News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by eli on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @08:02PM (#2757174)
DMCA takedown has pretty much the same weight as a cease & desist. DMCA does not really give you a bigger stick, instead it offers the recipient a carrot -- follow the rules and you won't be held responsible.

In both cases it's just a request and in both cases you'd have to file a lawsuit to force action.

Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by seabee on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:53AM (#2757957)
Sorry, no, that's just wrong. IANAL but it's rather clear that responding to DMCA takedowns is what grants you safe harbor protection, and such takedowns are made under penalty of perjury. Unless you are outside the US or you're happy to lose your protected status and get sued for copyright infringement whenever a user uploads copyrighted content, you can't just choose to disobey it because you feel like it.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by eli on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @08:00AM (#2758655)
Yes, that's my point. Respond to a DMCA according to the rules, or you could be sued. Likewise, respond to a C&D or you could be sued. In fact, since the C&D offers no safe harbor, you could be sued even if you do exactly what it asks.

The threat in both cases is the same. If anything the DMCA is weaker.

Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by seabee on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @10:25AM (#2759042)
You're mixing up the weight of the threat (that you could get sued for this) with the weight of the C&D itself, which at best means "I cared enough to pay a lawyer some comparatively small fee to write this for me" and in this case means bunk. You could even pretend you owned the image and that I broke a million laws, if you wanted - it's not legally binding.

Besides, sending a DMCA takedown doesn't bar the sender from suing you if you aren't an online service provider (e.g. you're a blogger using Wordpress.com, rather than Wordpress.com itself) or if you knew you hosted the supposedly infringing material in the first place. Both of these apply in this case.