So basically, in order for it to equal the cost of a comparable product, you have to get the DVD and watch it the same night, then ship it back and hope 2.75 days is enough for Netflix to ship you another one.
Don't know about others here, but I don't really get time to watch DVDs during work days. This leaves the weekend, so for $8 a month, I can rent 2 DVDs per weekend and receive greater amount of entertainment during a more convenient time.
So using your example of 4 DVDs per month, that's $2 per with Netflix or $1 (50% less) per with box rental services. So in terms of actual spending, you are still only saving 4 bucks (not even a cup of coffee), but % wise, you save 50%.
(and yes, I go to the store regularly, so I'm not counting cost of gas in this example)
Now, if they only had the latest stuff in the streaming catalog... that would be entirely different story.
But the big draw of Netflix DVD by mail is its enormous back catalog. The size of the Redbox library pales in comparison.
I want to stream everything but I can't, so I still get DVDs. And since I still get DVDs they need to raise the price on me.
If they just came out and said "Sorry we don't have more digital content available." there wouldn't be an issue. Instead they are acting shocked I'm not satiated with their anemic online offering.
Bonus Fact: Netflix and Groupon have the same operating cost yet Groupon offers no physical or digital products.
How do you abuse a plan advertised as "unlimited"?
Percentage-wise while it sounds a huge increase, it is absolutely nothing when you look at the real dollars. My cell phone bill is $100+, ISP is $70+, web hosting is $30+, and I pay $10+/month for many different web services (include many startups I found via HN). How is $8/mo for renting 3-4 DVDs a month too high? Sure, it was $2 before but you can't expect any company to make money on deals that get abused by more than a few.
I'd rather have Netflix charge their customers appropriately than go out of business or start nickel and diming like airlines or cellphone companies.