News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by gojomo on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @12:40AM (#273709)
The average upvoter has become less sophisticated.

A top story for almost two days was a screenshot of a hapless fellow complaining about mistakenly ordering the 'I Am Rich' iPhone app. (It got 59 story upvotes, and this was in addition to other news coverage of the app.) The thread had multiple highly-rated comments that were no more insightful than "ha, don't click 'buy' if you don't want to buy". (Two of those had over 20 net upvotes.)

The idiot hordes have arrived and are breeding like rabbits through mutual upvotes. Death of News.YC predicted; news at 11.

Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by thaumaturgy on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @02:43AM (#273778)
This is an utterly predictable problem.

News.YC has been mentioned in enough places -- like Reddit, where I migrated from -- that it's been gathering some influence from those places. PG has been curiously adamant about not doing anything algorithmically to address this, instead insisting that somehow this forum will just never accumulate the kind of cruft that every other web-based forum accumulates.

I think that web-based forums have to follow one of the basic rules of capitalism, in that it has one of three states: either it's dying, or it's growing slowly, or it's growing quickly.

Interesting conversations and submissions happen as a way for people to signal information to other people that they think might not be aware of it, and might find it interesting. Assuming it were possible for a forum to never either lose nor gain participants, eventually the participants would share most of the information that they weren't mutually familiar with, and those that were interested in external sources of information that they weren't initially aware of would begin to follow them, and there'd be nothing left to share. The forum gradually gets quieter, and dies.

Or, the forum can grow. It may grow quickly, as with Reddit or Digg or Fark or what-have-you, in which case it has a natural tendency towards more mainstream topics. Or, it can grow slowly, like News.YC, but it still gathers a little bit of new blood, and inevitably, that new blood brings a certain fraction of mainstream interest along with it.

The funny thing is, a forum in a slow state of growth will tend to accelerate into a faster state of growth, as the gradual increase in mainstream topics draws the interest of a larger cross-section of people.

So, the trick is to enforce a slower state of growth without killing it altogether, and I haven't seen any willingness here to do that.

Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by biohacker42 on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @11:15AM (#274073)
Captcha, but not for bots, for humans.

The way I found reddit was from a link in pg's essays. And boy was reddit good when pg first linked to it. So we need a place where the only people are the kind who would voluntarily read something like pg or steve yegge.

Perhaps a simple logic puzzle wrapped inside a question about programming? That would require both factual knowledge of programming and at least a modicum of thinking ability.

That's your captcha for posts and voting permissions.

The problem I see is how to generate the captcha question/reply pairs. Perhaps something wiki style?

Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by gaika on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @12:37PM (#274175)
For each problem in Project Euler there is a forum that is open only after you solve it. One of the hard ones has "First!" comment in there.
Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by aswanson on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @08:35AM (#273933)
Glad someone else has noted the karma inflation. It used to be that to cross the 20 point threshold for a comment it had to be insightful. Now the first snide reply to a rhetorical question an article poses gets 30+ easily.
Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by ardit33 on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @01:20AM (#273743)
I kinda agree. Especially if there is a thread about macs, and you dare say macs are too expensive, you will get downvoted to death. It's like fanboys have arrived, and herd mentality is being prevalent. Unless the post is offensive, there is no point to downvote more than a -2, just b/c you don't agree with.
Re:Ask HN: why do we have less science related posts now tha... by KirinDave on Tuesday August 12, 2008 @03:11AM (#273795)
That thread was full of idiots on both sides, man. I wouldn't read too much into it. People, especially hackers, get stupid when it comes to religious things like editor wars, OS choices, and anything else.

Cry as we might, this HN is still better than Reddit or Digg.