News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by geraldalewis on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @05:32PM (#2756701)
I can set my Canon to take a picture after a 10 second delay, so that I don't have to be in the presence of my camera to take a picture. Canon does not own the image, simply because it activated the triggering mechanism.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by danilocampos on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @05:50PM (#2756761)
You activated the triggering mechanism. Its delay is inconsequential, whether it is 10ms or 10 minutes, since you are the proximate cause of the capture.

These primates composed and snapped the photos themselves, unaided, on their own initiative. The providence of the camera doesn't make the camera's owner the copyright holder, any more than using a rented camera makes the rental company owner of the resulting images. Composition and shot timing are the two primary creative acts in photography — the monkeys did both.

Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by Terretta on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @07:16PM (#2757059)
In further support of this, the photographer didn't "activate the triggering mechanism" by even intentionally leaving the camera in hopes to have them take the photos.

I'd argue that a tripwire or any other mechanism of photographer intent to have the animals photograph themselves, would be akin to setting the timer. But, he says it was accidental:

> One of them must have accidentally knocked the camera and set it off because the sound caused a bit of a frenzy, said Slater, 46.

Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by derobert on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @10:57PM (#2757596)
Copyright (under US law) is for creative acts. The creativity in a photograph is things like setting up the shot, framing it, choice of subjects, lighting, angle, aperture, focus, etc.

If there is no creativity, there is no copyright. See Feist.

So the delay, and even who presses the button doesn't matter; the only thing that matters is who is responsible for the creative aspects of the photograph.

And, in this case, whether a non-human can, as a legal matter, create an "original work of authorship".

Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by tb on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:17AM (#2757861)
The monkeys took many photos, most of which were out of focus or poorly composed. Could not sorting through the essentially random photos that the monkeys took, and selecting those with most artistic potential, and perhaps cropping them to improve the composition, be considered a creative act?
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by derobert on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @03:17PM (#2760210)
Sorting through them might be making a compilation, which has separate protection under copyright law. It wouldn't extend to the photos in the compilation, but only the compilation itself…

I have no idea if sorting through monkey photos would count, that's a question best addressed to an IP lawyer.

Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by Natsu on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @04:25AM (#2758267)
Cropping photos I could possibly believe to be a creative act, but I would find it absurd to consider selecting only the in-focus photos to be a "creative" act. I would put that decision on par with alphabetizing the phone book.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by tb on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @05:00AM (#2758311)
"Selecting those with most artistic potential" were the exact words I used. The fundamental question is whether "found art" is copyrightable.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by bluedanieru on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:00AM (#2757972)
Ask yourself this question again but forget that monkeys took the photos. Who would own the copyright in that case?
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by tb on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:50AM (#2758084)
The person who took the photos, since that would be the creative act. Sorting through the photos and selecting the good ones is also a creative act, but it is a derivative work because the original images are copyright protected. The difference comes about because monkeys are not capable of owning copyright, and hence are not capable of "creative acts" as far as copyright is concerned.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by monochromatic on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @05:48PM (#2756754)
That's not really comparable. You yourself would hold copyright under those circumstances.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ... by Joakal on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @09:27PM (#2757403)
What if the camera falls out of a ripped bag at an airport by a handler and upon hitting concrete, button-first, it takes a picture that would go on to become incredibly popular?

Stakeholders: 1) Owner of bag may claim that it was done on purpose. 2) Owner of camera for the trigger-like aim despite it only happening to camera under severe stress. 3) Baggage handler initiated despite being unaware that the camera took a picture at all until news came out. 4) Baggage company due to contract clause.