News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by lr1970 on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:41AM (#27569855)
Can these companies still claim that they are "Equal Opportunities Employer" if they openly discriminate against residents of one state?
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fennecfoxen on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:03AM (#27570066)
The EEOC's guidance regarding pre-employment inquiries falls into the following categories, and state residence is not addressed:

- Race

- Height & Weight

- Financial Information

- Unemployed Status

- Background Checks

- Religious Affiliation Or Beliefs

- Citizenship

- Marital Status, Number Of Children

- Gender

- Disability

- Medical Questions & Examinations

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by hunter2_ on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:28AM (#27570347)
> Citizenship

Perhaps this category can be rescoped to include subnational citizenship.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizenship#Subnational

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fennecfoxen on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:40AM (#27570469)
Perhaps, but there is very little precedent for this in US law as it stands.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:17AM (#27570236)
Excluding candidates from Colorado will have disparate impact in every one of those categories.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fennecfoxen on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:27AM (#27570340)
Well, let's see. Colorado is 84% non-hispanic white, to the nation's 60% white, so yeah, there will totally be a disparate racial impact on white people. They're also 33% unaffiliated with religion, to the nation's 23%. Looks like the sex ratio is more or less identical to the national level.

I wish you luck making your case to the EEOC.

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by corin_ on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:43AM (#27570510)
That's fairly irrelevant considering it's true of any sample. Even excluding one single person has a "disparate impact" since it consists of 100% of one gender and 0% the other, etc. etc.

Since it's not targeted because of those categories not affecting exclusively those categories, it obviously wouldn't be covered.

(IANAL etc. but seems pretty clear.)

edit: more detailed explanation by fennecfoxen: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27570439

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 20, 2021 @11:36AM (#27571053)
> That's fairly irrelevant considering it's true of any sample.

Yes, that's pretty much the point I'm making. The same argument applies to all claims of disparate impact. It occurs in every sample.

> edit: more detailed explanation by fennecfoxen

That explanation does not reflect the law. (Nor does yours.) Recall that the first disparate impact case ruled it was illegal to preserve a requirement that the company had imposed prior to the civil rights act, because of the effect that requirement had on black applicants. The shift from this set of requirements:

   Must be white
   Must have a college degree
to this one:

   Must have a college degree
constitutes illegal discrimination against blacks. Obviously no one claimed that the degree requirement was intended to keep blacks out.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by Broken_Hippo on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:23AM (#27570291)
Sure, but none of those reasons are the reason for excluding Colorado candidates.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:29AM (#27570358)
So? The whole idea of disparate impact law is that the reason doesn't matter, only the effect.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fennecfoxen on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:37AM (#27570439)
Not so.

Disparate impact cases revolve around the reasoning for a rule. A rule which is "reasonably designed and administered to achieve a legitimate business purpose in light of the circumstances," including its potential harm to a protected class, is legitimate. This is why an employer like a fire department, or a moving company, can have fitness qualifications, even though these have a disparate impact on the elderly, while age is a protected class.

The EEOC identifies the following criteria to help evaluate the soundness of a rule:

- The extent to which the factor is related to the employer's stated business purpose;

- The extent to which the employer defined the factor accurately and applied the factor fairly and accurately, including the extent to which managers and supervisors were given guidance or training about how to apply the factor and avoid discrimination;

- The extent to which the employer limited supervisors' discretion to assess employees subjectively, particularly where the criteria that the supervisors were asked to evaluate are known to be subject to negative stereotypes;

- The extent to which the employer assessed the adverse impact of its employment practice on the protected class; and

- The degree of the harm to individuals within the protected class, in terms of both the extent of injury and the numbers of persons adversely affected, and the extent to which the employer took steps to reduce the harm, in light of the burden of undertaking such steps.

I'd comment on applying this to Colorado but it is meaningless because there's not actually a disparate impact.

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 20, 2021 @11:40AM (#27571109)
> This is why an employer like a fire department, or a moving company, can have fitness qualifications, even though these have a disparate impact on the elderly, while age is a protected class.

But note that fire departments can't have the same fitness qualifications for men and women. Age is a protected class; sex appears to be a more protected class.

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by humanistbot on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:57AM (#27570003)
As defined by US law, equal opportunity protections are only for the following classes: age, disability, sex, sexual orientation, national origin, race/color, and religion.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fallingknife on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:03AM (#27570059)
And on race "equal opportunity" means we can discriminate at will as long as it is against Asians or white people.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by umanwizard on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:09AM (#27570135)
No it doesn’t. Discriminating against any racial group — not just disadvantaged groups — in hiring is illegal
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fallingknife on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:24AM (#27570307)
Then how do companies have DEI policies for hiring and promotion?
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by umanwizard on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:30AM (#27570364)
Programs to increase diversity at the top of the hiring funnel (e.g., outreach to universities whose students are mostly from underrepresented groups) are legal, but taking race (or gender) into account for the actual hiring decision is not.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by dylan604 on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:03AM (#27570065)
My religion is of an open and free society. They practice said religion by passing laws that allow for data to be public, protecting what one does at home as private, etc.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by fennecfoxen on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:05AM (#27570085)
I suppose if you find an employer discriminating against you based on this religion — rather than based on your state of residence or the like — then you are welcome to file an EEOC complaint.
Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by seanmcdirmid on Sunday June 20, 2021 @09:47AM (#27569912)
It’s not like companies can just not open up offices in states whose laws they don’t like, no one is debating that they can’t do that. As for remote positions, it gets trickier: if the state has laws that have scope beyond the state if the company employs a resident, does the company still have a right to avoid employing in that state for positions that do not have fixed office locations? EOE just means you don’t discriminate along some protected classes, employers can still discriminate for legitimate reasons (degree status, citizenship status, work experience, criminal record, etc…).

The courts might have to work out whether state residency is a protected class or not.

Re:Many companies want remote workers, except from Colorado by bitexploder on Sunday June 20, 2021 @10:25AM (#27570315)
It just becomes so obvious and blatant for these remote roles. There are a lot of other justifications to not have an office in a state.