Re:Google Circles is high work and low return
by garry on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:30PM
(#2752385)
You're right, the Google drag-and-drop thing works pretty well and is quite innovative. That's certainly a direct way for them to mitigate the circle-creation problem. Arguably that's actually a critical piece of making Google+ work even though Circles is an n^2 operation.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return
by 51Cards on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:43PM
(#2752435)
I don't disagree that setup is a bit more work, but I think the pay-off for the individual user is very high. On top of that I expect you'll see Google introducing "Groups" as well very soon... public subscription groups that work better for a "Follow my company" type of thing. Not sure how they will implement that but I do think it is also a needed structure.
Personally though I would take the Circles concept even as it stands now any day over Facebook's method of social management. I've already found myself sharing far more on G+ (despite the fact only a small part of my social graph is there yet) just because I'm not worried that Aunt Mabel will find this offensive, or I'll have to field questions from Uncle Earl about what that tech link meant.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return
by Terretta on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:37PM
(#2752587)
EDIT: Derp, I'd read "n^2" as "n^n" both in a comment above and here, and even typed "n^2" while thinking it said "n^n". Sorry, garry.
---
Even if you're making a circle for every person, and putting every person in every circle, it's not n^n, it's just n * n.
75×75 = 5,625
75^75 = 4.26 × 10^140
But I don't see why you'd make a circle for every person, when you can add arbitrary individuals to Post or Share permissions.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return
by agscala on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:49PM
(#2752613)
n^2 is the same as n*n.
Except that in many programming languages, ^ means xor, so they do very different things. As a result in programming discussions I use n2 instead of n^2 to avoid the possibility of confusion if someone tries to cut and paste formulas into code.