News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Company returned 3X, but I (investor) may lose m... by antimora on Sunday July 10, 2011 @08:18PM (#2748997)
And the sadder part is that richer investors know their way around those taxes better than new comers because they have access to accountant professionals who can advise to pay less tax.
Re:Tell HN: Company returned 3X, but I (investor) may lose m... by sa5 on Sunday July 10, 2011 @09:23PM (#2749114)
I'm not a tax expert so this assumption may be wrong, but if the 2X is being taxed as ordinary income at 35% wouldn't that imply that beagle3 is making at least $379,150 + 2X this year? I would consider someone with that kind of income to be rich.

Also, if the stock has gone down 40% can't you claim that as a loss when you sell and lessen your overall tax burden?

Re:Tell HN: Company returned 3X, but I (investor) may lose m... by beagle3 on Sunday July 10, 2011 @09:35PM (#2749134)
Well, it might be _just_ 33% depending on how my other projects work out this year. Not much of a difference those 2%. I've been doing well so far with actual work, and my investments seem to be going well, except that I keep getting hit on the crazy taxes (to the point that GOOD investments end up as losses!)

The reason I "told HN" is that I was not aware of how bad not optimizing the taxes could be; I thought I'm wasting 5-10% of potential profits by not optimizing. Turns out to be more than 100% on a totally ordinary deal.

> Also, if the stock has gone down 40% can't you claim that as a loss when you sell and lessen your overall tax burden?

Not really - not with AMT.

Re:Tell HN: Company returned 3X, but I (investor) may lose m... by anamax on Monday July 11, 2011 @12:43AM (#2749528)
> wouldn't that imply that beagle3 is making at least $379,150 + 2X this year? I would consider someone with that kind of income to be rich.

So what?

Seriously - do you think that the US govt or NYC is likely to do better with that money than he would have? Based on what?

Re:Tell HN: Company returned 3X, but I (investor) may lose m... by sa5 on Monday July 11, 2011 @09:39AM (#2750596)
In my comment I did not state whether I agree or disagree with the current US tax laws and that was not the point. I was responding to the post above mine which I think made some incorrect assumptions concerning beagle3's income level and ability to afford professional accountants.