News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by pb77 on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:11AM (#27355581)
Some of these landlords also have mortgage on rental property, one of my friend had a rental property, i think he was netting $100 a month. The rest went for mortgage, property tax, maintenance and property management person. He sold it in 2014.

I don't think he could have absorbed 12 month + of non rent payment and pay all those expenses out of his pocket.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by throwaway0a5e on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:12AM (#27355607)
That's just the risk of investing in real estate directly instead of through a financial instrument.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:13AM (#27355628)
The risk of being forced to house someone for free by government edict? Who doesn’t love unfunded mandates.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by titzer on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:17AM (#27355727)
What's the difference if it's empty? Same loss of revenue. And sure, some maintanence/upkeep for tenants, but given how fast properties rot when vacant, that's probably a wash.

Rent seeking with someone else's money? Yeah, that's risky.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by cronix on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:32AM (#27356027)
> What's the difference if it's empty?

Was it empty though? There is a shortage in housing and it's pretty rare to have an empty rental in this market. You're injecting conditions that don't really exist to make your point.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by threatofrain on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:59AM (#27356578)
> Rent seeking with someone else's money? Yeah, that's risky.

This point is enough.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by jressey on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:59AM (#27356593)
Oftentimes the landlord covers utilities and lumps that up in to the rent, and I have a place in New England where that is the convention. We pay $500-$600/month for heating oil in the winter. Then we have about $300 in electricity and another $300 for water/sewage.

These numbers might be off but you get the idea.

That's the difference.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by aww_dang on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:34AM (#27356069)
If empty you can more readily find another tenant, perhaps at a lower price?
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by _-david-_ on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:46AM (#27356339)
> What's the difference if it's empty?

If it is empty then someone who is willing to pay can rent it.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by root_axis on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @03:58PM (#27360421)
The government edict didn't appear in a vacuum, it was a response to a massive crisis affecting the entire country. Ultimately, from a financial perspective, this is no different from any potential crisis that could have caused a downturn in the rental market, and those risk factors are what you take on when you make rental investments.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by arrosenberg on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:19AM (#27355757)
It doesn’t sound like anyone in the government forced them to buy a rental property that stretched their finances to the limit.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by anonAndOn on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:43AM (#27356270)
The government changed the terms of fully executed private contracts. But as risk increases, so follows insurance. So if the government wants to abuse contract law, watch the rent, penalties and security deposits climb to compensate for any future "moratoriums".
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by arrosenberg on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @12:01PM (#27356615)
The government enacted emergency powers and public health laws they already possessed when those contracts were signed. Where is the abuse?

I'd be personally ok with the government bailing out smaller landlords (just because), but the largest percentage of these defaults are going to affect private equity firms who have bought an outrageous amount of the housing stock. We need to stop socializing risk and privatizing profits, and this would be a good place to start.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by anonAndOn on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @12:30PM (#27357134)
The abuse was largely in the duration and indiscriminate scope, regardless of ability to pay or not.

Student loans are cheaper precisely because they cannot be discharged in bankruptcy. Rent is cheaper because of eviction. Now that we've seen the government unilaterally discharge rent through moratorium, you can expect to see that risk profile baked into an increased monthly payment.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:21AM (#27355802)
The US government and their mandate without compensation or forbearance stretched their finances to the limit.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by arrosenberg on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:23AM (#27355835)
It sounds like they stretched their own finances to the limit. The government was trying to solve a much larger problem that required indifference to the risks they took, but sometimes that’s what the government has to do. It’s the investors job to cover risk.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by tiahura on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:43AM (#27356277)
“It sounds like they stretched their own finances to the limit. The government was trying to solve a much larger problem that required indifference to the risks they took”

Your second point sort of invalidates the first. You argue that the government isn’t the source of the harm, then justify the government action as a prudent balancing of harms.

I think the point most are making is that they were trying to solve a much larger problem, but didn’t think the problem through particularly well.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by arrosenberg on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:58AM (#27356554)
> Your second point sort of invalidates the first. You argue that the government isn’t the source of the harm, then justify the government action as a prudent balancing of harms.

No it doesn't. The pandemic caused the harm, the government acted to mitigate the worst effects of it. You seem to be of the opinion that the "worst effects" are the landlords losing out on rent, but the worst effects are millions of people ending up homeless during a pandemic, which is what the government prevented. Even if it was clumsy, I tend to think landlords would have been worse off anyways if there had been mass homelessness and higher body counts. You can't collect rent if your renters are dead or your own head is in a basket.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by behringer on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:18AM (#27355743)
If you don't want to trust the government, don't buy property controlled by the government
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by rolobio on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:20AM (#27355777)
All property is controlled by government. Name me one single place where no property laws apply.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by pseudalopex on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:37AM (#27356132)
I think that's the point.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday June 02, 2021 @02:48PM (#27372441)
Seems to me there's a constitutional amendment against that particular unfunded mandate. (Yeah, I know, that was specifically housing soldiers. I'm not sure a court would agree, constitutionally, that the government can force you to house civilians either.)
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by behringer on Wednesday June 02, 2021 @08:58PM (#27375925)
Considering the current makeup of the Supreme Court, I highly doubt they would fail to make the distinction between soldiers and civilians. Aren't half of them literal constitutionalists?
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday June 03, 2021 @12:04AM (#27377102)
I doubt they're that literal... but I could be wrong.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by rolobio on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:19AM (#27355756)
Could an argument be made under the 3rd amendment if the renter is a US soldier?
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by GavinMcG on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:21AM (#27355809)
Almost certainly not, since they're not being housed as soldiers.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by Willson50 on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:12AM (#27355600)
They also end up with a house at the end of that mortgage.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by j_walter on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:19AM (#27355767)
They end up with a 30 year old house that has been rented. There is a lot of cost in the upkeep of a rented house. When purchasing a house with the intent of renting it there are rules in place to play by when calculating the risk and return...but when the government completely rewrites the rules on the fly and basically forces you to rent for free for >1 year then its a problem.
Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by smileysteve on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:23PM (#27358095)
Fortunately, the owner also gets to expense the upkeep (that's a 30+% discount on future cashflows) and depreciate the improvements over a 27 year life, meaning that they have a capital loss even if the house appreciates in value.

Oh, and they also got to forego mortgage payments during the pandemic and also potentially write off the less than market rent that they were unable to evict during. (for 30+% off of the missed rent)

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by j_walter on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @01:54PM (#27358581)
No they didn't...they got to put off mortgage payments for a few months, and all of those became due immediately.

Expensing upkeep...writing off rent...you act like thats free money that doesn't come out of their pocket. If you depreciate the improvements, you then have to pay the taxes on it when you sell the place.

Stop acting like it's free money and there is no risk...a significant portion of landlords do not make money month to month and do this for their long term financial health. I think if you had significant money and time tied up in any investment you would be just as pissed as they are if the government changed the rules in the middle of the game.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by danaris on Wednesday June 02, 2021 @02:05PM (#27371965)
Then stop acting like the government did this capriciously with no reason. The eviction moratorium was a necessary public health measure.

Now, if you want to say "well, the government should have also enacted a mortgage moratorium, and made the banks the ones who shoulder the financial burden, rather than landlords (whether individual or corporate)," I won't argue with that in the slightest. But given who "the government" was at the time, that would have been an extremely hard sell. (Even now it would be pretty difficult.)

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by smileysteve on Wednesday June 02, 2021 @05:49PM (#27374422)
These two statements contradict

> They end up with a 30 year old house that has been rented. There is a lot of cost in the upkeep of a rented house.

> you then have to pay the taxes on it when you sell the place.

Owners only pay taxes if the gain is greater than the depreciated loss; (and if owner doesn't 1031 exchange it for another property to lose money on) so, the premise that a rented house has lost value shouldn't really intersect with a capital gain.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by smileysteve on Wednesday June 02, 2021 @05:51PM (#27374449)
> Expensing upkeep...writing off rent

Expensing missed rent and eviction costs isn't free money; it does require reserves, but it does help a 1 year impact spread out over many years.

Re:Millions of Americans could face eviction as housing prot... by ms512 on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @11:15AM (#27355662)
While that is also true, the parent post was pointing out that the landlord has a cash flow issue without rent coming in.

If they can't pay the mortgage without a renter paying, they may have the property repossessed by the bank.