News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Most hospitals aren't complying with price transparency rule. Parent comment

Re:Most hospitals aren't complying with price transparency rule by majormajor on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @02:14PM (#27519326)
My first guess for the cost of a 10x surgery is something like "they didn't recover smoothly so what could've been outpatient is now a 4 day hospital stay that involved a lot more people and resources."

I can't say for sure, though - I've always gotten very detailed itemized breakdowns of all the cost, hospital stay vs surgeon vs anesthesia vs... but I've never compared them against someone else's bill for the same procedure.

Setting aside the why of the additional expense, the car mechanic model is very similar: you get an estimate, then you get the phone call telling you the additional things they found out, and the new estimate, asking for permission to do or not do the additional things. Though in the case of a surgery where you're knocked out, getting "incremental permission" like that wouldn't really work. You would just have to know the range up front.

But what if the range is so wide to be somewhat useless?

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Most hospitals aren't complying with price transparency rule by willcipriano on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @02:47PM (#27519778)
A good mechanic will tell you "it's $800 to fix the transmission, if the rotors are bad it'll be $1300." and if he finds is estimate is way off, that's his fault so he will take that on the chin and do right by the customer. Same for contractors who work on your home, sometimes you accidentally bid under cost and learn a lesson for next time.

Hospital estimates in the rare case they are provided only seem to get revised in one direction, that seems like having cake and eating it too. If the high school drop out painter can live by his estimates, so can the national hospital chain full of Harvard Business School graduates.

[ Parent | on HN ]