Re:Calculus for Seven Year Olds [pdf]
by jkhdigital on Friday June 11, 2021 @07:01AM
(#27471680)
Your account is only 4 years old ;-P
But seriously, +34k karma in four years is nuts
Doreen has been around on HN for a lot longer than this account. She's definitely one of the OGs. I would believe 12 years, that's about how long I've been here and I don't remember a time when she was not a member.
Re:Calculus for Seven Year Olds [pdf]
by auggierose on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:22AM
(#27472955)
I guess the broken glass is dispersed over another account.
This is precisely why I am unwilling to back down on some things.
If it is any comfort, I took your initial comment as well-meaning and intended to be helpful. It's just not a position I can embrace.
There comes a point past which politely going along to get along is part of the problem, not part of some kind of solution.
I have a strong track record of leaving nuanced comments on HN asserting that "No, it is not as simple as sexism and intentional exclusion of women in X case. Here is the data and women make choices." etc.
But in this case, I am quite confident that women not only get actively encouraged to go into early childhood education, they get actively advised that this is what they should do if their initial desired major has a strong math component and they are having trouble with the math and this is not done to men.
My oldest son ended up math phobic because his teachers couldn't teach it and brought a lot of baggage to the table. So I have seen firsthand what it can do to a child and that child doesn't have to be a girl to be negatively impacted by the emotional baggage that so many elementary school teachers have over the subject of math.
It can be a boy whose relationship to math is being egregiously harmed long term because of so many elementary school teachers having had their own dreams crushed on the excuse that "math is too hard for you" rather than being told "You can audit the class. You can get a tutor. You have to pass it, but it's fine if you only get a C as long your overall GPA is high enough. etc."
It doesn't just break women to have this done to women. It is breaking our society.
So if men value math and STEM, this is a practice they should be concerned about as well. It isn't just a women's issue by any stretch of the imagination.
I'm not angry at you. I'm not offended at your attempt to look out for my welfare in a cold, cruel world.
It's just the wrong answer in this case and I've basically crawled naked across broken glass for nearly twelve years on HN to claim my right to speak my mind to some degree here and I am going to exercise that right on details of this sort.