News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by throwaway3699 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:01PM (#27414479)
I don't know, inference from data is literally how all decisions are fundamentally made. Why wouldn't it be possible to create models that learn this particular pattern?
Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by mjburgess on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:18PM (#27414617)
Here's where the words "data", "pattern", etc. become unhelpful.

Learning, as in what we do, is not learning associations in datasets.

It is learning "associations" between: our body state and the world as we act. It's a sort of: (action, world, body, sensation, prior conceptualisation, ...) association. (Even then, our bodies grow and this is really not a formal process.)

This is, at least, what is necessary to understand what words mean. Words are just tools that we use to coordinate with each other in a shared (physical) world. You really have to be here, with us, to understand them. Words mean what we do with them.

Meaning has a "useful side-effect". It turns out when we are using words their sequencing reveals, on average, some commonalities in their use. Eg., when asking "Can you pass me the salt?" I may go on to ask, "and now the pepper". And thus there is a statistical association between the terms "salt" and "pepper".

But a machine processing only those associations is completely unaware there is anything "salt" to pass, or even that there are objects in the world, or people, or anything. Really, the machine has no connection between its interior and the world, the very connection we have when we use words.

When a machine generates the text "pass me the salt" it doesnt mean it. It cannot. There is no salt it's talking about. It doesnt even know what salt is.

A machine used to make decisions concerning people, unaware of what a person even is, produces new unethical forms of action. Not merely just "being racist because the data is".

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by seanp2k2 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:11PM (#27415007)
We also tend to have decades of experience interacting with other humans and understanding what would be reasonable to want / moral / what would “make sense”.

This is a big part of why I’m bearish on things like fully autonomous self-driving cars until general AI is achieved. Driving is fundamentally a social activity that you participate in with other humans, at least until we built out nation-wide autonomous-only lanes that only allow (through a gate or barrier) autonomous vehicles with self-driving engaged in a way that normal vehicles can’t “sneak in”…I’m not holding my breath. Maybe I’ll see it in my lifetime (30s), maybe not.

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by mjburgess on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:16PM (#27415038)
"Bearish" understates my mood.

I think we're drifting into charlatanism, fraud and pseudoscience.

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by michaelpb on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:41PM (#27415225)
Perhaps religious cult territory too. "The Algorithm" [1] is already being used to tell fortunes -- which if it just stays as a few people having fun with horoscopes I don't really care, it seems harmless. But I could also totally picture some cryptocoin charlatan getting revelations about The Spiritual Algorithm or something and starts selling AI for getting into heaven.

---

[1] By "The Algorithm" I just mean the public colloquially reference to trending formulas used on TikTok etc, which I'm sure probably uses machine learning somewhere

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by mjburgess on Monday June 07, 2021 @03:13AM (#27419903)
I agree. I have the same reactions to these guys as I did to religious zealots when I was a teenager; and later to "transhumanism". Alarm, disbelief, hostility.

There is a new secular religion underneath this.

"Uploading consciousness", "Aren't we all just data systems?", "We've built a neural network with as many (meaningless) neurones as the brain!"

It's the same disgust and denial at being biological animals that all religions foster.

Thankfully here, I think, the religion has predictions. It predicts a self-driving car, a "fourth industrial revolution", and so on. When these fail to materialise, some sanity will return.

(Of course they have already failed, the question is when in the next 5-10yrs people will realise.)

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by michaelpb on Monday June 07, 2021 @11:04PM (#27430193)
> It's the same disgust and denial at being biological animals that all religions foster.

Huh, I didn't think of it that way! Good point!

I love history and a few weeks ago I read passage in a history book on a period in the early 19th century dominated by "American radicalism" (a liberal movement) and "transcendentalism" [1], when many hucksters and itinerant pastors profited off of the hype of industrialization. It immediately reminded me of the modern crypto / AI hype. In both cases, it actually is simply more smoke-and-mirrors to remove culpable human elements from a changing system --- by replacing it with "AI" and "crypto" (today), or the "invisible hand" and "radical self-reliance" (the 1820s-1830s US).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcendentalism - and history "rhymed" 100 years later - https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/135050842091057... and I would argue that it "rhymes" once again today with Musk following in Ford's footsteps, although with perhaps less intent than Ford

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by noema on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:19PM (#27443516)
Hubert Dreyfus's critiques of AI systems (particularly, their all but total inability to bodily engage with a social world) still remain relevant.
Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by pjc50 on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:32PM (#27414706)
> A machine used to make decisions concerning people, unaware of what a person even is, produces new unethical forms of action. Not merely just "being racist because the data is".

Powerful and concise, thank you.

Re:Microsoft’s Kate Crawford: ‘AI is neither artificial nor ... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday June 06, 2021 @02:24PM (#27415096)
I think you can create models that learn this particular pattern, but the models being told that oppression is a bad thing will determine that being black is a bad thing and from there that black people are bad.