A couple years ago I got into it with Comcast over an Identity fraud issue. When I threatened to take them to court for harrassment (I'd sent them more than what was needed to prove I never resided at the address in question) they tried to throw the 'binding arbitration' clause out there... When I told them I never was or would be a customer of theirs and thus wasn't held to their arbitration, they didn't quite know what to say next.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27356550
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/amazon-faced-75-000-arbitration...
Doordash then tried to get a judge to make it a class action. The judge felt that this Doordash was in this mess due to their own hypocrisy and declined their request.
[1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/12/21135474/doordash-workers...
[2] https://www.courthousenews.com/doordash-ordered-to-pay-12m-t...
"Collective" is merely a tool for not clogging courtrooms; there really isn't any other benefit to consumers here.
This really ought to be illegal.
https://www.binadox.com/blog/clickwrap-held-unenforceable-na...
In my opinion, this legal change is a huge sleeper story that is behind a number of changes in how customers are getting treated. Since customers can no longer economically avail themselves of the courts to protect themselves en-masse, certain companies find it in their interest to exploit that asymmetry for profit.
In other words, a company could always impose a harm on all of its customers for its profit. But, now, if that that company imposes a class ban through arbitration, those customers cannot, collectively, seek recourse for that harm.