Think of just how contagious Covid would have been before we knew about it and started taking precautions. You could only introduce Covid into a country a few times before it'd inevitably start a self-sustaining transmission chain. We have no credible proof of that happening in the west until 2020.
I think the most useful measure that was actually carried out were the handful of places that take samples for flu surveilance that were able to retest the samples for covid. Of course, in many places, you can't actually convince a doctor to take a sample for flu-like illness, so there's no data.
The prevalence they found is extremely low, less than 0.05%, despite their samples going all the way back to Mid-March. Since they did not test on any samples that are definitely pre-Covid (e.g. early 2019, late 2018), we can't calibrate their false positive rate. But if we assume the specificity of the tests was 99% which seems on the high end for antibody tests, and that the false positives are uncorrelated, we're already in the region of false positives feasibly explaining literally all of their samples.
The data is just totally inconsistent with any kind of widespread transmission of Covid in the US in 2019.
So what's up with these early possible cases? I wonder how plausible it is that it there was some early spread of the same disease, but vulnerable populations were just luckily avoiding exposure. It really seemed to take off in the US in those nursing homes. IIRC that's what happened in Seattle, and that's what happened in my county. THAT'S what wiped out most of our body count, and that's what initially overwhelmed ICUs. And that's what raised a lot of awareness, and probably a few self-diagnosed false positives too. Could genuine COVID cases have been going around before then and just not getting the attention, or causing as much damage until that point?