Try having one official mobile client and a web client. And if you don't like either one, you're out of luck - and then the service is out of luck when you stop using it in favor of one with better software.
The relationship between developers and service providers is ideally symbiotic.
Developers follow the money, and customers follow the developed products. It's a cycle. You can't just say 1 is the whole driving force when in reality, both are, and they drive each other as well.
So maybe in order to bootstrap a platform you need to attract a bunch of customers including a healthy number of developers. If devs like the platform and there are potential customers that could create a spark.
I don't buy this at all. In fact, I don't buy the conventional
wisdom that developers are what makes and breaks a platform.
Developers do what Deep Throat suggests: they follow the money.
Sure a large body of developers follow the money, but a fantastic minority go and develop compensation-less bits of software such as Linux, Apache, PHP, Python, Ruby, Rails, Django, MySQL, Postgresql, Redis, NodeJS, etc. (Of course, as the projects mature and get noticed, money will appear and developers will flock to these platforms, too; and, of course, public recognition is a currency, too) Devs are not a homogeneous bunch and, unlike other groups, they can significantly affect the trajectory of a platform. See: Lego Mindstorms.This is not to say that developers are magical and that users, marketers, etc are not needed.
It was naive to go into building on someone else's platform any other
way (yet many did seem to believe that Twitter was somehow "different").
Also apparently naive: Zynga, FriendFeed, TweetDeck, PopCap, etc.FriendFeed and TweetDeck got gobbled up by the companies owning the platform they work on, and PopCap got bought by EA. Zynga could be brought to heel in an instant if Facebook wanted, too.
Good point, although I wonder if it would do no harm to Facebook either. They appear to be in a symbiotic relationship at this point. I bet Zynga would love not to depend on Facebook and vice-versa. Zynga probably is already mulling (if not preparing for) about porting their stuff to google+, just in case. I wonder how would Facebook take that.
[1]: http://www.marco.org/2010/11/04/developers-dont-rush-to-new-...
Your argument is exactly why Google+ is so dangerous for facebook and twitter, both have a very tortured relationship with 3rd party developers so if Google releases an api for google+ that gives developers an opportunity to make just as much money as twitter/facebook ... developers are going to be throwing up deuces to them and moving over to google since they can make just as much money with less stress.
People often complain about the unpredictability and capriciousness of Apple's App Store policies yet it's still where developers flock to. Why? Because they make money. Those same policies arguably hurt developers but they definitely help the consumer, which ultimately does help the developer. Tae that as an example of developers not knowing what's good for them.
You see the same thing particularly in tech journalism: people often say the problem with, for example, Windows Phone 7 or WebOS is a lack of developers. No. The problem is a lack of users (and thus money to be made). Developers follow the money.
In the case of Twitter, I think it's downfall is that it is simply a very marginal product and has missed its opportunity to change that. Its usage is a lot lower than the number of accounts suggests [1]. I believe it was envisioned as a way of people sharing status updates in a more public fashion than Facebook. The reality of Twitter (IMHO) is that it's a way of following celebrities.
Twitter clients were doomed before they started, doomed to commoditization then cannibilzation that is. It was naive to go into building on someone else's platform any other way (yet many did seem to believe that Twitter was somehow "different").
I don't believe the existence of these apps is the reason for Twitter's success either. My personal opinion is that people decide to use Twitter and then look for an app to do it. Twitter lives and dies by the success of... Twitter.
[1]: http://www.businessinsider.com/chart-of-the-day-how-many-use...