News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by criddell on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:41AM (#27540838)
They said "typically", so they aren't saying it's true in all cases, but generally when a person is trying to evade some legal authority, it's probably not for reasons good for society.
Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by thebean11 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:45AM (#27540896)
They are trading one legal authority for another, and this is agreed upon up front. Both parties agree that the code is the legal authority before entering into a contract, which is much different from evading authority after the fact.

> but generally when a person is trying to evade some legal authority, it's probably not for reasons good for society

Reminds me of the "nothing to hide" argument, that only someone trying to commit a crime would need or want protection from the legal system. History paints a different picture.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by RandomLensman on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:08PM (#27541190)
Courts remain the legal authority, you cannot trade on for other unless provided by law (as in statute), and then it is back again to the courts to interpret. What did both parties really agree to? IANAL, but intentions and assumptions of the parties can matter - for example, quite a few things you cannot waive in some places, irrespective of what you agree or not.
Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by gknoy on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:53PM (#27541717)
I don't know. I'm not a lawyer, but I recall that when it comes to contracts, they often allow you to waive protections that the law would normally give you (e.g., specifying that conflict is resolved with arbitration) if both parties agree to it.

In the case of smart contracts, where both parties (if I understand it right?) agree that the code defines the contract itself, it seems like saying "... but I made a mistake" (or it has an error) would be very hard to prove. It would be like if you had written in a 3 year no-questions-asked return period into a car contract, rather than a 3 day one, and then tried to litigate when someone actually used that.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by ska on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:28PM (#27542795)
> hey often allow you to waive protections ... if both parties agree to it.

This is not really generalizable. Arbitration clauses for example waive one method of recourse in favor of another method of recourse, both already accepted by the courts. I expect you couldn't replace that with trial by combat and expect it to hold in court, but you might be able to argue that a different resolution process with historical precedent would hold - at least you could test it in court.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by perl4ever on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:11PM (#27545900)
I'm not particularly knowledgeable on the topic, but there are all sorts of religious courts (at least in the US). Generally they coexist with the secular legal system.

https://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/08/applying-gods-law-religi...

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by ska on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:35PM (#27546052)
Yes that's true, but again it's a case where (a) both parties agreed to (b) a recognized form of resolution, in this case mediation - you can do this with a secular mediator also. In general they don't "coexist" so much as they are subsumed within, as allowable forms of resolution, within prescribed bounds.

Important to note that the courts already recognize and/or have precedence for this, and also there are limits to what you can shift here. Finally if the resolution process is not acceptable to one party there are ways to bump it back to the courts.

None of this applies to "smart contracts", which aren't contracts in the legals sense anyway. There is no (yet?) agreement by the courts that this is a valid resolution method, and any issues of contractual law brought before a civil court will be resolved by legal principles, not source code. I suspect that the best you could hope for in the current setting is that the source code + associated communications speaks to intent.

There's no reason to believe that it is impossible that US courts and/or legislation would at some point give some legal status to a smart contract beyond above, but that's not the case today as far I know.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by ineedasername on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:14AM (#27547289)
There are certain rights you can't waive. But that aside, the issue at hand is what happens when there is a mistake in the smart contract, unintended by either party? Who decides what happens? In this case IRON could even hypothetically claim (true or not) "nope, not a bug, the contract will stay in it's null indeterminate state, and in the meantime we'll be using that USDC as collateral for 30-year US treasury bonds. 2% isn't much, but it sure does add up nicely on $250+ million."

Or something like that. I doubt that's how it will go down here, but it will take a human judgement call or agreement-- not a coded contract-- to resolve this.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by shkkmo on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:40PM (#27542254)
You can amend some legal requirements, but certainly not all. There are many, many restrictions on the types of contracts that are legally enforceable.

> but I made a mistake" (or it has an error) would be very hard to prove

I don't think it would be that hard to prove that the implementation of a smart contract doesn't match the clear intent. The bigger issue isn't the disputability of the contract, but the difficulty of identifing who you would take to court.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by RandomLensman on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:41PM (#27542270)
That is somewhat a US/Common Law perspective, in places with codified civil law might be tougher/different (but again, IANAL - just from experience doing complex contracts)
Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by cool_dude85 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:03PM (#27541128)
>They are trading one legal authority for another, and this is agreed upon up front. Both parties agree that the code is the legal authority before entering into a contract, which is much different from evading authority after the fact.

The parties might "agree", but who cares? If they are in the US, for example, and the two parties have a smart contract that breaks US contract law, one of the parties can file a lawsuit and attempt to get their money back. You can't go to the judge and say "sorry, the code is the legal authority here".

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by thebean11 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:12PM (#27541238)
Yeah I agree with that. Once the contract has executed, enforcement actions can certainly happen in meatspace. But do you not see the difference between:

1. A normal contract (legal or illegal) that requires outside enforcement in the first place to force parties to comply.

2. A smart contract (legal or illegal) that executes itself without outside enforcement and can be overturned later (not literally overturned, but a subsequent transaction can be forced) by meatspace mechanisms

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by RandomLensman on Thursday June 17, 2021 @12:33PM (#27541491)
The vast majority of contracts in (1) does not need enforcing, because it is in both parties interest (at least long-term) to perform. Yes, there is implicit enforcement to some extent, but then "non-society" which don't even have that are not pretty places to be.

On (2), sure we can find ways to have the execution fail. In fact, anything where there is not fully escrowed payment/collateral/etc. can fail to execute properly if the other side does have not what it needs to deliver/or does not make it available on chain.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by thebean11 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:10PM (#27541926)
> The vast majority of contracts in (1) does not need enforcing

Of course, people are very careful prior to entering those contracts, because they know how big of a headache it will be if enforcement is needed!

> In fact, anything where there is not fully escrowed payment/collateral/etc. can fail to execute properly if the other side does have not what it needs to deliver/or does not make it available on chain.

Well, sure, if you write a contract that makes it possible for one side not to pay up, then that might happen. Having software run escrow is basically the whole point..

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by RandomLensman on Thursday June 17, 2021 @01:36PM (#27542198)
Most contracts are so basic as to be invisible, so no, people are not very careful when they buy a chocolate bar, for example

If you want smart contracts to be only applicable to very narrow sets of problems so be it, but otherwise you need to be able to allow, for example, unsecured lending and highly uncertain payoffs at T0 (staying in the finance domain)

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by thebean11 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:09PM (#27542566)
> people are not very careful when they buy a chocolate bar

Ok..sure, but I think it's sort of pedantic to bring up a class of contract that, obviously, nobody in this thread is talking about. It's a bad example anyway; even if you are being pretty careful it's simply not a risky transaction and therefor out of scope for complicated enforcement mechanisms like smart contracts.

I don't think smart contracts are very well suited to unsecured lending, at least not with available software. There would be no incentive to pay it back without some mechanism to force collections. Collateralized loans, however, is a great use case that exists already.

This is early stage tech, the scope is pretty small. I don't think anybody is arguing the contrary.

Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by porknubbins on Thursday June 17, 2021 @10:41PM (#27546849)
Freedom of contract is pretty well respected in the US, there are very few exceptions where carve outs are made where people are not allowed to contract freely. So its not clear what a “smart contract that breaks US contract law would be”, its much more likely for a smart contract to be a outright scam or illegal though, in which case good luck finding the funds or whom to sue.
Re:The collapse of the IRON stable coin by ineedasername on Thursday June 17, 2021 @11:58PM (#27547214)
Agreeing the code is the legal authority means implicitly believing the code is perfect: no bugs, no unanticipated edge cases. Which is just not realistic. So when they arise, who decides what happens?