Re:How nasty was Nero, really?
by billfruit on Saturday June 12, 2021 @10:32PM
(#27489283)
Anyone read 'Quo Vadis' of Henryk Sienkiewicz (He won the Nobel in literature 1905)? I have read a lot of novels in my life till now, but Nero's carnage against Christians depicted in it remains one of the most gruesome things I have read about.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How nasty was Nero, really?
by tbonesteaks on Saturday June 12, 2021 @10:42PM
(#27489326)
Yes, and the depiction of the fire of Rome is truly suffocating and terrifying. And the development of the protagonist’s conversion is very convincing. And also, more on topic, Nero is so dynamic. Seems like such a modern villain with so many believably awful traits.
The article suggests the stories could have been propaganda.
Of course, but you can say this about any historical figure before the age of mass media. That's not a particularly insightful or novel criticism. What do we really know about Pericles, Alexander the Great, Tiberius? We have a handful of biographies that have been passed down, and you can accuse any of them of being propaganda.
Re:How nasty was Nero, really?
by indigochill on Sunday June 13, 2021 @02:21AM
(#27490246)
> you can say this about any historical figure before the age of mass media
And after mass media! Just because we have an easier time disseminating information doesn't mean most of it isn't created with the intent to persuade the audience to believe things the author wants them to believe about the subject.
Yes, you have to sift through it, but the point is you get more than one or two primary texts, and so with a variety of witnesses you can make a stronger case. In the ancient world, it's not uncommon to have only a single text from a specific point of view and so there are always charges of propaganda to deal with.
Re:How nasty was Nero, really?
by boomboomsubban on Sunday June 13, 2021 @06:10AM
(#27491305)
Though I'm aware the author researched the Roman Empire, I wouldn't consider a 19th century fictional account a worthwhile source on the period.
Isn't Gibbon and Mommsen considered good enough sources on the Roman Empire still? Sienkiewicz is one of the most lauded Historical Novelists as well.
Re:How nasty was Nero, really?
by boomboomsubban on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:30PM
(#27496119)
Define "good enough sources." Both wrote their histories in a way that pushed their worldview, it's incredibly difficult not to. Similarly, Sienkiewicz was writing a largely pro-Christian novel, an accurate analysis of Nero was never their aim.