News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by Tiomaidh on Thursday July 07, 2011 @10:52AM (#2738662)
>Before I switched to OS X, I've never heard of any software being called "apps" on any other platform I used

Maybe you didn't use the TI-83+, which has an "Apps" button on it, and was designed in 1999.

And though I agree that Apple has put a lot of effort into its app store, I feel like saying that they should have sole access to the term is comparable to AOL suing anyone who uses "instant messenger" to refer to something other than AIM.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by sigzero on Thursday July 07, 2011 @12:10PM (#2739040)
Or Microsoft having "Windows" ?
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by Tiomaidh on Thursday July 07, 2011 @12:34PM (#2739140)
There's a lot more to an operating system than how it manages non-fullscreen applications. "Windows" is obviously a related term, but I don't think it's generic--when I boot up Linux on my laptop, I don't say, "This Linux/Xorg/Openbox combination sure is a great windows!" But I might say, "This collection of software for my smartphone compiled and sold by Amazon sure is a great app store."

Edit: See also: MS Office, MS Word, MS Security Essentials, and arguably MS Internet Explorer and Windows Explorer (I browse the internet and manage/browse files--there's not much literal "exploring" going on)

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by mikemaccana on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:09PM (#2739305)
> I don't think it's generic--when I boot up Linux on my laptop, I don't say, "This Linux/Xorg/Openbox combination sure is a great windows!"

You never 'open a window', or 'close a window', or 'change a window'? You might be younger than me (I'm 30) but I've been doing that since having an Atari ST in the last 80s.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by burgerbrain on Thursday July 07, 2011 @04:15PM (#2740106)
As far as I know, MSFT doesn't have a trademark on the term "window" as used to describe objects in a GUI. They have a trademark on the term "Windows" as a whole system.

Same reason you can buy "linux" laundry detergent.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by mikemaccana on Friday July 08, 2011 @04:04AM (#2741648)
Windows began as an installable GUI, target than a whole system. It was only in 1995 that it started doing more than windowing.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by burgerbrain on Friday July 08, 2011 @01:35PM (#2743338)
Even so, their trademark in that case was on the windowing system. Not on the UI elements generally called "windows".
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by mikemaccana on Sunday July 10, 2011 @06:17PM (#2748739)
I'm going to flat disagree that windowing systems and window UI elements are separate fields of endeavor, in the same way that laundry detergent and computer Operating Systems are. I think most lawyers would too.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by mikemaccana on Friday July 08, 2011 @07:14AM (#2741975)
Ahem, 'target' should be 'rather'. Hooray autocorrect.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by Tiomaidh on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:57PM (#2739536)
Sure I perform window operations, but they're not nearly the same thing as using Windows--which entails a lot more than using windows.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by cosgroveb on Thursday July 07, 2011 @10:51AM (#2738645)
I've never heard of any software being called "apps" on any other platform I used

I heard the term "killer app" at least 10 years ago. "App" is not only generic but it's been out there for a long time.

Edit: Here's the earliest I can find the word in print. It's from 2002. http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/55/love.html

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by Pinckney on Thursday July 07, 2011 @12:08PM (#2739030)
The OED has quotations for "app, n." dating back to 1985:

"1985 Info World (Nexis) 9 Dec. 41 At first look, the user sees only one new menu (‘apps’ for applications) at the top of the screen."

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by Tiomaidh on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:09AM (#2738742)
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by _delirium on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:42AM (#2738902)
Google Books also has a lot of uses in the early 1990s of the phrases "Windows apps", "Mac apps", "DOS apps", and "Unix apps". They appear to be used in a way that's pretty similar to how the terms "iPhone apps" or "Android apps" are used today.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by Samuel_Michon on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:24PM (#2739366)
Steve Jobs has been trying to popularize the word 'app' for several decades. At the very least since the 1989 launch of NeXTSTEP, an OS that used the word all over. For instance, watch this 1992 demo of NeXTSTEP 3.0: http://hivelogic.com/articles/classic-steve-jobs/

Because of its NeXTSTEP heritage, Mac OS X uses a lot of NeXTSTEP lingo, like 'app', 'dock' and 'plist'.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by mikemaccana on Thursday July 07, 2011 @01:07PM (#2739295)
A blog article on Click N Run, an app store for Linux that was started in the early 2000s with screenshots, ratings, etc. :

' And, of course: make the apps available with just one click. '

Date is Jan 2007, before the iPhone was ever released.

http://liquidat.wordpress.com/2007/01/24/clickn-run-for-fedo...

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by untog on Thursday July 07, 2011 @10:52AM (#2738654)
Who did anything first doesn't really matter. Ask Hoover. Or the original maker of the Yo-yo.

The point is that 'apps' have entered into common usage to refer to applications on all mobile platforms. 'App' is a generic term, that isn't attached to a brand. So, if you agree that 'Store' is also generic, then 'App Store' can't really be anything but.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by jws on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:15AM (#2738763)
Radio Shack™ would disagree.

All of the words in the English language are gone for naming purposes. If you want to alter the laws to prevent protection of novel phrases then you doom us all to a future of Xobni, Loopt, Wufoo, Weebly, Buxfer, Zenter, Zecter, Fuzzwich, Fliggo, Voxli, Nambii, Olark, Mertado, Movity, and other companies drawn as Scrabble™ hands. (Ok, you can't draw Fuzzwich.) Names that don't function as names because you can't say them to someone and have that person later use them to identify the entity because they can't spell it, don't know what it means, and will forget it before they need it.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by untog on Thursday July 07, 2011 @11:33AM (#2738860)
Yeah, I realised after I posted that a combination of two generic words can be a unique name. My bad. But any combination of two generic words doesn't automatically make it a unique name, which I guess is why this got to court.
Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by wnight on Thursday July 07, 2011 @08:33PM (#2740837)
Shack isn't a usual term for store, so it's less generic.

Allowing generic words to be trademarked too easily causes problems. International Business Machines seems like a fine name right up until there are many multi-nationals making business machines. At that point IBM starts to sounds more like a descriptive (It's an IBM, it's got English and German on the keys...)

Selectric on the other hand, seems like a name the public benefits by protecting.

Re:Judge Denies Apple Request To Stop Amazon From Using "App... by jules on Thursday July 07, 2011 @10:50AM (#2738643)
App is now a generic name, and thus it cannot be trademarked and existing trademarks are invalid. That's just how trademarks work. It doesn't matter that it didn't use to be a generic name (and I recall hearing app used generically for a long time, so I don't think it was ever Apple specific).