If a programmer is able to decipher so called business requirements and find holes there, why shouldn't he check contract for himself?
The band sells the right to its music, in exchange for the advance. If the band's income exceeds 1000% of the advance, it will get 10% of the income as an extra bonus. And when the contract ends, the label returns the rights back to the band.
What does the band get? An advance, possibly a bonus, marketing and promotion for the brand, and usually the rights to some other forms of income (concerts, merchandise etc).
Isn't this paying the advance back?
Counter argument: what has more utility than bringing people happiness?
That 2009 music industry revenue would pay for, what, 70,000 programmers? And there are a whole lot more programmers than that earning good money.
(Note: I'm only looking at RIAA figures, and ignoring independent artists, so it's understated to a certain extent. However, I believe RIAA revenue still makes up the majority, probably the vast majority, of total music revenue.)
But I sure am glad that the music industry CAN "bully" an industry far greater in the same way that I am glad that I can (if I had time and money) to do it because of the freedom of litigation.
Is it at all reasonable they get to force ISPs to enforce their rules without litigation? Is it reasonable to be legally able to charge me $250,000 in the US to circumvent the CSS "encryption" on a DVD?