News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inkscape 1.1 by cies on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:45AM (#27275654)
> it definitely needs to improve

Gimp is FreeSoftware (FLOSS), this puts the word "need" in a context where it does not really work like that.

> because Photoshop [in contrast to Gimp] has engineered their UX

This is straight up condescending to the Gimp devs. Sure PS has put more money in UX design, but your saying Gimp dev did not (or cannot) do any of that.

Please be kind when you get something for free.

Re:Inkscape 1.1 by schrute on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @05:50PM (#27283172)
> This is straight up condescending to the Gimp devs.

No, it isn't. There is literally years worth of user feedback and it still hasn't been addressed. It's a common complaint and to say they haven't "engineered" their UX is putting it lightly.

> Please be kind when you get something for free.

Something being free doesn't mean it can't be criticized. Nothing said was unkind.

Re:Inkscape 1.1 by snoopen on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:05AM (#27276295)
I read the criticism as fair and constructive, not condescending at all.
Re:Inkscape 1.1 by cies on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @02:04PM (#27280148)
Every UX is engineered. Maybe not by someone with a lot of experience in it. Maybe not by a team. Maybe not up to your standards. But it _is_ engineered. Basically, saying Gimp did not is not very nice then, especially know the engineer produce it for you for free.
Re:Inkscape 1.1 by spoiler on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @07:19PM (#27284039)
I didn't mean to sound condescending, and if I hurt any gimp devs, I'd like to apologise.

I... Partially agree with you that every UX is "engineered" but that depends on how far we're willing to stretch that definition in the design domain.

I'd hardly call any workflow I design an engineered one (even if I like this field), when compared to something produced by an UX designer (or a team of them) who specialises in the field. Maybe someone put a lot of thought into the gimp UX, but it seems like a wasted effort (or maybe it was just inexperience). I don't know how to phrase this without it sounding insensitive, though. I'm not criticising the people, just this instance of their work, so I hope it inspires them to improve. I'd like to see Gimp become as successful as krita or inkscape (which had UX issues for years, too)

I realise gimp is free, but there also seems to be a general attitude amongst gimp contributors that they think the UX is fine, while most people (in my circles, at least) disagree with that view

Re:Inkscape 1.1 by cies on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:59AM (#27287275)
I'm a little strict online when I find people just the slightest bit rude to FLOSS teams. It's hard enough doing all that for free. And for me it worked very well: i dont need to know PS, as I know Gimp.

Gratitude and praise it all I have for them. I only criticize in actual places where change is made (issues discussions, etc), and even then I try to be VERY polite.