News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by bellyfullofbac on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:02PM (#27387266)
A lot of people are indeed arguing that there needs to be more "positive discrimination" to help groups who've so far (on average) suffered the effects of negative discrimination. I tend to agree that it's necessary. But understandably, someone who's part of "not going to get an advantage" group would complain of negative discrimination. IANAL, but yeah, in the cold hard logic of laws, positive discrimination is surely against that law.

Now watch people misinterpret this comment and call me names...

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by gambiting on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:06PM (#27387322)
Positive discrimination is absolutely discrimination as well. You can't have a job offer that says "only women applicants", but there's nothing illegal about only ever advertising in say, women-targetted media or products, even if the position is open to everyone. That's not defined as descrimination in law(I'm not saying it's right or wrong, just that by law that's not discrimination).
Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by balls187 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:24PM (#27387543)
That isn't entirely true.

There are instances where there is bona fide qualification for being a specific gender.

It's not common, but does exist.

Megan Fox will not likely win a lawsuit alleging discrimination based on EEO Law if I did not cast her in the role of Barack Obama in my HBO Miniseries on the Death of Osama bin Laden.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by cm2187 on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:16PM (#27387443)
Which is pretty much redlining
Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by tylerhou on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:57PM (#27387916)
In my opinion, much of the time "positive discrimination" is a misnomer. The most salient debate is in college admissions — some people believe that BIPOC have an "easier" time getting admitted to schools like Harvard with the same amount of "merit." ("Easier" and "merit" in quotes for reasons below.)

Often, they justify this by claiming that Asian and white people have to score much higher on the SAT to gain admissions. But that's probably the wrong metric. The purpose of college is to grow students, which means a better metric of merit is not a snapshot of how proficient a student is at a particular moment in time, but by how much they have improved from some baseline.

We also know that society puts BIPOC at a disadvantage because of their race. For example, historical and present day discrimination means that they have less economic power, which directly translates to educational disadvantage (worse schools, worse nutrition, less time interacting with parents who may work longer hours). BIPOC are also less likely to be recommended for gifted programs at the same level of skill. Therefore (because of society) their baseline is lower.

So given the above two points, I don't really see admission of BIPOC as discrimination at if you shift the metric to "ability to grow." IMO this is also reflected in the admissions criteria; the ability to overcome adversity is sometimes cited, and adverse life events usually accompany some amount of growth. And even though the average SAT score is lower for BIPOC applicants, that average is not low enough for those people not to be able to handle the courseworks.

That's not to say that all BIPOC applicants come from a lower baseline than all Asian/white applicants; of course there will be some distribution overlap. But using growth as a metric (instead of absolute score) could probably explain most of the test score/GPA discrepancy.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 03, 2021 @06:23PM (#27388197)
I think this is getting into semantic mismatch at this point, it seems like you and the above commenter agree pretty much in entirety at a conceptual level just using different terms.

Your comment describes the meaning encapsulated in the term "positive discrimination". Groups have been disadvantaged throughout history, so the institution is deliberately assigning advantages for members of the group to offset that.

> And even though the average SAT score is lower for BIPOC applicants, that average is not low enough for those people not to be able to handle the courseworks.

This is not entirely true. Lower SAT scores are correlated with dropping out of certain majors at much higher rates. This is a significant factor in lower URM representation in STEM graduates: https://lawreviewblog.uchicago.edu/2020/10/30/aa-arcidiacono...

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by tylerhou on Thursday June 03, 2021 @10:13PM (#27389773)
> This is not entirely true. Lower SAT scores are correlated with dropping out of certain majors at much higher rates.

This statement needs more careful examination for two reasons. First, students drop out for various reasons that are not academic, including personal reasons. It's possible that if you come from a lower-income family, your family circumstances change such that you can no longer attend school. Even those who dropout for academic reasons may have their academics affected by their personal life, and without personal difficulty they may have been able to handle the coursework. So such a finding would not contradict my claim that most people have the ability to handle the coursework.

Second, because of Simpson's Paradox (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox). When you aggregate all students, you may find that lower SAT scores correlate with high dropout rates, but that would also be consistent with a school environment that discriminates against BIPOC. (Just because the admissions environment attempts to compensate for discrimination by measuring "growth" doesn't mean that the schools themselves cannot exhibit elitism and/or racism.) Your article doesn't provide any data (so I have no evidence to support this), but it's possible that if you separated SAT scores out by race, the score has little to no effect on dropout rates.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by Manuel_D on Thursday June 03, 2021 @11:47PM (#27390344)
The relationship between academic preparedness and persistence in STEM majors held true between White, Asian, Black, and Latin students. It also held true across class and income. A white, wealthy trust fund student with lower test scores is just as likely to change from a STEM major to another as a poor BIPOC student. In other words, a student with the same scores had the same likelihood of dropping out across any race. This is much more consistent with an academic testing system that accurately predicts academic ability.

Is it possible that it's actually a predictor of who will predict later extenuating circumstances inhibiting their studies? And one that works with remarkable consistency across all demographics? Maybe but I feel confident enough in the former that I'm going to expect to see data on those circumstances to which you allude before shifting conclusions.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by tylerhou on Friday June 04, 2021 @01:52AM (#27391001)
I going to need a citation for the claim in your first paragraph. I've skimmed through multiple papers (including the one you linked) and I have not seen an analysis of STEM dropout rates broken down by SAT scores and race.

https://www.google.com/search?q=SAT+score+STEM+attrition+cor...

Also, such a paper should analyze dropout rates at elite colleges, as it's possible that the correlation degrades after a certain threshold.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by Manuel_D on Friday June 04, 2021 @02:54AM (#27391292)
The paper was cited in the article: https://perma.cc/8M8L-GCUC

And yes, it is limited to an elite college (Duke University).

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by tylerhou on Friday June 04, 2021 @07:49PM (#27400487)
I don't think that paper says what you claim it says. From the conclusion:

> However, even though we have shown substantial evidence that Duke does indeed possess private information about the student’s future performance, we cannot conclude that there is mismatch.

It (claims to) disprove the hypothesis that there is no mismatch because Duke possess no private information, as private information is a necessary (but not sufficient) condition for mismatch.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by Manuel_D on Friday June 04, 2021 @09:09PM (#27400986)
The study didn't conclude that there was mismatch, because it didn't measure whether or not students chose differently when given information on their likely academic performance given their level of ability:

> In sum, Duke’s private information on student performance is important beyond the student’s grade point average, affecting both the student’s subjective well-being as well as the likelihood of persisting in a difficult major. It is important to note, however, that we have still only established that some of the necessary conditions for mismatch are met. For mismatch to exist, information must not only be important but the revelation of the information must change the institution the individual would have chosen to attend. Hence, even if individuals find out they are not as academically strong as they thought, the information still may not have changed their decisions.

Let's not lose track of what I initially claimed: that lower levels of academic preparedness lead to students changing out of science/engineering majors, and that this was consistent across race. The study did find that this was true. And this was limited to students at an elite university. Mismatch is about what students would have done when given this information, which is not directly related to my claim

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by Zababa on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:33PM (#27387629)
One thing that I don't really like with positive discrimination is that you don't really know if and when it's going to end. I would be more confortable with it if the goal was clear from the start, and the discrimination was then automatically deduced from this.

Another point is that when a group of people call for more diversity, which would be attained by employing more people from this group, I tend to see tribalism more than diversity. Of course in a way it's fine, it's the basis of human behavior, but it still feels weird to me.

Re:Snowflake CEO Says Worker Merit Should Outweigh Diversity... by nojokes on Thursday June 03, 2021 @05:57PM (#27387912)
There is no such thing as positive discrimination.