In more user-centric (as opposed to content-centric) forums this problem is solved by banning users who repeatedly make low quality posts. One crappy comment here and there is something anyone might make, but the same person posting pointless comments in every thread deserves a ban.
Re:I Miss the Old Internet (2019)
by systemvoltage on Sunday June 13, 2021 @02:57PM
(#27495234)
The solution is simple: Use downvotes for rude and disrespectful comments. I am all for moderating a forum for pointless and useless comments. Most downvotes now-a-days are about disagreements. Using downvotes as a tool to push others into conformity is the shittiest part of HN.
I actually have a sort of nice idea about this: make your downvotes' worth be inversely proportional to how many downvotes you give.
A person who gives 100 downvotes per month will have his downvotes count 1/20th as those of a person who downvotes 5 times per month. An incenctive to be really judicious in handing out downvotes and not simply using them to drown out minority opinions.
Re:I Miss the Old Internet (2019)
by SV_BubbleTime on Sunday June 13, 2021 @09:08PM
(#27498227)
Only issue here is that you are penalized for activity even if itβs in removing objective garbage. But I like the idea quite a bit. That you take a hit for being a negative ass that downvotes questions you think are beneath you.
Re:I Miss the Old Internet (2019)
by systemvoltage on Sunday June 13, 2021 @07:59PM
(#27497813)
Interesting. I think we would still have the issue of 10 people piling up on a comment with downvotes, as judiciously as they can spend the budget.
Reddit lost its way when they started heavily moderating or banning entire subs that didn't fit with their woke US-centric world view, while rape porn was "fine". I closed my account a while back and stopped visiting the site, but unfortunately, there are so many organisations and FOSS projects that use it in an official capacity that it's unavoidable.