News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Music Theory For Beginners (part 2) by sp332 on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @08:25AM (#2729546)
The randomness kind of bothers me. People don't write music randomly, and composition isn't just following some mechanical process and seeing what comes out. This method might get you music that sounds nice, but it can't stand up to music that is actually composed.

If you really want to learn about music, I think it's better to study good music. If you thought adding rhythm had surprising effects, this video will blow your mind: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0ZE38BQmvQ It's an analysis of Mozart in Leonard Bernstein's Norton lectures at Harvard.

Re:Music Theory For Beginners (part 2) by JonnieCache on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:16AM (#2729882)
The randomness seems to just be in there to illustrate the point about how automatic quantisation can impose structure. The author is just using the example of random notes to show how quantisation can impose structure, even on random notes.

Some artists do use randomness as part of generative music techniques, and it sparks a lot of controversy. In actual fact, randomness is not very useful for composition simply because even if you get something really nice out, you aren't going to get it again. So you either have to record everything, which becomes impractical, or you head into John Cage territory where you embrace the non-reproducibility and it becomes part of the art.

Far more effective to simply wire your studio up in such a complex manner that it behaves chaotically, which leaves you with all the serendipitous, 'surrendering to the machine' type benefits of randomness, but with the added benefit that if you hit rewind and play you will hear the same thing again.

The almighty Autechre, known for their generative music, are quizzed on this in their very interesting and geeky Sound on Sound interview: http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/apr04/articles/autechre.htm (the bit on randomness is halfway down in the "talking about our generation" box.)

Warning: UX people may have a slight breakdown when confronted with the screenshots of their custom software: http://media.soundonsound.com/sos/apr04/images/autechremax2.... (the color spectrum in the bottom right is what fascinates me, talk about indirection...)

Re:Music Theory For Beginners (part 2) by sheffield on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:13AM (#2729871)
"I would hope you put more effort into thinking of a melody and harmony than this, but the point is that rhythm makes a gigantic difference, even if everything else is messy."

You should read the article before commenting.

Re:Music Theory For Beginners (part 2) by sp332 on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @10:50AM (#2730012)
I wouldn't have minded some examples, but it bothers me that the entire lesson about rhythm is based on mashing his hands on the keyboard. If you're going to learn about rhythm, it would be useful to know what rhythm is for beyond "it sounds better than no rhythm."
Re:Music Theory For Beginners (part 2) by Goladus on Tuesday July 05, 2011 @05:30PM (#2731668)
If you aren't Mozart, though, randomness can be a shortcut past writer's block. Sometimes it's a lot easier to rein-in and organize pseudo-randomly generated ideas to make them your own than to allow instincts lead you to the same place over and over and over again.

(Incidentally that Bernstein lecture is great, thanks for linking it)