Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by sigzero on Thursday July 07, 2011 @12:10PM
(#2739040)
Or Microsoft having "Windows" ?
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by Tiomaidh on Thursday July 07, 2011 @12:34PM
(#2739140)
There's a lot more to an operating system than how it manages non-fullscreen applications. "Windows" is obviously a related term, but I don't think it's generic--when I boot up Linux on my laptop, I don't say, "This Linux/Xorg/Openbox combination sure is a great windows!" But I might say, "This collection of software for my smartphone compiled and sold by Amazon sure is a great app store."
Edit: See also: MS Office, MS Word, MS Security Essentials, and arguably MS Internet Explorer and Windows Explorer (I browse the internet and manage/browse files--there's not much literal "exploring" going on)
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by mikemaccana on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:09PM
(#2739305)
> I don't think it's generic--when I boot up Linux on my laptop, I don't say, "This Linux/Xorg/Openbox combination sure is a great windows!"
You never 'open a window', or 'close a window', or 'change a window'? You might be younger than me (I'm 30) but I've been doing that since having an Atari ST in the last 80s.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by burgerbrain on Thursday July 07, 2011 @04:15PM
(#2740106)
As far as I know, MSFT doesn't have a trademark on the term "window" as used to describe objects in a GUI. They have a trademark on the term "Windows" as a whole system.
Same reason you can buy "linux" laundry detergent.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by mikemaccana on Friday July 08, 2011 @04:04AM
(#2741648)
Windows began as an installable GUI, target than a whole system. It was only in 1995 that it started doing more than windowing.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by burgerbrain on Friday July 08, 2011 @01:35PM
(#2743338)
Even so, their trademark in that case was on the windowing system. Not on the UI elements generally called "windows".
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by mikemaccana on Sunday July 10, 2011 @06:17PM
(#2748739)
I'm going to flat disagree that windowing systems and window UI elements are separate fields of endeavor, in the same way that laundry detergent and computer Operating Systems are. I think most lawyers would too.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App...
by mikemaccana on Friday July 08, 2011 @07:14AM
(#2741975)
Ahem, 'target' should be 'rather'. Hooray autocorrect.
Maybe you didn't use the TI-83+, which has an "Apps" button on it, and was designed in 1999.
And though I agree that Apple has put a lot of effort into its app store, I feel like saying that they should have sole access to the term is comparable to AOL suing anyone who uses "instant messenger" to refer to something other than AIM.