News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Always Be Quitting by booleandilemma on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:31AM (#27456674)
Paradoxically, by being disposable, you free yourself.

No, you just make yourself disposable.

War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength.

Don’t listen to this article. It sounds like something overseers would tell their underlings.

And when you’re quitting, that’s the company’s problem, not yours.

Re:Always Be Quitting by wyqydsyq on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:59AM (#27457262)
> No, you just make yourself disposable.

You might be making yourself disposable specifically in the context of your original role which you are basically making redundant by documenting and automating everything - but trust me any sensible business will want to keep a staff member who massively improved their team's productivity (by enabling them to be more independent with less silo'd knowledge) and reduced the business' risk exposure (by making potentially critical knowledge more accessible and reducing single points of failure).

Employees who try to become indesposable by turning themselves into a mega-silo of knowledge that nobody else in the org has might gain some job security in the short term but they lose out on any potential job progression.

Turning yourself into a silo like this is practically blackmailing your employer into keeping you. They might keep you employed because they need to keep their systems online, but they will also not think twice about replacing you as soon as an opportunity is presented. That is making yourself disposable.

Turning yourself into a leader who improves the outcomes of various teams in a business will not only make you indespensable, it's genuinely the best (if not the only realistic) path for an engineer to work their way up into more senior or C-suite positions.

Re:Always Be Quitting by pydry on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:56AM (#27458124)
>trust me any sensible business will want to keep a staff member who massively improved their team's productivity

Whether sensible or not a lot of companies do not do this.

It is difficult to measure productivity increases at the best of times. Increasing your teams productivity doubly so. Increasing their productivity may even be net negative for you as it makes them look more effective compared to you.

This may be counterproductive for the company in question and seem idiotic but that doesn't stop it from being common. It's common precisely because it's a template for how most workers are treated. If you see programmers as individual resources not markedly different to Uber drivers (and SO many do) this way of thinking is completely natural.

>Turning yourself into a silo like this is practically blackmailing your employer into keeping you. They might keep you employed because they need to keep their systems online, but they will also not think twice about replacing you as soon as an opportunity is presented.

Right. But how else do you deal with a company that demonstrates repeatedly that they wouldn't think twice about replacing you no matter what? Starting from that assumption along with the restriction that you cannot easily hop jobs - what else are you supposed to do?

Plenty of tech is egalitarian and productive and not like this, but a larger unfashionable un-talked about underbelly of the industry most certainly is. The bimodal salary distribution also comes attached to bimodal working conditions.

Re:Always Be Quitting by 49531 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:57AM (#27460821)
> Turning yourself into a silo like this is practically blackmailing your employer into keeping you. They might keep you employed because they need to keep their systems online, but they will also not think twice about replacing you as soon as an opportunity is presented.

All employer / employee relationships have this dynamic. I get paid _n_ because my employer cannot figure out an effective way to do it cheaper, but as soon as they can I will no longer be paid _n_. While I think blackmail isn't an accurate description of this, what you're describing exists in all employment situations. Making yourself more disposable is only going to give the employer more power, which might work out better or worse depending on the employer.

Re:Always Be Quitting by wyqydsyq on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:05PM (#27468856)
> All employer / employee relationships have this dynamic

Wrong, no employer relies on a newly hired employee the way they rely on a senior knowledge silo'd engineer with a decade+ of domain knowledge which they are reluctant to share. In most jobs the employee is not in a position to have that kind of bargaining leverage. That leverage is only gained by an employee either intentionally and maliciously making the codebase as esoteric and unmaintainable as possible, or poor management not planning for these risks sufficiently e.g. not hiring more staff for a legacy COBOL system team as it's members leave until there's only one guy left who understands it.

> While I think blackmail isn't an accurate description of this

I'd argue it is. You know their business depends on you as a result of you actively working to make it depend on you, you use that knowledge to leverage your position in bargaining for higher pay or to never get fired from a low-effort "cruiser" job. Essentially blackmailing the business into continuing your employment under threat of losses caused by you leaving and nobody else being able to maintain the mess you created. This is not a normal employer / employee relationship dynamic at all.

Re:Always Be Quitting by DataGata on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:56AM (#27461483)
People that play zero sum games only get to play with other zero sum players. There is some risk they will lose. People that play win-win games get to play with other winners (and be winners).

Be a winner.

Re:Always Be Quitting by 49531 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:33PM (#27463896)
I hate to break it to you, but every economic scenario is a zero-sum game. In order for an economy to work you have to have a relatively fixed amount of resources.

This whole win-win ideology is mostly a tool to erase where the losers are, and to make losers feel better about losing. Every increase in my paycheck is a decrease in someone else's.

Re:Always Be Quitting by rthomas6 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:09PM (#27465152)
If that was even remotely true, we would still be sitting in caves sharing raw animal scraps. Fortunately it's not true, and things like discovering fire and inventing tools don't take resources away from others, but instead increase resources for everyone. This is just as true in the modern economy.

Obviously the inventor of fire got more of a reward from his invention's bounty, but everyone still benefited. Similarly whoever automates your job gets most of the reward, but ideally we all benefit through cheaper products.

At least, that's how it's supposed to work. Obviously it doesn't always.

Re:Always Be Quitting by readonthegoapp on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:03AM (#27456848)
I had a pretty strong visceral reaction to this article.

prob because i just read about the 1%ers avoiding paying taxes, and a thousand other much-more-horrific things, only to see the top post on HN advocating for workers to make themselves even more dispensable that they/we already are -- and i don't think it was meant as a joke. :-D

i've always done the 'obsolete yourself' routine, and still do/am -- part of it was/is always self-interest (not advancement, but getting freed from having to do stupid shit), but part of it was/is 'just doing the right thing by the company' and thereby hopefully being part of a successful operation which, if you're not doing anything too evil, would allow me to take some pride in it.

but i know that many of my improvements to products/documentation/training/etc. only help offshore myself _and_ all my co-workers, especially those of us in the US and other expensive places (and we don't even get health insurance).

if i was part of some type of co-op, all that would be taken care of.

one can dream!

Re:Always Be Quitting by dasil003 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:23AM (#27456968)
You are disposable though, everyone is. It's generally a losing game to try to cement your position by playing gatekeeper on institutional knowledge, because at best it will prevent you from ever being promoted, and at worst will peg you as a single-point-of-failure liability that needs to be dealt with proactively. I understand this sort of defensive posture might make sense in some companies/situations, but the article is clearly talking about software engineers in large upwardly mobile companies. In those situations it's essential to have a non-adversarial and trusting relationship with your boss, if you don't trust your boss than that's the first thing to address by any means necessary.
Re:Always Be Quitting by the_jeremy on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:56AM (#27462178)
I was on a team of 2 and underpaid for my YOE. My boss gave me the standard speech about the company not having the money to increase my comp, and said the company wouldn't be able to counteroffer anything I interviewed for.

I was doing interview prep and my coworker gave notice. I told my boss the range I was interviewing for, and got a comp adjustment the next day. It was a 60% raise.

Re:Always Be Quitting by yhoneycomb on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:16PM (#27462399)
If I were you I would have left that place even with the raise, or stuck around just long enough for me to get another opportunity. Clearly they don't value you unless you force they hand. Why stick around for that?
Re:Always Be Quitting by the_jeremy on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:01PM (#27463547)
My approach to interviewing was basically reject any companies paying under X, and slowly increase X over time as I got practice interviewing with the easier companies. I was only interviewing with one company that could pay X, and they didn't end up giving me the offer.

I like my coworkers and the work I'm doing, but mainly my current company came in with the highest offer.

Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:26AM (#27456998)
I got a significant raise lately because I was a single point of failure.
Re:Always Be Quitting by gregoriol on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:24AM (#27458323)
I was in this situation many times. You'll see the reality of it the day you leave: in a few days, maybe a month, you'll be forgotten there.
Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:18AM (#27459777)
When I leave, that corporation is no longer my problem :)
Re:Always Be Quitting by codeafin on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:04AM (#27458186)
This also has happened to me multiple times.

And to the comments saying the employer could "replace you any time" - most cases, they just don't know how to do so, or have the time and money to do so.

This strange article teaches you to do your employer's job by making it easier to replace you.

Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:20AM (#27459787)
Agree, that's why I think the article was written by a manager that lost some key people and he is in big trouble.
Re:Always Be Quitting by wyqydsyq on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:15AM (#27457403)
Meaning your employer now has all the more reason to replace you as soon as an opportunity presents itself
Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:29AM (#27457501)
They can. But it would be very expensive to replace more than 20 years of domain experience.
Re:Always Be Quitting by biztos on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:21AM (#27457874)
It would probably be a lot more expensive to replace more than 20 years of domain experience immediately because you quit to go work at rand($FAANG).
Re:Always Be Quitting by wyqydsyq on Thursday June 10, 2021 @10:49PM (#27468785)
Exactly this. If you are a single point of failure knowledge silo, the business sees you as a liability since if you decide to quit, their business is then screwed. This is why turning yourself into a silo is making yourself disposable - it gives the employer a very good reason to try and find an alternative to continuing their reliance on you.
Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:26AM (#27457893)
I agree, meanwhile they prefer giving me a raise than start looking for backup or replacement
Re:Always Be Quitting by tremon on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:56AM (#27458511)
Why does one exclude the other?
Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:52AM (#27460103)
short term, it cost more to bring a backup/replacement than give me a raise.
Re:Always Be Quitting by mLuby on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:49AM (#27457186)
Not "if you follow all these rules religiously, you will even guarantee yourself a lifetime of employment, since no one but you has a hope in hell of maintaining the code."

https://www.doc.ic.ac.uk/~susan/475/unmain.html

Re:Always Be Quitting by inshadows on Friday June 11, 2021 @09:58AM (#27473391)
I don't think OP is advocating making yourself SoP. I think what OP is saying, is that you should not waste your precious mental effort or free time to unmake yourself as SoP for the company, unless you're tasked to do so and paid for it. I.e. if it's in your job description that you'll be documenting all the things, then you'll do it, on paid time.
Re:Always Be Quitting by throwawaysleep on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:39AM (#27457119)
I see it as downside protection.

If I want a promotion, there are other companies.

Re:Always Be Quitting by unishark on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:49AM (#27457188)
Is your goal to be indispensable as in the only person still able to maintain some ancient legacy project that is still continuing? Or as in the person who gets things done?

Highly-paid professions have cookie-cutter skill-sets taught from the same textbooks at professional schools with the same basic curricula. They are valuable because those skills are valued, not because they trap their clients in some kind of infinite treatment plan.

Re:Always Be Quitting by pydry on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:19AM (#27458290)
My goal is to be the latter but I've worked with plenty of people who made it a goal to be the former.

I don't think it's necessarily irrational.

If you're self aware enough to know that you're on the wrong side of the programmer bell curve, you're counting down the days until retirement, if you're living in a market with relatively few tech jobs - this makes sense.

Re:Always Be Quitting by hughrr on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:43AM (#27457592)
From detailed experience on this you want to be both the first person to be asked to take on a complex problem and the last person out of the door when things get tough.

Make yourself indispensable through being the person running towards danger, being helpful to your colleagues, being knowledgable and treating people with respect but only write stuff down when asked lest someone think you're replaceable by a few confluence pages.

Re:Always Be Quitting by derefr on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:03AM (#27456844)
Sounds like you're writing from the perspective of an employee. The advice is a lot more applicable if you read it from the perspective of a founder — one who might want to get off the rocketship they've built at some point, without causing it to blow up (and tanking the value of their equity.)
Re:Always Be Quitting by apozem on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:44AM (#27462037)
> War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength.

With all due respect, it's overdramatic and ridiculous to quote Orwell. Comparing a blog post about career advice to totalitarian state propaganda is absurd.

Re:Always Be Quitting by booleandilemma on Thursday June 10, 2021 @11:53AM (#27462134)
You can nitpick but it doesn’t change my point.
Re:Always Be Quitting by derangedHorse on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:32AM (#27459889)
Any good team worth their salt will recognize that those with siloed information on the team are a threat to productivity to everyone else. People should get hired and kept based on their ability to learn, their approach to problem-solving, and their ability to share knowledge and unshackle their coworkers from any dependencies on oneself. If a coworker in my organization had disproportionate value stemming from a cache of undocumented information (meaning that then writing documentation would make them disposable), then they’re not worth having in the long run.

A smart manager would start finding someone to receive that knowledge and the smart employee would volunteer to learn. Giving raises to the person with the siloed information to incentivize them to work and share information with other employees is a relatively inexpensive cost to the alternative of spending a yearly salary on someone who’s main draw is being a walking notion/confluence page

Re:Always Be Quitting by bongoman37 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:24AM (#27457885)
Yea, when the person who is disposable quits, she gets a farewell lunch at best. When a person who is determined to be indispensable quits he gets a counteroffer.
Re:Always Be Quitting by stjohnswarts on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:36PM (#27463931)
Yeah I document stuff when I'm assigned it (say it has users that aren't programmers), or I have to take notes that I will understand. I don't dumb it down so a "newb" can take over my place, I document enough so that 6 months or more down the road I can come back to it and have a reasonable review of what's going on.
Re:Always Be Quitting by leke on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:01AM (#27456837)
> No, you just make yourself disposable.

Yeah, I agree, but I think you are also meant to prepare yourself for a new or higher role in the company.

Looking at the list of what you are supposed to be achieving, it looks like the itinerary of what a manager would want from their perfect employee.

Re:Always Be Quitting by hathym on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:23AM (#27456971)
It feels like an article written by a middle manager.
Re:Always Be Quitting by phendrenad2 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:06AM (#27457772)
The truth is, your disposability has nothing to do with how well you do your job, and everything to do with how visible you are. By writing documentation you're making sure that your name is attached to everything in a huge area that most people ignore.
Re:Always Be Quitting by pydry on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:22AM (#27458306)
Not all documentation highlights the author. I think if it did it would be more popular.
Re:Always Be Quitting by dangerface on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:03AM (#27459653)
> War is peace. Freedom is slavery. Ignorance is strength.

Is this a fascist dog whistle? I keep seeing it and I don't know why anyone would believe these things unless they are fascist,

Re:Always Be Quitting by detaro on Thursday June 10, 2021 @08:05AM (#27459670)
It's a 1984 reference, government slogans in the novel.
Re:Always Be Quitting by dangerface on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:57AM (#27460813)
Ah thanks, that makes more sense now.
Re:Always Be Quitting by ryeights on Thursday June 10, 2021 @09:31AM (#27460513)
Haha, this is peak 2021