The author claims Orwell had plenty of evidence the conflict wasn't winnable, which means it's a waste of life to fight it. Also that collectivism would have produced a worse tyranny, and potentially endangered representative democracy in Western Europe, given Spain would have had close ties to Moscow.
The thesis of the article is that Orwell is admired so much by all political sides because of his contradictions. He was against fascism, but he also recognized totalitarian tendencies in communism. Thus the line about some animals being more equal than others in Animal Farm.
Instead Spain became a fascist power with close ties to Berlin. Hardly less of a threat to representative democracy. Spain was a dictatorship until 1970.
Collectivism might have also produced tyranny but it's not a good thing that a fascist won.
Re:All Is Orwell
by publicola1990 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:31PM
(#27281407)
But loss would have not been good for representative democracy either in Spain. People speak now as if Western Europe is some bastion of Democracy, Spain and Portugal were not within living memory.
Re:All Is Orwell
by ImprobableTruth on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @03:02PM
(#27280953)
Because a unified 'side of the common man' is an illusion. The article even explicitly mentions how Stalinist communists later on brutally suppressed the POUM, the group of communists Orwell served with, even though they were 'on the same side'.
Re:All Is Orwell
by shoemakersteve on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:51PM
(#27283190)
The Russian civil war after the 1917 revolutions had something like a dozen different socialist factions fighting each other. There's plenty to disagree about (to the point of going to war) even if you agree on "big picture" stuff.
> Why, then, did he determine that it was a fight worth fighting? Bravely, and at some cost to his health, he fought an unwinnable war for a unrealizable cause. But he still believed it was right to have fought and to have gone on encouraging others to continue doing so. Despite the mountains of evidence to the contrary, the issue, in his view, was simple: “Shall the common man be pushed back into the mud, or shall he not?”
> This explanation, entirely bereft of historical and cultural context, is bound to strike anyone half familiar with the history of the conflict as simplistic in the extreme, even simple-minded. Orwell wrote: “I myself believe, perhaps on insufficient grounds, that the common man will win his fight sooner or later . . . . That was the real issue of the Spanish war . . . and perhaps of other wars to come.”
I mean, it's fair to say that any one sentence summary of a war is going to be somewhat simplistic, but if one side has monarchists, fascists and military dictators on it, then it seems reasonable to me. Just the way the author writes it, I feel I should know of some alternative take that it seems like I don't.
What do the "mountains of evidence to the contrary" suggest (in this author's view)? Presumably something along the lines of fascism being better than risking communism, which seems to a strangely recurring historical motif.