Re:Show HN: iOS Theme for jQuery Mobile
by Xuzz on Monday July 04, 2011 @08:25PM
(#2728269)
I like the idea of an iOS theme, but I feel that with iOS, you have to either get it perfect or not do it at all. That means fixing the font sizes in the headers, the button layouts and styling, and everything else to exactly match iOS. I know that most users don't know exactly how the iOS style looks down to the pixel, but if it's significantly far from that, it looks "wrong", and that kind of feeling can hurt people's impression of your site.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There is a kind of uncanny valley to UIs that imitate native UIs. For instance, I remember back when IE6 faked UI controls, they didn't act quite like the native Luna controls, and that upset some users.
I completely agree. I think I was keen on getting this out the door in an imperfect stage, just to see whether there was interest and if I should continue to develop it further.
I agree, too. Keep perfecting it and it'll be a great, useful theme.
Yes, it has to be perfect or it will ruin the expected experience.
Unfortunately, replications are never perfect. Thus it will always ruin the expected experience.
Plus, this is just builds fake iOS interface. Be original, not Apple's bitch.