I don't agree. I know Microsoft will move or even outright delete important content because chasing shiny new ideas will get somebody promoted. And so I direct people away from Microsoft solutions because that's going to make my life easier.
Any link to Microsoft documentation that doesn't both go via aka.ms and have a significant user community to ensure the aka.ms link stays correct will decay until it's useless.
So by the time you read this https://aka.ms/trustcertpartners may point at a page which is now styled as a wiki or a blog post or a video, but it will get you the list of CAs trusted by Microsoft's products.
However links from that page (e.g. to previous lists) are internal Microsoft links and so, unsurprisingly, they've completely decayed and are already worthless.
For the US Treasury, just like Congress or the Air Force, I don't have some alternative choice, so it doesn't really matter whether I think they're good or bad at this. But Microsoft is, to some extent at least, actually in a competitive business and I can just direct people elsewhere.
I don't doubt there is a narrower tech audience (e.g. HN) that would base tech stack strategy on which company has the most 404 errors but my comment was specifically responding to the author's use of "generally".
I interpreted "they generally lose confidence in the owner of the server" -- as making a claim about the psychology of the general public non-techie websurfers. TBL had an intuition about that but it didn't happen. Yes, people are extremely annoyed by 404 errors but history has shown that websurfers generally accept it as a fact of life.
In any case, to followup on your perspective, I guess it's possible that somebody avoided C# because the Microsoft website has too many 404 errors and chose Sun Java instead. But there were lots of broken links in sun.java.com as well (before and after Oracle acquisition) so I'm not sure it's a useful metric.
Ah, so that’s why Microsoft’s financials have been tanking.
Do the other providers that you recommend in place of Microsoft have a better record of not changing/removing URIs on their website?
I was originally going to say that although the links on the Microsoft page currently work they can't be expected to stay working. They had worked when I last needed them after all. But that was at least a year ago and so I followed one, and sure enough meanwhile Microsoft had once again re-organised everything and broke them all ...
Even the link to their current list as XML (on Microsoft's site) from this page is broken, it gives you some XML, as promised, but I happen to know the correct answer and it's not in that XML. Fortunately the page has off-site links to the CCADB and the CCADB can't be torched by somebody in a completely different department who wants to show their boss that they are an innovator so the data in there is correct.
Microsoft provides customer facing updates for this work by the way. The current page about that assures you that updates happen once per month except December, and tell you about January and February's changes. Were there changes in March, April, or May? Actually I know there were, because Rob Stradling (not a Microsoft employee) mirrors crucial changes to a GitHub repository. Are they documented somewhere new that I couldn't find? Maybe.
No, but some of us do get incredibly pissed off with them.
It's unendingly tiresome to find that some piece of content has disappeared from the web, or been moved without a redirect. Often archive.org can help but there's plenty of stuff that's just ... gone.
I don't necessarily run into this problem every day, but anything up to two or three times a week depending on what I'm looking for.
Is <10% worth caring about? It's certainly not the difference between life and death for almost everyone; no successful business or website is going to shut down because they had ads, or because they broke old URLs. On the other hand, <10% is hardly trivial, people work hard for things that gain a lot less than that, and really, is defining redirects that hard?
You can get away with it when you are "the government .gov", but if you are "small start-up.com" and I want to invest in your risky stocks and all I get is an "Oops page" when I want to know a little more about your dividend policy, I'm gone.
I do, to a degree. When I follow some old link to a site and realize they've changed their structure and provided no capability to find the original article if it's still available but at a new URI, I lose confidence.
Not in them overall, but in their ability to run a site that's easy to find what you want and that's usefulness over time isn't constantly undermined. I lose confidence in their ability to do that, which affects how I view their site.
> ... and the link is broken now in 2021. I don't think that broken link shakes the public's confidence in the US government.
Maybe not the Govt itself, but in their ability to provide information through a website usefully and in a way that's easy to understand and retains its value? I'm not sure most people had the confidence to begin with required for them to lose it.
I'm sure that wouldn't have been an issue if it was super popular and respected, but it was already fading away at that point.
However, it is extremly annoying and it happend to me just recently with Microsoft, when I researched PWAs... I had bookmarked a link to their description on how PWAs are integrated into Microsoft Store. I could only find it on archive.org...
With 2+ decades to look back on after this was written, it turns out the author was wrong about this. Web surfers often get 404 errors or invalid deep links get automatically redirected to the main landing page -- and people do not lose confidence in the site owner. Broken links to old NYTimes articles or Microsoft blog posts don't shake the public's confidence in those well-known companies. Link rot caused by companies reorganizing their web content is just accepted as a fact of life.
This was the 2013 deep link I had to USA Treasury rates: http://www.treasurydirect.gov/RI/OFNtebnd
... and the link is broken now in 2021. I don't think that broken link shakes the public's confidence in the US government. Instead, people just use Google/Bing to find it.