News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by truetraveller on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:25PM (#27429161)
Copied or not, if he signed a non-compete, he is violating the agreement. His project absolutely competes with Replit. Do you agree with this?
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by thebradbain on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:27PM (#27429174)
Noncompetes are illegal and unenforceable in California, where Repl.it is incorporated. So if he signed a noncompete, it would actually be Repl.it that is in the wrong here, not him.
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by gip on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:42PM (#27429302)
I am not sure they are 'illegal' - do you have a source for this? That being said, most non-competes are not enfoceable in Californina that's true. And that is a very good thing imo and a net positive for innovation.
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by jcrites on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:52PM (#27429372)
According to the California Business and Professions Code Section 16600, “every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void.”

https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio....

This does not make contracts containing such clauses "illegal", but rather unenforceable in court. The student could sign a contract saying "I will not work on a company that competes with Repl.it", and he did, and the company tried to sue him over it with that as the only claim, then the court would quickly grant a motion to dismiss the lawsuit.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by sithlord on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:50PM (#27429361)
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by gip on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:38PM (#27429278)
Strong competition has been a net positive for the tech ecosystem in my opinion and what has made SV what it is today.

Replit leadership and team should focus on winning by building faster and better, not by artificially blocking innovation.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by stevenhuang on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:33PM (#27429225)
You should know by now that non-competes mean diddly squat.
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by xenihn on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:35PM (#27429235)
Why do you keep posting about non-competes when they are not a factor in California, which is where this occurred?
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by truetraveller on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:48PM (#27429352)
I didn't actually know that. I stand corrected about that. But it's still arguably "morally wrong". Especially if Replit's unique design decisions and/or secrets are incorporated into this, as is claimed.
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by ncmncm on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:50PM (#27430128)
If, in fact, there were any plausible argument that it was morally wrong, we would not have a written statute specifically, actionably defending it.

Rather, making threats over what amounts to it, at someone not equipped to face even such a specious attack, is clearly and indefensibly morally wrong. Shame on Replit, and shame on you for supporting them.

Any company that has $20M in the bank but could possibly be threatened just by a new college grad coding alone does not deserve to exist. Give the money back to the investors and close up shop.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by evan_ on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:43PM (#27430434)
Non-competes are morally wrong
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by xenihn on Monday June 07, 2021 @09:58PM (#27429804)
> But it's still arguably "morally wrong".

According to who? You? Hundreds of people in this thread disagree with you. As does the law.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by truetraveller on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:42AM (#27430701)
Actually, I apologize. I don't think Radon's actions were morally wrong. I take that back. I can't edit my original comment.

The only beef I had was the non-compete agreement, which I believe is illegal in California.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by moosebear847 on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:47PM (#27430461)
As a thought experiment, if you ran a business, and all your ex-employees released a free version of the same product, would you be cool with this? Could you hang out with them, smile and say everything is totally cool?

Or would you want to ask them to not release free versions of your paid product?

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by ghosty141 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:47AM (#27431022)
Why should people leave your company and start something new if they are happy in their position right now?

Most of the time, this kind of "exodus" happens because the business somehow mismanaged their employees which resulted in them not being happy, leaving the business and opening up a new one.

Even then, if I knew my business would be superior, I wouldn't mind that much. In the case of repl.it I don't see any reason why Riju would pose even the tiniest threat. It's super basic with no obvious plans to be compete with repl.it. Just look at the polish of both products, one is a serious business with funding secured while the other one is a small OS web-app written by somebody in their free time.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by moosebear847 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:15AM (#27431506)
There is a small (to your point, pretty small) risk that it could be used in place of repl.it or inspire other competitors. If this was done by an outsider, this would be totally fine and healthy for consumers.

However, this is someone that the business helped out. One would hope that the person would reciprocate with positive value for the business, rather than negative value in the form of risk.

If you are interested I wrote another response alluding to the golden rule in a reply close by: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27431326

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by xenihn on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:31AM (#27430655)
>As a thought experiment, if you ran a business, and all your ex-employees released a free version of the same product, would you be cool with this? Could you hang out with them, smile and say everything is totally cool?

I've actually seen this exact situation play out twice (except the new products were not free), though I wasn't directly involved. Both times, it only happened because the business owner was, to put it bluntly, a bad person who had no business (heh) running a company, and the result was a mass exodus that birthed a direct competitor.

To answer your thought experiment:

I am looking at this as an employee, as a controlled person. You are looking at it as a founder, owner, or some other type of position that holds power. A controller.

Those with power would view it as immoral. An action like this threatens their power. Those who have enough power to exert a controlling influence, want, above all else, to maintain that power, while also increasing it. Anything that impedes that is unfair, and thus immoral.

Those without power, or with less power, do not see it as immoral, because it is a redistribution of power to those who deserve it just as much, if not more. It is fair. It is just. It is moral.

You see this as immoral because your sympathies lie with those who have power. Might makes right. The states that enforce non-competes have the same view as you, but California does not, and that is one of the many reasons that it remains the global center of technological innovation.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by moosebear847 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:43AM (#27431326)
Rather than looking at it from the view of an employee or founder with power, I am attempting to view it through the lens of a good relationship between two people, with this being mainly defined through the golden rule - treating others as one wants to be treated.

It would seem to me that if I hadn't chosen to train and work with this person, he probably wouldn't have chosen this exact product to release out of all the possibilities in the world.

Let's say that he had an innate inclination for this exact product and would have done it even if he hadn't worked for me. Even then, he wouldn't have been privvy to the various and more detailed information that you are exposed to as an insider.

Going forward, I would be wary of any information I share with this person, given that it could work against me. This would definitely harm our relationship, and I would wish that this person would not do this to me.

If this were a fishing village, and the main thing to do around here was fishing, I would understand. There's not much choice there. But given that there are many different things this person could have worked on besides my exact product, my reaction would be, 'really man?'

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by xenihn on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:07AM (#27431452)
Does your interpretation of the golden rule involve browbeating with unfounded legal threats that wouldn't stand up in court?
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by moosebear847 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:28AM (#27431571)
That legal threat was not a good response. I think both sides messed up here.

It seems like the ex-intern made an honest mistake especially given his age. This isn't exactly the same but Helen Keller messed up and plagiarised when she was young before. People do dumb things, especially when they're young.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by gilrain on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @09:06AM (#27434614)
"As a thought experiment"

=

"The actual situation is indefensible, so let's argue a situation of my choosing which is."

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by moosebear847 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:40PM (#27439809)
The thought experiment is meant to take the situtation to the logical extreme, something that is unlikely to happen yet still realistically possible, in order to more clearly understand the effects of the behavior.

E.g. one guy littering isn't so big a deal, but it's clearer that littering is bad if everyone does it because the planet will get filthy fast.

Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by Aeolun on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:32PM (#27429219)
After years have passed, on a noncommercial project?
Re:Replit used legal threats to kill my open-source project by phonon on Monday June 07, 2021 @08:28PM (#27429185)