Re:“Crunch” Open Source Texture Compression Library vs. U.S....
by Dylan16807 on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:02AM
(#27469472)
I was going to ask if DXT was still relevant since ASTC has come out, but, uh, apparently ASTC never got implemented on anything desktop? Weird.
There's BC6H/BC7 but it's not as flexible and doesn't do normal maps.
Edit: I misread the description of 3Dc and cancel what I said about normal maps being stuck on DXT5. But there's still a lot of use of DXT5 for normal maps, which is a weird thing to see recommended when 3Dc is almost the same but strictly better.
Re:“Crunch” Open Source Texture Compression Library vs. U.S....
by sfblah on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:59PM
(#27468073)
How does this work when the "violation" is in open-source software? Wouldn't the issue be with products which incorporate the patented technology? I thought part of the point of the patent process was to encourage inventors to disclose how their inventions work so, while the inventors do profit from them, innovation could continue without everyone hiding secret formulas from each other.
Re:“Crunch” Open Source Texture Compression Library vs. U.S....
by colejohnson66 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:20PM
(#27468247)
Open source isn’t a “get out of jail free card” for patent violations. Despite how many of us here feel about patents, a patent is for a temporary monopoly in exchange for not “hiding secret formulas”. Open source/freeware/etc. or not, patent infringement is illegal. Independent discoveries (like this) do throw a wrench into that, but IANAL.
Re:“Crunch” Open Source Texture Compression Library vs. U.S....
by colejohnson66 on Monday June 14, 2021 @03:10PM
(#27506872)
IANAL, so I can’t say. You could try using the “code is speech” argument like what encryption advocates in the 90s argued. It worked then, but I doubt it’d work for this.
Re:“Crunch” Open Source Texture Compression Library vs. U.S....
by loeg on Friday June 11, 2021 @12:42AM
(#27469363)
I'm concerned how a 2009 work (crunch) could infringe on a 2010 patent (#20110115806), which was before the US switched from first-to-invent to first-to-file.
Re:“Crunch” Open Source Texture Compression Library vs. U.S....
by SloopJon on Friday June 11, 2021 @04:19AM
(#27470610)
Although Richard wrote crunch in 2009, he didn't publish it until 2011. Therefore, it doesn't serve as prior art to invalidate the patent.
Richard didn't apply for a patent himself, so first-to-invent is not applicable either. If he had learned of Doug's patent application, and then made an application of his own, there would have been a legitimate dispute as to priority. Since Richard shopped the library around in 2009, he might have been able to prove that he conceived the invention first. However, Doug might then have argued that Richard had abandoned, suppressed, or concealed it. See this blog post from 2005 discussing a similar hypothetical:
The technique employed by crunch was effectively a trade secret until its open source release. It's entirely possible that the patent is invalid for other reasons, but my layman's understanding of patent law is that because Richard didn't publish or patent in time, crunch can in fact infringe Doug's patent.
https://richg42.blogspot.com/2012/07/doug-has-updated-his-bl...
"Immunity," but not a license. Whatever that is good for.
https://levien.com/patents.html
There's BC6H/BC7 but it's not as flexible and doesn't do normal maps.
Edit: I misread the description of 3Dc and cancel what I said about normal maps being stuck on DXT5. But there's still a lot of use of DXT5 for normal maps, which is a weird thing to see recommended when 3Dc is almost the same but strictly better.
In addition there are licensing and business issues that made Microsoft mandate BCx for DirectX and Google mandate ASTC for Android.
And having both blocks on a GPU would need way too much area.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_infringement_under_Unit...
Richard didn't apply for a patent himself, so first-to-invent is not applicable either. If he had learned of Doug's patent application, and then made an application of his own, there would have been a legitimate dispute as to priority. Since Richard shopped the library around in 2009, he might have been able to prove that he conceived the invention first. However, Doug might then have argued that Richard had abandoned, suppressed, or concealed it. See this blog post from 2005 discussing a similar hypothetical:
https://www.irmi.com/articles/expert-commentary/the-dangers-...
The technique employed by crunch was effectively a trade secret until its open source release. It's entirely possible that the patent is invalid for other reasons, but my layman's understanding of patent law is that because Richard didn't publish or patent in time, crunch can in fact infringe Doug's patent.