News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by 51Cards on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:25PM (#2752360)
My Mom has already made circles and found the drag and drop feature to be dead easy. She loves it.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by garry on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:30PM (#2752385)
You're right, the Google drag-and-drop thing works pretty well and is quite innovative. That's certainly a direct way for them to mitigate the circle-creation problem. Arguably that's actually a critical piece of making Google+ work even though Circles is an n^2 operation.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by 51Cards on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:43PM (#2752435)
I don't disagree that setup is a bit more work, but I think the pay-off for the individual user is very high. On top of that I expect you'll see Google introducing "Groups" as well very soon... public subscription groups that work better for a "Follow my company" type of thing. Not sure how they will implement that but I do think it is also a needed structure.

Personally though I would take the Circles concept even as it stands now any day over Facebook's method of social management. I've already found myself sharing far more on G+ (despite the fact only a small part of my social graph is there yet) just because I'm not worried that Aunt Mabel will find this offensive, or I'll have to field questions from Uncle Earl about what that tech link meant.

Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by Terretta on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:37PM (#2752587)
EDIT: Derp, I'd read "n^2" as "n^n" both in a comment above and here, and even typed "n^2" while thinking it said "n^n". Sorry, garry.

---

Even if you're making a circle for every person, and putting every person in every circle, it's not n^n, it's just n * n.

  75×75 = 5,625
  75^75 = 4.26 × 10^140
But I don't see why you'd make a circle for every person, when you can add arbitrary individuals to Post or Share permissions.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by agscala on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:49PM (#2752613)
n^2 is the same as n*n.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by btilly on Monday July 11, 2011 @07:50PM (#2752961)
Except that in many programming languages, ^ means xor, so they do very different things. As a result in programming discussions I use n2 instead of n^2 to avoid the possibility of confusion if someone tries to cut and paste formulas into code.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by Terretta on Monday July 11, 2011 @06:20PM (#2752724)
Heh, no kidding. I thought I saw one thing while my fingers typed what was actually there. Hate it when that happens.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by ChuckMcM on Monday July 11, 2011 @05:43PM (#2752599)
I wonder how that scales when your web page shows you 150,000,000 possible people to put in your circles.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by 51Cards on Monday July 11, 2011 @06:28PM (#2752751)
Not really much differently than FB's UI does. Each person is in a small rectangle with the bottom part of the window split to display the circles. The top scrolls and you drag from there to the bottom pane. They will have to come up with a more compact view eventually though for long lists but they aren't too far off FB's lists for space. You can also multi-select (with a window as well) and drag a batch to a circle, as well as use CTRL to copy between circles.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by ChuckMcM on Monday July 11, 2011 @07:06PM (#2752846)
Hmm, when I went to the 'show all' for people I might want to add to my circles it seemed to select from everyone who had an account (there were a lot of squares). Maybe there is a limiting function Facebook that works better.

My UX friends tell me that a selection box with more than 1,000 choices in it is ineffective as a tool for initializing sets.

Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by 51Cards on Monday July 11, 2011 @08:08PM (#2753007)
Interesting, may want to submit that as a bug. When I do a show all I get about 80-100 people but that's probably just a factor of my connections list. They will need to trim that down if it's being overly generous in suggestions.
Re:Google Circles is high work and low return by ChuckMcM on Monday July 11, 2011 @08:36PM (#2753072)
Fair enough.

A meta question is why asking the question of how someone would feel about the utility of the UX when there were many choices offered which would not be appropriate for a particular circle, gets a down vote.

Is it not a real concern?

Is the answer so obvious I just missed it?