News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by aurizon on Thursday June 24, 2021 @08:20AM (#27616456)
Yes, this is what it was made for. I got mine up to $150,000 based on the annual increment and a few smart buy/sell. I wish I had bought $50,000 Apple at $2, it would have turned into $25 million. A few like Thiel do better. Want to hurt Thiel? Hurt us all is your only way. Block options etc, so only trading shares can go in. No 'popcorn' shares that expand by 100 to one or more after they vest etc.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by not2b on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:01PM (#27619525)
No, it isn't what it was made for. You're limited to a $2000 contribution. Claiming that the value of a share of PayPal was 1/10 of a cent was nonsense. He found a loophole, sure, but it's morally fraudulent even if legally allowed. To close the loophole, putting private shares into a Roth IRA should be banned because they have no true market price that indicates their worth.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by iammisc on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:01PM (#27620500)
> it's morally fraudulent even if legally allowed

Can you detail the immorality?

> To close the loophole, putting private shares into a Roth IRA should be banned because they have no true market price that indicates their worth.

Why should they be banned? Everything has a price. IIRC, in a self-directed IRA you can put anything... paintings, gold, collectibles, houses. Why not random shares?

I see a huge problem here. Roth IRAs were made with certain guarantees. That some people would make outsized returns in a country of almost 400 million should be expected. Why do we find it necessary to then go and 'get our fair share'? Didn't we already set the rules? Why must we now change them since some guy got lucky?

Ideally, we should just say 'good job Mr Thiel', you held up your end of the bargain and we'll hold up ours. The deal was already struck. This is why no one trusts the American government.

Also, I'd point out that the roth IRA mentioned here is only nominally worth $5b. If he were to sell all the shares there would likely be a huge drop in price. Either way, what goes unmentioned is that the $5b wouldn't be taxed anyway if it was all in unrealized capital gains.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by not2b on Thursday June 24, 2021 @08:26PM (#27625669)
The transaction was dishonest from day one. Those shares were worth more than 1/10th of a cent each. Had he offered to sell them at that point (if he were willing to do so and legally allowed) he would have gotten far more than that. He (rather, the company that he controlled) just declared a value by fiat.

The stock had no true market price because there was no market: at that point, the shares could not be sold to outsiders, so there were no willing buyers or sellers to set a price.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by silicon2401 on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:57PM (#27620428)
> He found a loophole, sure, but it's morally fraudulent even if legally allowed.

Morality is relative. You can't legally police other people based on your personal morality. To me, morality is maximizing your self-benefit, so there's nothing wrong with what Thiel did. If other people disagree, then there are plenty of avenues to campaign for outlawing what he did.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by icedchai on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:55PM (#27620373)
$2000 hasn't been the contribution limit for almost 20 years. It's $6K now, but we could argue that it's still not enough.

Private companies that are raising money have a valuation on them done periodically ("409A valuation"), and this is what private stock options and common shares are based on. This is the IRS's own rules.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by bklyn11201 on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:50PM (#27620282)
Precisely. Was anyone else allowed to buy Paypal shares at 1/10 of a cent in 1999? If he alone marked this price, how would it not be fraudulent?
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by jandrese on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:29PM (#27620993)
He basically bought those shares from himself, which is why he was able to set the price arbitrarily low.

The point of the Roth IRA is to encourage middle and lower class people to invest in their retirement by offering a tax incentive. But to avoid being abused by the rich the total yearly contribution limit is set very low. Thiel avoided this limit by simply selling himself a huge amount of stock for fractions of a penny on the dollar, knowing the actual price on the open market would be far higher. However, nobody can prove that the price of the private share would have been higher at the time because they weren't on a market.

It would be like if you were trying to avoid taxes by selling your 1,000 acre mansion to a LLC that you own for $1 and paying the tax on that $1. This doesn't work for real estate, but the Roth IRA system is not as sophisticated so you can get away with it.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by vmception on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:12PM (#27621674)
I dont find this to be a loophole, you just werent aware of it. A plain reading of the tax code would make that possibility fairly obvious.

This approach will just leave you surprised in the 2040s about what anybody with reading comprehension skills is doing in 2020s.

Also greater private equity access was just expanded in the tax code for tax deferred roth products. So the opposite is happening.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by s1artibartfast on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:34PM (#27621081)
>Claiming that the value of a share of PayPal was 1/10 of a cent was nonsense.

It was the valuation at the time and there is nothing illegal about that. You can invest your Roth in penny stocks or sub penny stocks today if you want.

The real question is if it was legal to purchase stocks in a company he also managed.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by medvezhenok on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:54PM (#27622255)
The only way that was a true valuation of the shares at the time would be if he were willing to sell those shares to someone else at that price ($0.001) at the end of 1999. If not, that's not true value, that's just accounting fraud.

For a valuation, there has to be a market and a market clearing price. If there is no market (no buyers and sellers), valuation is meaningless.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by s1artibartfast on Thursday June 24, 2021 @03:11PM (#27622493)
That's not how tax law works. When you found a company you buy founder's stock, with an initial valuation filed with the IRS and this is the value until the next qualified valuation event, where it may change. Share prices of $0.01 to $0.00001 are common. I guarantee that $0.001 was the founders share price filed with the IRS at company formation.

https://gust.com/launch/blog/how-to-value-startup-stock

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by machinebun on Thursday June 24, 2021 @05:22PM (#27623954)
Sure, $0.001 is the value on paper (and under current law). The point is, it's exploitable (let's say I'm an Apple engineer, I start a new company and get a wink wink from some friends in high places who want to invest in my company doing X. I put in my founders stock into IRA in return for first dibs on placement for the investor - 1 year later company has valuation, my stock has risen many %%. Sure, I'm technically doing everything legally, but practically it's somewhat equivalent to insider trading + avoids taxes).

I would personally ban non-public investments in Roth IRAs. That way a debate about market value doesn't have to happen.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by NonEUCitizen on Thursday June 24, 2021 @06:17PM (#27624571)
Many times, $0.001 turns out to be too high a value for startup shares -- a lot of startup shares end up being worth zero.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by s1artibartfast on Thursday June 24, 2021 @06:25PM (#27624669)
seems like the far better solution is banning IRA investments in your own company. This is the current law.

If you make a smart or lucky in somebody else's company, bitcoin, or whatever, it isn't an exploit, it is the point.

[dead]
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by dang on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:05PM (#27621574)
Please don't be an asshole on HN, no matter how uninformed someone else is or you feel they are. It only makes things worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by vernie on Thursday June 24, 2021 @11:01AM (#27618616)
The usual response to any criticism of Thiel on HN: Actually this rocks!
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by papito on Thursday June 24, 2021 @11:21AM (#27618919)
Any suggestion on HN that Peter Thiel is a shit-tier human and a monster will get you downvotes.

The funny thing is, there is never any verbal defense - just downvotes.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by peter422 on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:58PM (#27620437)
I thought his book on startups was very well done and interesting.

However this seems quite shady. The rich should still have to pay taxes.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by lotsofpulp on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:06PM (#27620595)
They do have to pay taxes. Maybe Congress should not pass laws that exempt them from paying taxes, or require them to pay more taxes.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by papito on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:38PM (#27621149)
Congress doesn't write laws - people like Peter Thiel do. You sound like these billionaires are innocent virgins. "Oppsies, I made all these billions because the incompetent congress let me do it". Uh huh.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by cinntaile on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:10PM (#27621651)
It's a pretty smart loophole but it's not like he came up with this. He has tax specialists for that. Now, it's probably not a good idea for loopholes like these to exist. Articles like these can certainly make a difference to close them. Although it's definitely not black and white, excluding private shares would be too broad imo but maybe a different mechanism to determine the value should be used.

More general I'd say Peter Thiel is both loved and hated and everything in between on HN, there is no real consensus.

Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by jrochkind1 on Friday June 25, 2021 @10:21AM (#27631096)
Why would excluding private shares be too broad? What portion of non-super-rich IRA's do you think have private shares in them? Probably approaching zero, right? Do people really need private shares to be able to set up retirement accounts? People can buy private shares when they have access to do so, they just can't use their IRA for it.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by cinntaile on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:59AM (#27641129)
I don't have any experience with the US tax system but where I live we have certain accounts that exclude private shares (and many other things). The main problem is valuing these shares correctly and if this can be done in an appropriate way I think it makes sense to not exclude them. For example... Private shares can be traded and are sometimes relatively liquid even though they're not public, in that case the trading price should be pretty representative of its real value.
Re:Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank by aurizon on Thursday June 24, 2021 @11:15AM (#27618823)
I did not criticise Thiel at all, he did well. That said he did have the ability to capture the entire leap from option pennies into mature trading stock at many many dollars, and roll that over a few times.