News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by tolbish on Saturday June 19, 2021 @12:37PM (#27561981)
Can we also offer tax credits to encourage making the next hardware innovation hub somewhere other than Phoenix, Arizona? I thought the southwest is being ravaged by the effects of climate change (120+ degree weather, massive droughts)
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewmcwatters on Saturday June 19, 2021 @02:23PM (#27562965)
We might be on fire, but doing business here is excellent. I'm fine being quoted on that.

It's just about a joke anywhere else I've seen. Such as annual fees just to maintain an LLC. As if you're not already paying a high effective tax rate.

The cost of living and cost of doing business doesn't make much sense in other major metros. Unfortunately, so many people are coming here that it's raising our COL, too.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by CameronNemo on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:36PM (#27565142)
The cost of living and cost of doing business doesn't make much sense in other major metros.

Then explain all of the people living and doing business in other metros out west? Must have made sense for them...

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewmcwatters on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:51PM (#27566683)
Sure; I'm positive it made more sense in the past when COL of those locations wasn't as high as it is now. Depending on your line of business, there are some great market hubs out west, but now they're saturated and fully taken advantage of by incumbents looking to capitalize on those who thought the allure was worth it.

Except cost is important. Especially when you're a small business. When you see that cost of living and cost of maintaining is business is higher than you'd like, you're free to say, "No thanks," which is what plenty of businesses out here did.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by wolverine876 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @03:16PM (#27563505)
> It's just about a joke anywhere else I've seen.

Wow, you encompass a lot of very successful communities and businesses with that statement.

> Such as annual fees just to maintain an LLC.

I don't know what you mean exactly, but I've never heard a businessperson complain about such fees.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewmcwatters on Saturday June 19, 2021 @03:41PM (#27563737)
Well, hello then. Here I am, complaining. Operating costs for a business to simply exist should be nothing. Free. Nada. It should cost 0 for some database entry to exist in a corporation directory. Oh, and if you're interested in that, welcome to Arizona.

You're already paying taxes. You're already paying insurance. You're already taking on risk. There should be absolutely no friction to take on risk and start an enterprise. Leave that friction to all the other places that make sense like taking out a loan, building your brand, establishing a network.

And yet, if you wanted to expand to other countries, you have to pay sometimes thousands of dollars annually just to exist as a foreign corporate entity. It's nonsense. It's just a money grab for certain regions. As if you paying those contractors or employees isn't directly injecting capital into those economies.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by thevagrant on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:30PM (#27565521)
It used to be that way where I live. Zero fees to register and maintain registration. What happened was the register became a target for money laundering shell companies. Companies would be owned in complex layers by other shell companies (hundreds of layered companies to make investigating ownership too difficult). The govt added registration fees and annual renewal to help resource the register to improve it's system and ensure that the database maintained its purpose.

Many argue for paying less taxes but we might want to look closely at where we live and consider whether our locality is truly well resourced in all walks of life. Has all infrastructure been built and maintained to perfection? If yes, then maybe it is worth arguing for reducing fees/taxes but I don't know that this utopia exists yet.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by rapind on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:37PM (#27565155)
This sounds like a really good point to me. If a politician wants to encourage small businesses, why not remove all fees to get up and running? Maybe provide free lawyering and business plan consulting as well?

Too often incentives are locked behind a bunch of paperwork and hoops which require up front capital to take advantage of. Which creates a market for third parties to benefit from by charging for these services, instead of founders benefiting directly.

A great example of a horrible incentives program that results in this is SR&ED in Canada. I guess you could argue it employs a bunch of service providers to assemble SR&ED claims... so jobs?

You also pay at least $600 to incorporate in Canada and most often employ a lawyer to do it for you ($1,200+). Seems pretty counter intuitive if your goal is to promote startups and small business.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewflnr on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:35PM (#27566612)
As a recent small business starter, the most valuable thing to me would have been a complete, authoritative checklist of all the steps needed. All the licenses, registrations, etc, and dependencies between them. Sure, it will need a bit of customization for each business (need food service license?), but if it's still ambiguous after that, fix the law so it's not ambiguous.

I generally think it's a human rights violation that law is so impenetrable to the people who are supposed to follow it, but it's especially obvious in this case that murkiness helps literally no one.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by wolverine876 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:58PM (#27565300)
An argument in theory, but in practice it has no bearing on starting a business. You can complain all you want, but in my entire career you are the first. If I was doing business with you and you were wasting your time on this issue (as opposed to chatting on HN) (edit: or, goodness forbid, choosing a business location based on it), I would question your business sense. Surely there are a million things you could do with greater ROI.

In theory, a business receives very many services from government, such as entire systems of infrastructure (which itself is composed of systems of transport, energy, etc.) and law. The fees are a fantastic deal.

[dead]
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by wolverine876 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @11:25PM (#27566830)
Another thing I've learned over many years: If someone is using insults then they are out of ideas.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewmcwatters on Sunday June 20, 2021 @12:54AM (#27567187)
I mean there's nothing you're contributing by saying I'm the first person you've come across that's complained about fees. So what?

You're just antagonizing to antagonize. But my business sense is fine, thanks. I'm pretty sure retiring in my 20s allows me to say that.

Maybe you know something I don't, though, having accumulated this knowledge over many years; I'm open to learning new things if you're open to contributing something useful.

Maybe if you wanted to make your point you could at least say something about effective tax rates in the most populous metro areas, or state-by-state annual fees or corporate requirements, or literally anything.

But my guess is you don't have any of that information to provide. In business there aren't "a million things you could do with greater ROI."

You form a business, you sell goods and services, and you focus on the maybe 5 or so things that are relevant to your industry. All of this other imprecise talk is just online blabber.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by wolverine876 on Monday June 21, 2021 @03:32AM (#27577090)
More personal attacks, and now fabricating my motives. As I said, you must be out of ideas. I'm moving on.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by CameronNemo on Saturday June 19, 2021 @06:33PM (#27565124)
If you can't scrounge up a few hundred to register an LLC ($140 in Washington from what I read), how the hell are you going to order any kind of computer hardware? Prototypes can cost thousands.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewflnr on Saturday June 19, 2021 @10:29PM (#27566570)
We're not just talking about hardware startups, but tiny service businesses and the like. While getting off the ground, they might have minimal startup expenses but also near zero revenue. You might say they should wait until they have more revenue, but there's no good reason to force them to register an LLC later, with all the pointless change to bank accounts and such that entails, if you don't need to. I mean, I don't hate that I paid $50 or so (IIRC) to register my VA LLC, but any more than that is getting to be a bit much.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewmcwatters on Sunday June 20, 2021 @01:02AM (#27567237)
I think you just have an incomplete picture. Most LLCs, most small businesses, are nearly indistinguishable from individual income in terms of revenue simply because a large portion of them are single-member.

So that being said, there's little to no difference between these individuals complaining about non-commercial fees, and commercial fees.

Fees are fees. And these ones don't make any sense.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by unstatusthequo on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:35PM (#27565559)
How’s that new income tax hike in AZ treating you?
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by andrewmcwatters on Monday June 21, 2021 @10:50AM (#27579716)
Doesn’t affect most of us.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by GoOnThenDoTell on Saturday June 19, 2021 @02:11PM (#27562842)
Seismic stability is apparently a big plus for the area
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by bgorman on Saturday June 19, 2021 @12:42PM (#27562019)
The water used by a chip factory is almost 100% recycled
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by farco12 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @01:34PM (#27562473)
Do you mind providing a source for that claim?

I've seen several articles[1] mentioning that the current Taiwanese semiconductor shortage has a lot to do with water rationing due to drought. Do semiconductor manufacturers in Taiwan not recycle water like semiconductor manufacturers in Phoenix?

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-chip-shortage-is-bad-taiwan...

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by franknine on Saturday June 19, 2021 @02:58PM (#27563315)
Semiconductor manufacturers in Taiwan are mostly around the Hsinchu area. They paid a premium to truck water from other areas and the government limited agricultural activities in Hsinchu as well. They almost got affected, but then there was a heavy rain in late May and the water rationing was lifted for Hsinchu.

Currently COVID poses a larger threat to semiconductor production as multiple COVID clusters are detected in packaging/testing plants.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by BlueTankEngine on Saturday June 19, 2021 @01:52PM (#27562650)
Pretty sure the OP is right, not sure about Taiwan

Source: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/06/04/why-intel-tsmc-are -building-water-dependent-chip-plants-in-arizona.html

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by pretendscholar on Saturday June 19, 2021 @02:38PM (#27563115)
It says page not found.
Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by bellyfullofbac on Saturday June 19, 2021 @04:13PM (#27564009)
You should notice that the text after the URL still looks like a URL, so there must've been an extra space in the middle of it...

Feel free to burn this comment to the ground, but is this really the level of HN reader nowadays? Can't even notice a spurious space...

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by KingMachiavelli on Saturday June 19, 2021 @01:11PM (#27562267)
So they would be OK paying a 10x price premium? at least that would be the easiest way to determine if the claim is true.

At least in Taiwan earlier this spring was facing a drought which came close to impacting semiconductor production.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by bpodgursky on Saturday June 19, 2021 @01:34PM (#27562467)
That requires individual states to be tax and business friendly. The Northeast and Pacific rim no longer make any attempt at this. The rust belt tries sometimes, but flip politically too often for companies to make big investments.

There's nothing meaningful congress can do to order states to be friendly to business.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by wolverine876 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @03:20PM (#27563544)
That depends on your definition of tax and business friendly. Note that the Northeast and Pacific Rim have produced far more success and wealth in business than other places, probably more than any places in the history of the world, without exaggeration.

Taxes are the front end transaction of investment, in education, infrastructure, courts, support for workers and families, etc. Those things are very business friendly. Low tax areas, which lack this investment, don't have a great history with businesses.

Re:U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor ma... by gremloni on Saturday June 19, 2021 @07:19PM (#27565449)
What’s wrong with 120+ degree weather? It’s fantastic in my opinion.