those limits. You can't change that fact, with or without a f'n Jira.

Re:U.S. unable to explain more than 140 unidentified flying ... by gruez on Friday June 25, 2021 @07:32PM (#27637535)
That assumes it can be easily fixed, or is the same cause every time.