News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by babelfish on Friday June 04, 2021 @01:55PM (#27396594)
Is this really a surprise to anybody? UFO means "unidentified flying object", not "alien".
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by vlovich123 on Friday June 04, 2021 @01:59PM (#27396656)
For some reason all the news reporting I’ve seen about it breathlessly insinuates aliens without actually saying that because they’d be legitimately ridiculed. Alluding to it though brings in more viewers. Kind of disgusting.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by savanaly on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:15PM (#27396929)
It feels a bit like the lab-virus theory felt last year. If you entertain the notion of it you're supposed to be ridiculed and possibly kicked out of polite society, but does it really deserve to be set alongside flat earth theory and intelligent design? I'm not so sure we won't look differently at it years from now.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by vlovich123 on Friday June 04, 2021 @06:25PM (#27399770)
No, it’s not science violating like flat earth or unscientific like intelligent design. So from that perspective, it obviously shouldn’t be dismissed out-of-hand. It’s still so far out there in terms of an actual possibility that there’s no point speculating. Mundane reasons are far more likely, especially since extraterrestrials on our planet would imply extraterrestrials with a significant technological advantage - likely extrasolar (implying FTL) & able to evade all sorts of detection methods. Even if you think there’s a massive government conspiracy to conceal their detection, you’d be claiming this conspiracy is effective at hiding it from all sorts of academic telescopes/satellites/radars (these are extraterrestrials so they’d have to live off-earth).

In essence, the claim of “aliens” (particularly intelligent ones) is outlandish given our current understanding of the universe. Of course that could change in the future but speculating wildly about it now & reporting on it similarly is irresponsible.

And as for the lab virus theory, that’s a bad analogy. The zoonotic origin is more plausible but it’s probably like 2:1 or 10:1 odds against it being a lab escape. For aliens you’re looking at like 1000000:1 odds against.

Heck, humans from parallel dimensions seem more likely at the point where we’re wildly speculating without any evidence. Why is aliens the dominant theory?

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by phpnode on Friday June 04, 2021 @01:58PM (#27396636)
I've heard a lot of credulous people describing these reports as proof of aliens. To me the idea that aliens exist is unsurprising, but aliens being here would imply FTL is possible, and that would be a huge discovery!
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:30PM (#27397199)
I don't think aliens being here implies FTL travel. If we're assuming that there's such a huge thing we don't know, it seems equally likely (or even more likely) to be a surprising surprise. We're assuming that they got here in a way we didn't anticipate, so why assume that it's via FTL travel?
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by komaromy on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:06PM (#27396775)
> aliens being here would imply FTL is possible

Why? There are plenty of stars within a sub-light-speed radius since events that could've announced us to the galaxy: advent of radio, first nuclear tests, etc.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by flatline on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:16PM (#27396945)
My favorite back of the napkin math about the practical reality of interstellar space travel, from cstross:

https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_hig...

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by lazide on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:12PM (#27396886)
The sheer timescales and energy levels involved with all known methods of transportation is what makes it unlikely - at least for life on the timescales we live on.

The odds someone is interested enough to spend truly mind boggling amounts of energy (literally moving hundreds of mountains worth) and hundred of years to check us out after one of those events - and not even say hi - is low. That they are also so close - also low. If they have some sort of magic drive tech (implied by the behavior of these drive sightings), then that changes the math a lot.

Most people mean ‘magic drive tech’ when they say FTL.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by userulluipeste on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:07PM (#27401301)
"The odds someone is interested enough to spend truly mind boggling amounts of energy (literally moving hundreds of mountains worth) and hundred of years to check us out after one of those events - and not even say hi - is low. That they are also so close - also low."

How could one even begin to make that kind of reasoning? Then the conclusion estimating the low probability is based on what? If I'd have to guess, I'd say otherwise - once a reasonably developed civilization (Kardashev type II and above) gets access to colossal amount of energy, there aren't that many things worth spending it (and attention in general) for. Life may or may not be plentiful around in the universe (it occured relatively shortly after Earth formation), but I'd bet sentient life is orders of magnitude more scarce, considering that it took billions for it to develop on Earth. That alone would make potential cradles for sentient life to be very interesting destinations to check once in a while. To provide here a relatable example, let's imagine a mostly desert continent, with a community living somewhere on its coast. At one point they develop enough capabilities to safely venture out in the desert and to make long journeys. How interested would they be in revisiting some oasis where they encountered some earthworms and small plants, and how interested would they be in revisiting a place (even across the continent, if that is what takes) with apes which happened to also exhibit some signs of primitive engineering?

P.S.: With all that, I still hope we're alone within a large enough vicinity, so we won't have to deal with anyone else for as long as our species exists.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by lazide on Sunday June 06, 2021 @01:26AM (#27411000)
It’s pretty simple math? We’ve only had meaningful ‘not background event’ radio transmissions for about 115 years [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_radio]. Assuming no faster than light travel or similar magic (to the earlier point), but some near light speed magic drive, even if our potential visitors had the ability (and interest) to accelerate to light speed the moment they picked up Marconi’s initial broadcast, they would have to be within about 57-58 light years or less radius of us.

There are roughly 1400 star systems within 50 light years of us [http://www.atlasoftheuniverse.com/50lys.html]

Which sounds like a lot. But there is estimated to be about 10 to 100 billion star systems in the Milky Way alone. So the odds that any of those stars are occupied by any excitijg neighbors is pretty low, unless the number of alien species+occupied star systems is mind bogglingly large. If there are 100 occupied star systems randomly dispersed in the galaxy meeting all these requirements, it would be one in 70,000 to 1 in 700,000 odds for instance.

Not great. And that is assuming a lot about how much energy they would be willing to expend. We’ve seen no evidence of anything resembling a Kardashev type civilization in the neighborhood.

If there is magic FTL tech, obviously everything is different. Also, who knows maybe we grew up next door to an equivalent to a intergalactic bus depot. That would also change things.

At least based on what we know now though, the tyranny of the rocket equation is rather complete, the distances involved in traveling between star systems so vast, and the energy requirements of even approaching C are so high that it is not a realistic thing to consider for life that works the way we do any time soon.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by userulluipeste on Monday June 07, 2021 @10:38AM (#27423137)
Your math is sound, but I don't agree with all your data inputs. Specifically, that only (the engineered) radio signals would pick the attention of an alien civilization. (In fact, I think that Marconi's or most of the subsequent man generated signals, maybe with exception of nuclear detonations and such, were to faint to be picked up even from within the limits of our own planetary system.) The most obvious clue for presence of life, visible from far away, started with the Great Oxygenation Event. That enough should put Earth on anyone's map, and that happened 2 billions years ago. Achieving 100% of light speed is not possible within our current knowledge, but I assume that 20% should be for non life-carrier spacecraft, which at our galaxy's 200ly diameter gives us a cap of around 1'000 years of travel between most of the intra-galactic destinations. Even with a 10'000 technological head-start, a given civilization can devise a system to achieve galactic oversight. If there's indeed someone out there, with such a head-start, we should assume they're already watched our planet closely and maybe even getting a continuous track of our evolution.

As for "we’ve seen no evidence of anything resembling a Kardashev type civilization in the neighborhood", although you're right, it's hardly useful to think in this frame. The available means that we had so far for observing anything in far away space were and still are pretty limited, for even inert phenomena. I'd say that counting on that to spot something sentient, where things are actively engineered, which may as well include engineering for the appearance itself, is overly optimistic.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by lazide on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:45PM (#27440536)
We’re just getting more and more hypothetical in a complete vacuum of real information though right?

If we’re trying to get something even somewhat defensible, there has to be some grounding on SOMETHING, or it’s all just fantasy.

If they spent 10k ly getting here, and the ungodly amount of energy and time it would take to do 20% of light speed over that distance, and they had since the great oxygenation event to notice us and get here (and have such a technological and energy advantage over us they were able to do it) - then why are they being seen randomly checking out military aircraft (not very smart or subtle it seems?) but never talk to anyone else? And show no other signs of existing?

Not impossible, but seems like a truly massive amount of energy and commitment of time over what far exceeds the timescales life as we know it works on to check out what could just be a puddle full of gooey algae for all they knew. And then potentially just sitting and watching for 100 million or a billion years.

At least seeing radio signals or a double flash from a nuke test means there is something like intelligent life?

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by userulluipeste on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @09:55AM (#27447837)
"We’re just getting more and more hypothetical in a complete vacuum of real information though right?"

Not really. Both of us were counting on current human knowledge, that our galaxy is this (light years) large, that the maximum speed is that of light and that an exponential amounts of energy is needed for each logarithmic increment of relativistic speed, that there is a working model for life based on what we call organic chemistry, that an atmosphere rich in a highly reactant element that is oxygen can not exist without something continuously producing it and what that could mean for an alien observer, all because, in the slim chance that we are the ones with technological head-start, that should serve as base ingredients for thinking about our long-term future external policy. I'm thinking if we are to become Kardashev type II (and above) civilization, what ought to be the best approach in dealing with an evolving galaxy? But yes, there are also aspects which are hard to think of now in more than hypothetical terms, like what would mean in practical terms to have access to (at least) a star's amount of energy and what it would be worth spending it on. To me, "to check out what could just be a puddle full of gooey algae" looks like a very important objective, and finding something underwhelming should be the desired result, safety wise.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by knute on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:17PM (#27396960)
Even near-lightspeed travel (say, >0.2C) would be leaps and bounds beyond what we know how to do at this point.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by dragonwriter on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:13PM (#27396896)
> aliens being here would imply FTL is possible

No, aliens (or alien-made un-aliened probes) being here wouldn't mean FTL is possible. It would imply very advanced societies are capable of diverting energy into projects with very long payoff windows, but not the existence of FTL travel.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by Marsymars on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:19PM (#27396999)
> aliens being here would imply FTL is possible, and that would be a huge discovery!

"Huge discovery" is understanding that - FTL would imply that either causality doesn't hold, or that we've fundamentally misunderstood relativity.

Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by spideymans on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:57PM (#27397596)
Not necessarily. These could very well be a fleet of self-replicating “unmanned” drones that were sent on a mission to explore the galaxy millions of years ago. Heck, our own civilization likely isn’t all that far off (relatively speaking) from being able to do the same thing
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by arkitaip on Friday June 04, 2021 @01:59PM (#27396658)
There are literally millions of people who expected this to be the big reveal about aliens. It's crazy how the US military has been teasing the UFO community during the last few years.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by gruez on Friday June 04, 2021 @01:58PM (#27396645)
That's the strict definition, but to most people "UFOs" are still associated with "aliens".
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by beermonster on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:05PM (#27396743)
That’s how I interpret it. But I guess other people choose to interpret it as ‘little green men’. That makes it hard to investigate without ridicule. So maybe the name change is all about being able to do that?
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by 6gvONxR4sf7o on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:27PM (#27397144)
In terms of hollywood and pop culture, UFO 100% means alien. It's a great example of a piece of niche jargon getting a non-niche meaning, which ends up kinda taking over the word.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by tangy_fluid on Friday June 04, 2021 @03:34PM (#27398094)
UFO means "unidentified flying object". A spinning top UFO 12 hours a day, every day for 2 years means aliens.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by OldGoodNewBad on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:10PM (#27396850)
Aliens are demons, they don’t need special machines to fly through the air and probe people’s butts in the middle of the night.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by ChrisGranger on Friday June 04, 2021 @03:02PM (#27397667)
You say that like it's a statement of fact, yet present no evidence. This isn't helpful.
Re:No evidence UFOs are alien craft, unclassified US intelli... by OldGoodNewBad on Friday June 04, 2021 @04:39PM (#27398825)
It’s as helpful as speculating on their nature in any other way. People get wide eyed and excited at the concept of intergalactic or ultra-dimensional “aliens” yet scoff at the simple idea that they’re just demons. Both require a mountain of unproven assumptions, why’s one worse than the other?

I happen to know, of course.