News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by RicoElectrico on Monday June 14, 2021 @07:49PM (#27509825)
> a lot of HW was essentially sent to the landfill.

I mean, you could replace fake with the original quite easily as a drop-in replacement? 5-minute soldering job.

Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by comfydragon on Monday June 14, 2021 @08:20PM (#27509979)
Not quite, at least not necessarily. One feature of FTDI chips is an EEPROM that can be used to customize the enabled features, enumeration strings, and other things. That programming could probably be done in a separate jig, or in-circuit. So yes, 5 minutes of hardware work, but more potential rework at a higher level.

Not to mention the possibility of sealed cases/enclosures or potted PCBs.

Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by x0 on Monday June 14, 2021 @09:37PM (#27510417)
5-minute job for someone with a hot air rework station and experience soldering SOICs. Assuming no conformal coating or anything weird.
Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by mdip on Monday June 14, 2021 @10:31PM (#27510652)
Speaking as someone with a hot air rework station and no experience soldering SOICs, I can make a whole bunch of melted crap in 5 minutes all while burning my fingers.

5-minutes sounds insane to me, but I know it's accurate (the key being "experience").

Any tips for learning how to do this sort of thing with proficiency? How long does it take to become that proficient? What kind of coating/weirdness would present a problem? I'm asking for a bit OT reasons -- it's always been something I've wanted to learn/teach my kids.

Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by SpikedCola on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @12:59AM (#27511474)
For disassembly practice, I used to collect broken electronics, and desolder various components for fun. You learn the different heat requirements of eg 2 layer boards vs motherboards with many layers.

For assembly practice, you can buy "SOIC breakout boards", the cheapest chips you can find, and go to town. Either with a solder stencil and some paste, or a syringe of paste and a blunt needle (this gets old fast!)

Coatings tend to make lots of nasty fumes when heated. Some can also prevent solder from wetting the pads or legs. Depending on the coating, overheating/burning may change its electrical properties.

Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by aidenn0 on Monday June 14, 2021 @10:44PM (#27510712)
I have some experience soldering SOICs, but the difference between me and a pro is insane. I've seen someone remove and replace a half-dozen 0805 (2x1.2mm) SMD components with a fairly standard fine-tipped Metcal iron (not even a rework station) in under a minute.

[edit] I misremembered the component size

Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by koofdoof on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @02:16PM (#27519350)
Spend an hour watching Louis Rossman do it on YouTube, and then do it a few times on scrap boards.
Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by Klinky on Monday June 14, 2021 @09:15PM (#27510302)
Rework is extremely expensive, especially if you imported the devices and don't have manufacturing facilities of your own, plus the potential cost of retrieving units in the field. The soldering is the easy part. Labor and logistics are the hard part.
Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by CamperBob2 on Monday June 14, 2021 @08:44PM (#27510125)
Instructions unclear, accidentally built Dropbox
Re:FTDI FT232RL: Real vs. Fake (2014) by artemonster on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @03:32AM (#27512352)
How to tell me that you understand zero shit about electronics and/or manufacturing without telling me that you understand zero shit about electronics and/or manufacturing