All 3 of the accounts listed regarding Agrippina's death are subjects of the article in question and suspected of outright making things up. Your own link even puts forth the fact that all three accounts are unbelievable. I don't know the current consensus on all of that, but I know that the consensus is that most of the more outrageous things Suetonius had to say about the 12 Caesars was nonsense. I don't think it'd be all that surprising if Tacitus and Cassius Dio did similarly.
I haven’t read Dio but Tacitus struck me as quite sober. He didn’t mix in myth the way Livy did (Romulus and Remus in a history?).
Re:How nasty was Nero, really?
by 0xbadcafebee on Saturday June 12, 2021 @10:22PM
(#27489237)
I haven't dug into it much, but isn't Tacitus also one of three sources about Caligula? Could it not be that a lot of the reputation of the Julio-Claudians was exaggerated well after nobody could or would defend them?
Easy to underestimate the historians incentive to blame the previous regime & to paint their patrons ancestors in good light.
The more fantastical Caligula stuff also generally isn't taken seriously these days.
The best propagandist makes it a little believable, right?
Isn't the article's point that those might be made up, or at least exaggerated?
Seneca himself was ordered to commit suicide by Nero.
But before Seneca had been tutor, mentor and acting prime minister for Nero.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seneca_the_Younger#Imperial_ad...
BTW. Some scholars claim that Seneca's writing had been part of clever crafting of his public image and written by ghost writers (slaves most likely). Real Seneca had been rather ruthless investment banker and politician in mode of the times.
> Tacitus says he killed his mother (who was pretty nasty in her own right).
Mentioned in the article; this was a trope that Roman historians (who weren't historians in the modern sense) routinely used about people they didn't like, and the accounts are inconsistent. Like, it's certainly _possible_ he did, but there isn't great evidence for it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnaeus_Domitius_Corbulo
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrippina_the_Younger#Death_an...