The theory about Pacific islanders has evidence; the above does not.
> It's fantasy science
That's a fantasy comment.
not really. Their ships (even quite large ones for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olympias_(trireme)#/media/File...) weren't ocean going (like for example giving the way of construction the hulls wouldn't have been able to sustain the heavy waves stress for many days, etc.). To compare this is an example of the ocean going ships - Viking drakkar - in which Americas were first reached:
https://youtu.be/XORSpUUy0lQ?list=RDCMUCNnLNJLZj11RlFYq4HZ6c...
Nobody is gonna sail a warship with a huge expensive crew across the ocean without a damn good reason. Such reason almost certainly never materialized, that's a given.
But local mediteranean cargo vessels are more than seaworthy enough to cross the Atlantic in the same way that I can haul 3000lb in a Ford Ranger. Water and navigation will be your issues. The capability to get it done with not that much luck needed is there. I can't think of is why someone would both have the requisite provisions and a reason to sail west for weeks on end other than a "Skydiving From Space, Brought to you by Red Bull(TM) " style vanity project. And the economic surpluses at the time simply weren't large enough to support a lot of that kind of activity so it's doubtful anyone would have done it.
It is however, the class of outcome I think should definitely be considered plausible, and possible.
But that also admits the plausibility of Phoecians, Romans, reaching the Americas. Could have, but didn't to the best of our knowledge.
Because of a culture of glass and metalworking, they're both outcomes we could expect to "prove" by archeological finds. Coastal locations to 100km inland might withstand the timescale, and yield something, but its needle in a haystack time, and the vikings didn't leave very much behind. (a counter example we have higher confidence in, which yields very little structural evidence)
I do think pacific/island stone tools would stand the same test, but I can't see how an "edge" to antarctica would sustain preservation of worked tools. If you found them in the continental offshore ooze, that would be amazing. (or for that matter, roman artifacts offshore of the americas)
It's fantasy science, but then think about "doggerland" and what is being found in shallow waters between the UK and continental Europe.
Maybe when we start manganese nodule mining by robot, we're going to turn up the equivalent of roman coke tins, phoecian pencil stubs and Islander burger-wraps?