News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by dmitriid on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:36AM (#27459113)
> At least, with VW system, you pay when you use it. Doesn't work in your area, you don't pay.

"AWS has billed us tens of thousands of dollars because we forgot to turn something off/confusing billing" hasn't taught anyone anything?

There's nothing honest about VW's approach. They won't have self-driving either, it will be at best the same as Tesla's. And yet, they want to charge you, and charge you significantly more than 10k upfront (because they expect to extract this payment every time, all the time, for the entire lifetime of the car).

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by SamBam on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:49AM (#27460066)
You're inventing hypotheticals to say why they're going to charge you more, without evidence.

Pay-per-minute autonomous driving is far more like old pay-per-minute phone plans than it is mystery-AWS-data-charges. You know when it's driving and when it's not. There's no unforeseeable per-lambda charges about it.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by lp0_on_fire on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:01PM (#27464273)
I think it's reasonable to worry that WV or another company might start charging a variable rate for different "types" of autonomous driving. Pay-per-minute phone plans could be just as mysterious when you factored in long distance and peak usage hours.

It's not a huge logical leap to think that a subscription based service like this could lead to things such as:

You want to travel between point A and B several miles apart in rural Kansas on a straight road with a road density of 2 vehicles per mile? "Sure, that's 8.50 an hour."

Oh, you want to travel between Newark and Manhattan in the middle of a snowstorm? "That will be 15 an hour because we have to cover the costs for the real-time feed of data from our weather and control center"

Oh, you have a camper, too? "That's an additional 2 bucks an hour for our towing package"

Oh, you're traveling across state lines and the state over imposes an additional tax on autonomous driving. "we need to charge you 8.75 to cover the tax and our costs but only in that state."

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by dmitriid on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:22PM (#27466598)
> You're inventing hypotheticals to say why they're going to charge you more, without evidence.

Ah yes. There's no evidence. Except the countless instances of dark patterns everywhere on the web tricking into you paying money. Countless instances where you can't cancel a subscription, and have to go through multiple hoops to do it. Countless instances when there's a runaway billing in a SaaS that leaves people with huge bills.

But sure. These are all just "hypotheticals", and not the reality how the absolute vast majority of subscription business works.

> You know when it's driving and when it's not. There's no unforeseeable per-lambda charges about it.

Ah yes. Because of course it will be as simple as "when it's on, it will be charged", and not "when an obscure setting is on, you will be charged, regardless of whether it will be self-driving or not".

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:10AM (#27459321)
That's the same argument against software-as-a-service

Maybe I'm not bothered about self driving for 90% of my journeys, but on occasion I'm going somewhere unusual or want to travel overnight or after drinking or whatever I'll just pay for a few hours.

Imagine a world where there was just a set fee of $x per hour and $x per mile to travel. Would allow a far easier choice between different modes of transport, as the marginal cost becomes the actual cost.

(Of course self driving is years away so this is all just spin)

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by dmitriid on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:51AM (#27459572)
And then you forget to click a "don't use autopilot" setting buried in three levels of settings, and will pay for a month-worth of driving.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by BenjiWiebe on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:52AM (#27460759)
Seems to me it would be difficult to not notice your car driving itself.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by dmitriid on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:15PM (#27466511)
It doesn't matter if the car drives itself or not. What matters is how money is withdrawn.

It's enough to have "on/off" somewhere in settings, and have it "enabled" even if you don't use it.

Good grief, there are countless articles even here on HN about dark patterns where people are tricked into subscribing to something, or being unable to unsusbcribe except when going through the hoops. But sure, a car manufacturer charging maney for a subscription will never ever do that as long as you "don't use a feature".

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bluGill on Thursday June 10, 2021 @07:48AM (#27459552)
It won't be long after self driving arrives and you won't get that option. Humans are terrible drivers, even in the best cases. Once self driving is better survival than humans it won't be legal to drive on public roads.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by amcoastal on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:36AM (#27459931)
Maybe where you live. There's a 0% chance human driving will be banned in America until we are all well passed driving age.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by redbeard0x0a on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:55AM (#27461479)
It wont be banned, it will just cost much more to insure (since it will be directly tied to risk, computers already drive better than humans). If you drive manually, you will need to pay for the privilege.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ars on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:25AM (#27461805)
> since it will be directly tied to risk, computers already drive better than humans

They do not! Are you comparing computer driving in "easy" situations with human driving in all situations?

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by rout39574 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:08PM (#27462315)
I think the comparison is made over the entire range of situations.

If we can get rid of, or vastly reduce, the problems of inattention, exhaustion, rage, chemical impairments and the like, we have a huge improvement. I think that improvement is vastly more, cost measured in human life, than the problems we see with computer control in odd situations.

So yes. They do drive better than humans. The fact that their failings are wack-doodle to us (you drove _right_ into that truck??) is swallowed in the fact that their failings are profoundly fewer than ours.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by avereveard on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:59PM (#27463530)
> their failings are profoundly fewer than ours

Better start showing off some statistics along with that claim.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by kuratkull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:53PM (#27464945)
Insurance is already directly tied to risk - car ensurers are profitable companies with current rates
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ashtonkem on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:24AM (#27460444)
I wouldn’t be so confident. I think you’re drastically underrating how much convenience will drive changes in behavior and social expectation. If self driving works (big if, I’m dubious about this), then the vast majority of us will switch over to using it for regular trips very quickly. As that happens, the perception about what is safe and socially acceptable will change quickly, as will the types of vehicles consumers demand.

This type of change isn’t instant, but it can happen faster than a human lifespan. Think about someone born in the 70s and what they’ve experienced with cigarettes. They were born into a world where close to half the US population smoked, and they’re now retiring in a world where smoking is de facto banned in most non-residential buildings. That is a drastic change, and remember that tobacco is addictive, which hampers change much more effectively than habits like driving.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by kortex on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:43AM (#27461341)
I wouldn't be so confident 100% ("steering-wheel-less") L5 self-driving is possible. Long tail is a thing. There will for a long time be a need for manual override, for things like tricky parking or slow-speed maneuvering, bad weather, weird lightning conditions, etc.

That rules out de facto driving ban. That leaves driving ban by fiat. Also never gonna happen in this century, unless it carves out an exception for "classic cars."

As far as hazard ratios go, cigarette smoking is orders of magnitude more dangerous than driving. Not a good comparison.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ashtonkem on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:20AM (#27461738)
> I wouldn't be so confident 100% ("steering-wheel-less") L5 self-driving is possible.

I’m not, you didn’t read what I wrote. I specifically predicated my theory on if it was possible, and indicated my reservations there.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:23AM (#27461783)
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jsight on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:34PM (#27463273)
Yeah, I don't think it will ever be completely banned. It might be restricted a little bit, though.

But the big benefit that I see of self-driving is that a lot of manual driving becomes safer. Autonomous vehicles won't overlook motorcycles and Miatas.

Autonomous cars will go a long way to making small, fun vehicles safe again.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ryathal on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:39AM (#27460612)
Maybe on restricted access highways, but self driving isn't coming to dirt and gravel roads any time soon.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:53PM (#27463466)
So this model works well - rather than paying $10k for a feature that only works for 100 hours a year you spend on the freeway, and not the 400 hours you spend on your dirt road in smallville, you get the benefit when you go and visit Aunt Mabel without having to pay a large fee upfront.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:13AM (#27461017)
From a technology standpoint, this seems much much easier for AVs vs humans than many other AV challenges. When it comes to measuring physics precisely, complex computation, and rapid control, computers beat humans by a million miles. This is in stark contrast to, say, driving through a crowded urban environment with all manner of rule-breaking peds and bikes popping out of everywhere.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by kube-system on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:11PM (#27462346)
The ability to calculate the physics of driving dynamics has been solved for decades. But, if you feed garbage data to your physics models, you will get a garbage result. Computers are still very very awful at image processing as compared to humans.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:51PM (#27469090)
Yes, I'm saying that environments with diet and gravel roads are a much easier perception problem than dense urban environments, and perception is one of autonomous driving's weak spots. Conversely, quick physics computation and response is a relative weakness of human drivers, and is exacerbated by these environments.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by g00gler on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:36AM (#27459926)
A future where humans are no longer able to drive will have to be a decade or more after self driving arrives. It’s impossible for everyone to replace their non self driving cars immediately.

The used car market is a $150bn industry. A quick spot check found that a 2010 Honda Civic still costs between $5k and $10k depending on mileage, etc.

By the time that self driving is required by the NHSA or whatever body requires backup cameras and the like in new cars self driving will be standard.

A $20k Subaru will come with it out of the box, no add ons, just like a backup camera today.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by twiddling on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:01AM (#27461542)
<A future where humans are no longer able to drive will have to be a decade or more after self driving arrives.

The National Driver's Association will arise with bumper stickers: "You can pry the steering wheel from my cold, dead hands"

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:53PM (#27463471)
...38,000 times a year

As self driving becomes common, people won't bother with getting a driving license. States that do can actually put in decent levels of restrictions and competency to get one rather than letting an 16 year old with 5 minutes driving round a car park out on the road.

As fewer people get new licesnse, the demand for self-driving goes down as people who can drive the legacy way die off.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jewel on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:45AM (#27460684)
It might be possible to add self-driving features as an aftermarket upgrade. My 2013 model car already has drive-by-wire features (for automatic parallel parking), so it just needs more cameras and a replacement CPU. Heck, as a last resort you could put a robot in the driver's seat, physically operating the steering wheel and pedals.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ars on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:42AM (#27460644)
> Humans are terrible drivers, even in the best cases.

Humans drive correctly 99.99999% of the time. We can't can't even keep a computer up and running that well, never mind driving perfectly.

See this thread with the math: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12012166

The future you are expecting is never going to happen.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by elzbardico on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:06PM (#27462290)
Averages are extremely misleading here, on the human side you're lumping drunk drivers (that could be precluded from driving by the simple mandatory adoption of interlock system), commercial drivers, people driving in really bad weather, across all types of roads and with cars in variable state of maintanance. Remove all those factors (specially DUI) on the human side, then add all those conditions were self-driving doesn't even attempt to try, and the sheer superiority of the human visual cortex alone is indisputable.
Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:31AM (#27461204)
> Humans drive correctly 99.99999% of the time. We can't can't even keep a computer up and running that well, never mind driving perfectly.

This comparison doesn't make any sense. You're comparing _continuous_ operation with the aggregate of the average human's bouts of driving. Even robotaxis aren't going to run constantly. A sensible analogue would be something like aircraft software, which I'd guess does have near the reliability of human drivers (and can last much longer continuously than humans do).

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by ars on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:24AM (#27461786)
> You're comparing _continuous_ operation with the aggregate of the average human's bouts of driving.

I don't understand what you mean. I'm comparing actual time behind the wheel - hours of correct driving vs hours (well minutes) of incorrect driving.

Do the math yourself, take total hours behind the wheel and divide by the accident rate, like I did. You'll get the same results. Depending on your assumptions anywhere from 99.999 to 99.99999% correct driving by humans.

> Even robotaxis aren't going to run constantly.

Again, I'm not comparing constantly, I'm comparing actual hours behind the wheel.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by iso1210 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:01PM (#27463544)
84 billion hours of driving[0] for 35,485 deaths[1]. That's one death per 2.4 million hours, so that's an indicator of the magnitude that's needed before even talking about it.

That number also means no situations where the computer gives up and hands control back to the driver.

If autonomous cars can never hand back (at most stopping legally, safely and out of traffic) and cause 1 death per 10 million hours, that would seem about right.

[0] https://www.volpe.dot.gov/news/how-much-time-do-americans-sp...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by wutbrodo on Saturday June 12, 2021 @11:04AM (#27484956)
Is this not a reference to uptime (as in servers)?

> We can't can't even keep a computer up and running that well

That's the comparison that I quoted in my comment and that I was responding to. You're comparing continuous uptime to humans' disconnected (and brief) bouts of driving.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bumby on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:37AM (#27461958)
>A sensible analogue would be something like aircraft software

Does automobile software development have the level of oversight that aircraft development has in terms of regulation and approval for use? I know the NHTSA approves safety with crash tests (and are currently working on AV standards) but I'm not sure it's an equivalent to what the FAA currently does.

Not to say they won't be equivalent in the future, but I don't know how well the analogue holds up if they don't have equivalent levels of quality oversight currently.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:43PM (#27469049)
> Does automobile software development have the level of oversight that aircraft development has in terms of regulation and approval for use?

Nothing in my comment implied this, and I don't disagree that it doesn't. The question is immaterial to the specific topic of discussion: the comparison of server uptime to human-driver reliability as an indicator of the feasibility of functional AV software.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bumby on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:25AM (#27472983)
The tone of your response seems to imply I’ve was attacking your position, but that wasn’t my intent.

I am legitimately asking how much parity there is regarding oversight regulation between flight and autonomous software, which would help make your point clearer since it has a direct relationship to reliability.

However, I do think it’s relevant to the point. If you are making an analogy about reliability but one is legally forced to demonstrate reliability while the other is not, does that comparison really make sense with that additional context? While I've worked in the aerospace software domain, I don't know to what standard AV is held which is why I was asking.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by wutbrodo on Saturday June 12, 2021 @11:03AM (#27484946)
> seems to imply I’ve was attacking your position, but that wasn’t my intent.

Not quite attacking, but disagreeing with an implied assumption that I didn't make (ie, that I was arguing that AVs were ready for primetime instead of narrowly disputing the flawed reliability comparison in the parent comment).

> I am legitimately asking how much parity there is regarding oversight regulation between flight and autonomous software, which would help make your point clearer since it has a direct relationship to reliability

The reason I figured it was rhetorical is that I thought it was fairly universally known that there's no comparable regulatory apparatus for AVs (yet?). But you're mistaken that this is relevant to my point: the parent comment was discussing the feasibility of AVs by saying "we can't build computers with the uptime of human drivers", and I was pointing out that he had this backwards.

> If you are making an analogy about reliability but one is legally forced to demonstrate reliability while the other is not, does that comparison really make sense with that additional context?

I didn't say AVs were as reliable as aircraft software, nor that they would definitely get to that pt (perhaps they don't need to, as safe stops are much easier on the ground). I was disputing the claim that computer system uptime can't be made as reliable as humans in the current day, using aircraft systems as an in-production example.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by bumby on Saturday June 12, 2021 @11:17AM (#27485053)
Ah, ok. Thanks for taking the time to clarify. It sounds like we’re making the same point but maybe talking past one another.

My point was that AV-aircraft comparison is only valid iff they are held to the same quality standard. It sounds like we agree they are not.

I think it’s important to include that caveat, that’s all. If you assume everybody already knows that, I can understand why you didn’t include it in your original point.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by Larrikin on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:18AM (#27460362)
There is very little reason to believe Tesla will be best let alone first when it comes to self driving technology. I personally feel they are backing the wrong technology and will ultimately be unsuccessful without LIDAR sensors like Waymo and other startups and the beta testers with current model Teslas are going to ultimately end up disappointed.

I don't own a car currently (nor any Tesla stock) so I'm happy to wait and see if I'm wrong or right.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by vardump on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:47AM (#27461373)
Tesla can already generate a pretty good "lidar point cloud" out of just camera input.

But we'll see.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by jsight on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:35PM (#27463284)
One issue with Tesla's approach is that they do not have enough cameras to do this at every angle. Its going to be especially tough in parking lots, as they have very poor coverage of the road directly beneath them.

Mobileye's camera based point cloud approach appears to be much more robust.

Re:What would you pay for autonomous driving? Volkswagen hop... by vardump on Friday June 11, 2021 @08:26AM (#27472347)
Why would the car need to see the road directly beneath while parking? Because of positional error (drift) or what? It should know the painted markings from earlier frames.

Good point though. I'd like Tesla to add more cameras.