News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by saurik on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:07PM (#27541889)
FWIW, I had understood it first try, but I do agree that it is a bit strange as the normal way of phrasing this would be "Amazon reducing their cut of developer revenue from...".
Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by chrisseaton on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:13PM (#27541956)
How did you disambiguate ‘developer revenue cut’ to be Amazon’s cut not the developer’s? Since it says ‘developer’ not ‘Amazon’.

And weirder than that it’s not Amazon’s cut of the developer’s ‘revenue’ either - since the developer was never getting it in the first place - it’s their cut of the sale price, or the combined revenue, not the developer’s revenue.

Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by saurik on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:26PM (#27542087)
1) We normally don't talk about the developer / manufacturer getting a cut: we talk about the middleman / sales channel "taking their cut", so inherently the word "cut" is biased to make it at least sort of understandable.

2) And no: developer "revenue" is the full cost of the receipt, and then a cost of their doing business is the cut taken by the platform, which decreases their resulting "income". The word "revenue" specifically is a number from which you deduct costs to obtain "income".

Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by chrisseaton on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:30PM (#27542127)
I think revenue is money you get your hands on, and then pay costs out of. If you never get your hands on it then it's not your revenue, it's someone else's revenue that they're paying their costs - your developer fee - out of. Like a singer's revenue is not all record sales as they're not selling the records they've just licensed someone else to do so and they're getting a cut (wait... so that's cut the other way around...)
Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by saurik on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:56PM (#27542415)
So, the definition "money you get your hands on" definitely isn't correct, and the way to make this clearer is to think of it in terms of credit card processing and merchant accounts: if you sell a $5 product and the credit card processor takes $0.25, your revenue is $5, not $4.75, and they actually will report the full $5 to the government as part of a 1099-K and then your job is to report that full gross income and deduct the fees you paid. They also will report any sales you made which were refunded, and you would then separately report deductions for that also.

Now, that said, one can actually use that construction to argue that the store is then having revenue, and giving a royalty to the developer or something, and in fact my store did something where I sometimes modeled it as a retail storefront of licenses I purchased wholesale, but these are just not normal models for how the word "cut" is then applied: most people reasonably--and I think correctly--believe that the user bought something from the developer, with the store acting merely as a middleman payment processor charging a "fee" or taking a "commission" off of every sale (and I am pretty sure at least Google even models it directly in that way in its reports; there are a ton of advantages to the store to doing that, and I think even Apple sometimes reaches for this model).

From such standpoint, and to look at this using descriptive linguistics, you simply don't ever see anyone say "Apple recently increased the cut of smaller developer's from 70% to 85%": every single headline I've seen says "Apple recently decreased their cut from smaller developers from 30% to 15%".

Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by gouggoug on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:12PM (#27542603)
> How did you disambiguate ‘developer revenue cut’ to be Amazon’s cut not the developer’s? Since it says ‘developer’ not ‘Amazon’.

To me it's because in my mind "Amazon" is the person taking a "cut".

We never say "developers take 70% cut of the app store revenue", because developers don't "take a cut", they sell, and amazon takes a cut of their sale.

Still, I agree, the title is ambiguous.

Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by cortesoft on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:52PM (#27542379)
It made sense to me the first time I read it because I know most app stores appear to have settled around 30% as their cut, so I just assumed the 30% referred to the amount Amazon was taking. The rest just followed logically.
Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by mistersquid on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:04PM (#27542519)
> How did you disambiguate ‘developer revenue cut’ to be Amazon’s cut not the developer’s? Since it says ‘developer’ not ‘Amazon’.

Amazon to reduce its cut of dev revenue from 30% to 20% with 10% in AWS Credit

or

Amazon to reduce its cut of dev revenue from 30% to 20% plus 10% in AWS Credit

Re:Amazon Appstore will reduce its developer revenue cut by ant6n on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:40PM (#27546087)
Amazon is reducing their fee